Microsoft Edge and Aloha caught sharing precise user location data with third parties

submitted by

https://www.techradar.com/vpn/vpn-services/microsoft-edge-and-aloha-caught-sharing-precise-user-location-data-with-third-parties

24
430

Log in to comment

Hot Top New Old

  • A new Surfshark study found that over 50% of the top 15 mobile browsers collect user location data.

  • Microsoft Edge, Aloha, Yandex, and Phoenix collect precise location data, with Edge and Aloha openly sharing it with third parties.

  • Privacy-focused browsers like Tor, Brave, and DuckDuckGo do not collect app-level location data, proving that continuous tracking isn’t technically necessary.

proving that continuous tracking isn’t technically necessary

 reply
88

Weird omission of Firefox.

 reply
61
edited

That was OP, not the original post by rene

Four popular mobile browsers collect only your approximate location: Google Chrome, Apple Safari, Opera, and Mozilla Firefox.

privacy-branded browsers like DuckDuckGo, Brave, Tor, and Ecosia, alongside Samsung Internet, UC Browser, and Mi Browser

 reply
38

Never ever trust anything from Microsoft, Google, Amazon, Meta, X, TikTok for anything. Just don’t use their software.

 reply
52

Agreed.

Sent from my pixel phone. 💀

 reply
26

GrapheneOS 😎

 reply
18

How to buy from Google and still think you’re an anarchist😎

 reply
-4
edited

Got it second hand mate, google earned nothing from me.

EDIT: I am aware of the cognitive dissonance needed to be an anarchist under capitalism. The hypocrisy is everywhere. Children died for the minerals needed in the devices we’re typing these comments on.

 reply
13

Running Grapheneos right? Running Grapheneos right?

 reply
2

What really?

 reply
13

On the Internet?! C’mon get real! Next youre gonna tell me that picture of the woman touching her laptop screen and keyboard simultaneously is faked.

 reply
1

This is a marketing post.

 reply
24

It’s so lucky Surfshark have the answers!

 reply
13

Right? Their “study” seems to have been reading the Google App Store and disclosures 😂

 reply
5

It’s also completely wrong about the apps on iOS which have system level controls for approx and precise location.

 reply
2

“The developer states…” honestly I barely trust apple anymore. I miss the days of human app reviews and a curated App Store. Gay Grandpa has sold us out, Jobs was an abusive narcissistic sociopath but I still miss him.

 reply
3

It doesn’t matter if you trust the developer or not, that’s the whole point of the system-level controls for these things.

 reply
2

And you think you have that? Uber got around Apple’s control and then bribed their way back in… Apple’s basically telling you they’ve abdicated responsibility at this point.

 reply
1

That’s like “catching” a bird flying.

IT’S WHAT THEY DO. They don’t know anything else!

 reply
8
edited

On iOS Edge, and all other apps, have a precise location setting alongside the location settings, so is this only talking about Android?

You can choose to use approximate or precise location right in the settings:

If you have never selected it doesn’t even get your approximate location.

 reply
3

The article talks about safari as well, so this doesn’t seem to be solely an android problem.

From memory, Android has a similar location precision setting, but I switched to iOS 2 years ago so I’m a bit hazy on that.

Reading the article, it sounds like the issue is more about how your data is used if you give your browser access to your precise location. Even if that access is allowed, not all browsers are sharing it. Edge and Aloha seem to be the only two which say they share your precise location.

 reply
1

It’s just a poorly, or non-researched ad for a VPN basically.

If you give something location access, read what it uses it for. Pretty straight forward.

 reply
1
Insert image