Skip to content

Comment on China accuses US of 'fabricating' Nvidia spy claims to push tech 'blockade'

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • The problem with that, is China had to have been aware she was smuggling Nvidia chips out of Singapore thru her company…

    China holds a stake in every Chinese company, and it’s not just on paper, government officials get access to everything.

    Which is why the line between corpo spying and government spying is virtually non existent. Especially when the Chinese government doesn’t hold anyone accountable.

    0
    • This front has been known for over a year. You can find Reuters or the Guardian reporting on it.

      And while you are overstating Chinese corporate ownership(its more like having stakes in companies that compose 60% of their GDP, and a lot of that is concentrated in the commanding heights and the rest is often minority stakes through state linked investment firms), that sort of just makes any and everyone a “spy” for the CCP if that is the criteria.

      Which then sort of makes that designation functionally useless and taken to it’s logical conclusion would mean any romantic relationship with Chinese business leaders by Americans in positions of influence or power is fraternizing with a spy

      And from there what exactly is the allegation? Nvidia has a vested interest in wanting their products to be integral to AI everywhere. Including China. This is not a viewpoint Huang just established last year. It’s been his perspective from the jump, and part of a broader libertarian ethos.

      Frankly, I would be asking who benefits domestically for this becoming a zeitgeist moment right now given the only thing truly new is the second affair? Like who might benefit from pushing out a CEO that supports open-weight AI strategies favored by China and putting government pressure on the company to shift away from that business strategy?

      0
      • (its more like having stakes in companies that compose 60% of their GDP, and a lot of that is concentrated in the commanding heights and the rest is often minority stakes through state linked investment firms),

        Nope:

        The overarching goal was to weave the party “comprehensively” into the fabric of the economy’s private sector (Central Organization Department, 2012). Local authorities were directed to establish special agencies to support this goal and firms were requested to seek guidance from local party leaders on important managerial decisions. Further, governments were mandated to use firm-based party cells to advance party-related policy beyond the reach of formal state institutions. The service-oriented character of party organisation was also underlined in a Central Committee document from 2014. While mainly addressing party cells in public organisations, it stipulated that company-based party cells should assist corporate production and operation, and serve as the central mechanism for political leadership of a company’s development (政治引领, zhengzhi yinling) (General Office of the Central Committee, 2014).

        The 2012 central regulation was personally endorsed by Xi Jinping in several speeches (Xinhua, 2012). The intervention of the top party leadership contributed to a rapid increase in the percentage of private businesses with a party cell embedded in their organisation: from 21 per cent in 2010 to 73 per cent in 2017 (Koss, 2021: 229). Among China’s top 500 private companies, 92 per cent had established party cells by 2020 (Chinese Private Enterprise Survey, 2020). Nevertheless, implementation efforts encountered various challenges, including the lack of clear and specific guidelines, instances where business owners co-opted party organisations for their own benefit, and a significant number of inactive party cells (Yan and Huang, 2017).

        https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/18681026261445459

        They literally have to have government official embedded in their corporations

        0
        • @Nola@piefed.zip· · edited

          Yes, many, if not most companies inside their strategically defined industries(the commanding heights in particular) have party cadre in some capacity. I never disputed that

          It is not literally every company though.

          And furthermore your own citation hints at the next key point, what this functionally means and looks like varies and it’s functional relationship to the core CCP leadership is even more diffuse at times.

          The system is designed to ensure Chinese capitalism remains in it’s “birdcage” and key sectors will stay aligned with larger industrial policy. Yes, I am well aware of this.

          But again, the core point I was making is that that sort of criteria just makes any and everyone a “spy” for the CCP.

          Which then sort of makes that designation functionally useless and taken to it’s logical conclusion would mean any romantic relationship with Chinese business leaders by Americans in positions of influence or power is fraternizing with a spy.

          And so what then is the actual allegation? And why did it take a year to scandalize it?

          0
          • Local authorities were directed to establish special agencies to support this goal and firms were requested to seek guidance from local party leaders on important managerial decisions.

            0
            • @Nola@piefed.zip· · edited

              And?

              Do you have a point beyond dragging me along as you slowly educate yourself(poorly) about the Chinese party cadre system thru your reactionary lens?

              -1

Sign in to comment. Sign in