it appears that some members of the group decided to enter the construction site “with violence” anyway, forcing the police to intervene and leading to their arrest
Absolutely no evidence that the protest “turned violent”.
Entering a construction site is obviously not violence. Breaking in is not violence either. Even destroying it would not be violence. Violence happens to people.
I mean I agree that the phrasing is misleading as fuck because “turns violent” really feels like it indicates something more severe but violence is not a thing that only happens to people. Destroying a gate to enter somewhere is entering with violence.
Depends on the definition being used. According to the UN, violence is only used against a person, group, or communities. Nothing about physical objects.
I believe you might be misinterpreting that. It does explicitly mention “injury or damage”. And this makes sense, for example if someone destroys your home while you’re not in it, what is that if not violence harming a person (would the Reichspogromnacht have been non-violent it the nazis didn’t directly injure or murder any person? I think that’d be a ridiculous position).
That said, it also defines it as intending to cause harm, which wouldn’t really apply to forceful entry since it’s probably more of a means to an end.
There is no mention of damage in the UN’s definition of violence. Those would probably be included in a different category. Might be “property damage” or even in the worse case-scenario “genocide” depending on the intent.
Violence is a social phenomenon that involves forceful acts or behaviour that are intended to cause harm. The injury or damage inflicted by violence to an individual or collective group may be physical, psychological, sexual, or deprivation, or combined. Violence is both intentional and forceful
Words have meanings. You can’t just erase part of the meaning of a word to feed your narrative. Not that I even think said narrative is wrong in this case.
Comments
Absolutely no evidence that the protest “turned violent”. Entering a construction site is obviously not violence. Breaking in is not violence either. Even destroying it would not be violence. Violence happens to people.
I mean I agree that the phrasing is misleading as fuck because “turns violent” really feels like it indicates something more severe but violence is not a thing that only happens to people. Destroying a gate to enter somewhere is entering with violence.
That’s just property damage.
Depends on the definition being used. According to the UN, violence is only used against a person, group, or communities. Nothing about physical objects.
I believe you might be misinterpreting that. It does explicitly mention “injury or damage”. And this makes sense, for example if someone destroys your home while you’re not in it, what is that if not violence harming a person (would the Reichspogromnacht have been non-violent it the nazis didn’t directly injure or murder any person? I think that’d be a ridiculous position).
That said, it also defines it as intending to cause harm, which wouldn’t really apply to forceful entry since it’s probably more of a means to an end.
Headline is misleading either way but yea
This is still violence only because not having shelter harms a human.
Whereas destroying a decorative gazebo, for example, or a commercial construction site - that would just be property damage.
There is no mention of damage in the UN’s definition of violence. Those would probably be included in a different category. Might be “property damage” or even in the worse case-scenario “genocide” depending on the intent.
Not sure which definition you’re looking at.
https://www.undrr.org/understanding-disaster-risk/terminology/hips/so0301
Unless the UNDRR has a seperate definition from other parts of the UN but that seems weird
“Gate violence! Someone call the fascist paramilitary and arrest 200 people! Don’t forget to beat them and mistreat them like they are terrorists.”
Sure you’re just not a nazi? You sound like a nazi. Everyone’s downvoting you like you were a nazi. You even smell like a nazi.
Lmfao you’re delulu
Words have meanings. You can’t just erase part of the meaning of a word to feed your narrative. Not that I even think said narrative is wrong in this case.
Sign in to comment. Sign in