T-Mobile illegally imposed 50GB cap on low-income home Internet plan, NY says: Law requires 25Mbps home Internet. T-Mobile lowers speed to 600Kbps after 50GB cap.
We really need to mandate serious fines for companies that violate trust regulations, like 20% of the estimated annual profits (based on the previous five years) or 5% of the company’s valuation. You know, the way a traffic ticket is about a week’s pay.
If their contempt of law is recurring or particularly egregious, nationalize the fucker.
Companies should just be charged the fine multiplied by the number of offenses (like any individual being charged), then multiplied by the number of employees. Any amount over their available cash, becomes asset seizure (for “too critical to fail” companies) or make them go through bankruptcy to liquidate. Hell, you can even be nice and let them do a “payment plan” over a year or two, seizing all profit until the fine is paid in full. I bet companies would follow laws remarkably well if that were on the line.
The US would just be a couple Facebook privacy violations away from running a governmental surplus for the first time in decades!
Nah, then they just gut themselves into a series of subsidiaries and replace most of the workforce with “contractors”. Can’t seize profits either, too much accounting magic available to keep that from staying pennies a year. Hit them where it hurts; base fines on total revenue, and start arresting people on and conspiring with the board of directors.
It’s crazy that this isn’t being properly implemented (probably easier to say and talk about, but stil) because really hefty fines are the only way to stop companies from bullshitting their literal customers.
If there is one thing we know, than it is that companies will not stop at hurting people, the environment or fucking over their customers if it means they make a good profit off of it and can get away with it.
It’s literally a simple calculation for them, nothing more. Literally kill an entire ecosystem and risk poisoning tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of humans? No problem, as long as it pays off.
It cannot be a fixed ceiling - fixed floor, sure - but ceiling should be a percentage of market cap. It’s their responsibility to maximize shareholder profits - making it no longer in the best interest of the shareholders if they had to sell more shares to raise money to pay fines and dilute shareholder value
What we need to do is treat internet access as a public utility rather than a private commodity. That means removing control of the essential infrastructure from private corporations, establishing strong public oversight, and heavily regulating how internet services are delivered to consumers.
The infrastructure already exists to provide virtually every American with high-speed internet access without compromising network performance. The argument that universal, affordable, high-speed internet is somehow technologically or economically unfeasible is largely a matter of priorities and policy.
Look at much of Europe, where consumers have access to significantly more internet service providers competing for the same customer base. In the United States, depending on where you live, you might have two or three realistic options, often with little meaningful competition between them. Three major providers dominate much of the market, and somehow they have managed to make an essential service extraordinarily expensive while offering consumers remarkably little choice.
I don’t believe internet access should be something corporations get to hold hostage for profit. It is essential infrastructure in the modern world, and it should be treated accordingly.
utilities exist to serve the majority of the country, high speed internet only exists in the big cities which make up significantly less than 5% of the country.
Really? Something like 85% of the American population lives in or around metropolitan areas.
And let’s be realistic here: people who live out in the boonies don’t exactly have an abundance of utilities either. They have septic tanks and propane tanks. Some don’t even have electricity, although that’s increasingly uncommon.
It is not at all unreasonable to consider internet access a public utility.
I’m not even sure why I’m getting downvoted. It would benefit the entire population if internet access were treated as a utility rather than remaining under the control of three or four major corporations that effectively have a stranglehold on the market.
What’s particularly strange is that we’re supposedly all about socialism, equality, and equity. But the moment I suggest that internet access should be a utility, suddenly everyone has a problem with it.
I swear, the majority of people on Lemmy must be somewhere between 12 and 25 years old. There’s an awful lot of idealism and not nearly enough real-world perspective.
And even smaller towns have better internet than you’d think. I went to college in a town of ~5k people and the internet was fine, especially if you went with the local co-op internet. They were slightly more expensive but most years you’d get money back so it wasn’t really more expensive and the service was fantastic, sadly they were hard for the college students to use because they only offered yearly contracts unlike the big names.
ISPs should be better. But when you say ‘like utilities’ there’s been way too many for profit companies acting like local monopolies screwing people over too - look at Enron and now Xcel and CenterPoint trying to pass the cost of the Texas freeze to all of their customers all over the country because they lobbied for deregulation and Texas gave it to them. NONE of these companies should exist.
electric companies are also really annoying if you want three phase power at a residential address, I can see a utilityified ISP doing the same for anyone that doesn’t want to be behind CGNAT
Law requires 25Mbps home Internet. T-Mobile lowers speed to 600Kbps after 50GB cap.
I use TMobile and do Internet using tethered data from my phone. That’s MY cap… I’m doing fine every month for a couple of days until I hit 50GB, and then it’s 600Kbps for the rest of the month. It’s kind of miserable, but I can watch YouTube at 480p and I can play WoW. The minimum cost, with minimal phone service: ~ $80/month . And I’ve tried throwing money at TMobile but they don’t offer better service to PAYING customers, let alone their charity cases.
Americans are ignorant and utterly obsessed with laissez-faire capitalism
The oligarchs are. The patriots I’ve met all understand that capitalism requires guardrails and protections. It’s similar to democracy that way, actually.
T-Mobile had a similar subscription in the Netherlands for mobile internet: you got a certain amount of GB with normal bandwidth, when you reached that quota, your bandwidth got limited to 400kbps (but unlimited amount of data).
You can still watch YouTube at 600Kbs, at 480p. I know because I’m a paying customer of TMobile, and I get capped at that every month, after about three days of sweetness.
Calling it affordable broadband while throttling people to 600 Kbps after 50 GB is like selling a discounted bus pass that turns into a pair of shoes after four rides. And hiding the plan from search engines? Apparently the cheapest way to provide low income internet is making sure nobody can find it.
Artificial static throughput caps on modern networks are asinine and archaic, especially on shared mediums.
Network providers should permit shared best effort throughput, with a sliding temporal window which keeps a tally of usage and feeds into a ratcheting deprioritisation of slot allocations. This would permit short bursts of maximum throughput, which is more efficient and frees the channel quicker, and slots longer transfers into the remaining default channel space.
Differentiate service based on the dimensions of the monitored and enforced windows, not an arbitrary static sphincter.
Technically under the most private way of doing things we could just lump all traffic from a geographical area into one and not let them know who is who. So then they wouldn’t even know how much bandwidth you used. They also wouldn’t be able to do seperate “plans” it would just be you paying a flat rate for access to the same internet connection everyone else uses.
I’m not sure if that would be the most equitable solution either as what would prevent Netflix or YouTube from setting their servers up in your geographical region and consuming all your bandwidth for their own profit while only paying the same rate that you do? It could also be challenging for rural regions as they’ll have a lot fewer people sharing the cost of the infrastructure over a large area.
I don’t think you understood what I meant by geographical area. I’m talking like a neighborhood. I imagine people would notice a data center next door.
This is exactly why I refuse to even consider those silly hot spot cellular based services for your home. They spend decades capping and throttling that shit. There is no trust there.
I tried to use one for a month when I cancelled Comcast. They’re garbage. For home internet, you need it to always work. Having no internet is unacceptable, especially if you work from home. Well, the cellular hotspot services go back and forth between having signal and not having signal, so the internet is routinely not working.
Internet speeds being measured in bits instead of bytes is absolutely not to falsely represent Internet speeds, nor is there anything false about it to begin with. Measuring network transmission speeds in bits is an engineering custom used in telecommunications long before consumer internet existed and for good reason. A byte being 8 bits is the standard today, but in the past a computers byte could be anywhere from 1 to 48 bits depending on your hardware, therefore measuring internet speeds in bytes per second would be meaningless.
Even today where we’ve standardized 8 bits to a byte, measuring internet speeds in Bytes or Megabytes per second would actually be more misleading than the Megabits we use today, since not every bit in a packet is used for user data transfer nor is there even user data in every packet. 25 megabits per second is equal in size to 3.125 megabytes per second, but if you put 3.125 megabytes per second on the tin, people will expect for example to be able to download a file at 3.125 megabytes per second but they can’t. Assuming no bottlenecks and perfect efficiently, they’d only be able to download a file at a speed closer to 2.5Megabytes per second.
There are good reasons to use bits for engineers, but residential internet consumers are not engineers. In no other context do you market incomprehensible engineering details, just here because higher number is better marketing. Almost everyone I know is confused why the speeds they pay for don’t match the speed of downloads in Chrome. Marketing in bits is anti-consumer, since average consumer does not understand what actual download speed they will get when buying.
Marketing in bits is anti-consumer, since average consumer does not understand what actual download speed they will get when buying.
It’s not anti-consumer to advertise a product’s capabilities in the most accurate way possible. When you pay for internet bandwidth you’re not paying for download speed, you’re paying for a transmission rate. Advertising internet plans based on the speeds you get in Chrome would not be possible and therefore any attempt to do so would be deceptive to the customer.
Almost everyone I know is confused why the speeds they pay for don’t match the speed of downloads in Chrome
The Internet bandwidth they pay for will never match the speed of downloads in Chrome, even if you convert bits to bytes.
What you’re missing here is that you want the number you pay for from your ISP and the number you can measure downloading a file at to match. But they never will, because they’re two completely different concepts. One of those number is a constituent part of the other number. They’re not interchangeable.
Governor Kathy Hochul and New York Attorney General Letitia James today announced an agreement with T-Mobile USA, Inc. (T-Mobile), requiring the company to improve and expand the home internet service it offers eligible New Yorkers under the New York Affordable Broadband Act (ABA).
As a result of OAG’s investigation, T-Mobile will remove the data caps associated with its ABA plans and deliver 25 Mbps download speeds to all ABA plan subscribers, unless network congestion requires temporary reductions. In addition, T-Mobile will offer ABA plans in all areas where it provides home internet service and make its ABA plan webpage discoverable by search engines.
WHERE’S THE MOTHERFUCKING PUNISHMENT?! All I see is where they’re making T-mobile pinky-promise to start following the law they’ve been breaking all this time, while being allowed to keep every single goddamn penny of their ill-gotten gains!
NO mention of prison time for executives.
NO mention of punitive fines.
NO mention even of restitution to wronged customers, which is less than the bare fucking minimum!!!
The only even slightly useful part of that press release is this at the bottom, because every New Yorker should be absolutely livid about this weak-ass corporatist shit:
Contact the Governor’s Press Office
Contact us by phone:
Albany: (518) 474-8418
New York City: (212) 681-4640
Any punishment to the company will be paid by it’s customers anyway… For any large company fines and legal fees are calculated in as a cost of doing business. Prison for execs will just lead to fall guys getting the job while the real beneficiaries i.e. major stakeholders will pull the string from the shadows. If you want this to stop you have to go after them. Something like community service or % of their stock holdings going to the victims would be more effective imo.
Edit: You may not like what i’m saying but deep down you know i’m right.
True. However, fining them will impact their profits, which impacts the valuation of the company and their competitiveness (due to needing to charge their customers higher prices as you mentioned, compared to their competitors), and both will hit the pockets of the shareholders. The only thing that needs to be kept in mind is that breaking the law should not increase profits more than the punishment would decrease it, so netto it should impact their profits.
And morally it is justified to compensate the victims.
In theory sure, but in practice there are ways a company can offload this burden onto the consumers with minimal impact to their bottom line, like raising prices in an area where there isn’t any competition. Hurting the competitiveness of a major player will likely negatively impact the whole market because it will allow their competition to charge more as well. Most likely it won’t impact large shareholders whose portfolio is diversified enough, as they can own stake in all players on the market simultaneously, it might even be good for them; less competitive market -> higher margins, shareholders with equal stake in T-Mobile, Verizon, AT&T win regardless of any one company’s performance.
I don’t get it, how do they know it’s illegal? Every time I hear about politicians performing legally dubious acts, our legal system is apparently a huge fucking mystery, and no one seems to know what our laws are, and if the acts really break any of them.
In my country it is a normal practice that internet providers start fucking your connection up so you move to a different plan. Faking that the connection is failing, limiting downstream…
work your job all day to help some ass hole boss get rich, come home to relax and your internet gets secretly slowed down - so your bosses kids can also own you online in literally any multiplayer FPS.
Starlink is objectively a fucking terrible thing, possibly worse than data centers.
Rural connectivity is a good thing, but why do we all pretend it’s cheaper to invent a private space company to launch disposable satellites that burn up into toxic byproducts and need to be refilled every few months so that the sky internet can be controlled and monitored by the same people that want machines to automate all the labor so they can let us die because they hate having to deal with us?
Starlink ruins the night sky at scale, wastes a massive amount of resources to launch, and requires continuous replacement. In limited usage it is pretty good, but as the intended full replacement of glocbal networks as a whole that it was deaigned to be it is horrible.
It has its uses, but that doesn’t mean that the FCC should continue to give Musk’s company rural internet grants. Those should go to local fiber PUDs. Musk can fund it on his own.
It also means that you are supporting Musk when you use it, even if it’s the best option. It’s important to remember that.
As a former subscriber to both T-Mobile’s fixed wireless home internet and their subsidiary Mint Mobile’s fixed wireless home internet, this explains a lot.
Oh, Mint Mobile, as in “for just $15 a month” Mint Mobile?
I’m irrationally angry about Mint Mobile. They lean so heavily on the message that they’re cheaper than everybody else, and it is some of the most cynical, anti-consumer bullshit I’ve ever heard. You barely have to look into it at all before you see that offer is
only valid for the first three months, and
only for new users. On top of all that,
those first three months are gonna cost you more than the advertised $15 because of hidden fees.
Outside of those first 3 months, they’re charging at least as much per month as most off-contract providers.
And I understand that none of the above is unique to Mint Mobile. I guess it’s Ryan Reynolds’ smarmy delivery in their ads that makes it seem so arrogant, like, “Yeah, I’m already rich, and I’m getting richer by lying to you about a cellphone contract, what are you gonna do about it? I’m Deadpool, just buy it, you idiots!”
I signed up for Mint Mobile’s fixed home wireless service because I’d had such a great experience with their phone service. I’ve used their phone service for a long time, and it’s been rock solid.
It’s really weird, but their mobile service is fantastic. Their fixed home wireles service was absolutely awful. There’s literally no reason why it should have been bad, but I prepaid for three months of their fixed home wireless, and switched to a different provider very soon after signing up. Their mobile service is still very good, and absolutely worth it. It literally is $360 per year. One payment, once a year, unlimited. Works well.
I was completely baffled why their fixed wireless was so bad.
Comments
We really need to mandate serious fines for companies that violate trust regulations, like 20% of the estimated annual profits (based on the previous five years) or 5% of the company’s valuation. You know, the way a traffic ticket is about a week’s pay.
If their contempt of law is recurring or particularly egregious, nationalize the fucker.
Ceo’s in orange jumpsuits.
Yeah, unfortunately this is the only real way to force companies to remain ethical. But also, this would only encourage companies to set up a patsy.
[deleted]
Companies should just be charged the fine multiplied by the number of offenses (like any individual being charged), then multiplied by the number of employees. Any amount over their available cash, becomes asset seizure (for “too critical to fail” companies) or make them go through bankruptcy to liquidate. Hell, you can even be nice and let them do a “payment plan” over a year or two, seizing all profit until the fine is paid in full. I bet companies would follow laws remarkably well if that were on the line.
The US would just be a couple Facebook privacy violations away from running a governmental surplus for the first time in decades!
Nah, then they just gut themselves into a series of subsidiaries and replace most of the workforce with “contractors”. Can’t seize profits either, too much accounting magic available to keep that from staying pennies a year. Hit them where it hurts; base fines on total revenue, and start arresting people on and conspiring with the board of directors.
It’s crazy that this isn’t being properly implemented (probably easier to say and talk about, but stil) because really hefty fines are the only way to stop companies from bullshitting their literal customers.
If there is one thing we know, than it is that companies will not stop at hurting people, the environment or fucking over their customers if it means they make a good profit off of it and can get away with it. It’s literally a simple calculation for them, nothing more. Literally kill an entire ecosystem and risk poisoning tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of humans? No problem, as long as it pays off.
It cannot be a fixed ceiling - fixed floor, sure - but ceiling should be a percentage of market cap. It’s their responsibility to maximize shareholder profits - making it no longer in the best interest of the shareholders if they had to sell more shares to raise money to pay fines and dilute shareholder value
What we need to do is treat internet access as a public utility rather than a private commodity. That means removing control of the essential infrastructure from private corporations, establishing strong public oversight, and heavily regulating how internet services are delivered to consumers.
The infrastructure already exists to provide virtually every American with high-speed internet access without compromising network performance. The argument that universal, affordable, high-speed internet is somehow technologically or economically unfeasible is largely a matter of priorities and policy.
Look at much of Europe, where consumers have access to significantly more internet service providers competing for the same customer base. In the United States, depending on where you live, you might have two or three realistic options, often with little meaningful competition between them. Three major providers dominate much of the market, and somehow they have managed to make an essential service extraordinarily expensive while offering consumers remarkably little choice.
I don’t believe internet access should be something corporations get to hold hostage for profit. It is essential infrastructure in the modern world, and it should be treated accordingly.
utilities exist to serve the majority of the country, high speed internet only exists in the big cities which make up significantly less than 5% of the country.
Really? Something like 85% of the American population lives in or around metropolitan areas.
And let’s be realistic here: people who live out in the boonies don’t exactly have an abundance of utilities either. They have septic tanks and propane tanks. Some don’t even have electricity, although that’s increasingly uncommon.
It is not at all unreasonable to consider internet access a public utility.
I’m not even sure why I’m getting downvoted. It would benefit the entire population if internet access were treated as a utility rather than remaining under the control of three or four major corporations that effectively have a stranglehold on the market.
What’s particularly strange is that we’re supposedly all about socialism, equality, and equity. But the moment I suggest that internet access should be a utility, suddenly everyone has a problem with it.
I swear, the majority of people on Lemmy must be somewhere between 12 and 25 years old. There’s an awful lot of idealism and not nearly enough real-world perspective.
Lemmy really is a strange freaking place.
And even smaller towns have better internet than you’d think. I went to college in a town of ~5k people and the internet was fine, especially if you went with the local co-op internet. They were slightly more expensive but most years you’d get money back so it wasn’t really more expensive and the service was fantastic, sadly they were hard for the college students to use because they only offered yearly contracts unlike the big names.
ISPs should be better. But when you say ‘like utilities’ there’s been way too many for profit companies acting like local monopolies screwing people over too - look at Enron and now Xcel and CenterPoint trying to pass the cost of the Texas freeze to all of their customers all over the country because they lobbied for deregulation and Texas gave it to them. NONE of these companies should exist.
electric companies are also really annoying if you want three phase power at a residential address, I can see a utilityified ISP doing the same for anyone that doesn’t want to be behind CGNAT
I use TMobile and do Internet using tethered data from my phone. That’s MY cap… I’m doing fine every month for a couple of days until I hit 50GB, and then it’s 600Kbps for the rest of the month. It’s kind of miserable, but I can watch YouTube at 480p and I can play WoW. The minimum cost, with minimal phone service: ~ $80/month . And I’ve tried throwing money at TMobile but they don’t offer better service to PAYING customers, let alone their charity cases.
Honestly maybe Tmoblile should trust busted and fined hundreds of billions of dollars
[deleted]
US is a weird country.
I live in EU, and I haven’t even heard of bandwidth quotas on home fiber. Cheap mobile subscriptions have some, though. But mostly it’s just no limit.
It used to be that way in the U.S. but Americans love companies extracting rent at the same time the public is subsidising them.
Americans are ignorant and utterly obsessed with laissez-faire capitalism
The oligarchs are. The patriots I’ve met all understand that capitalism requires guardrails and protections. It’s similar to democracy that way, actually.
You mean data quotas, bandwidth is what is capped.
T-Mobile had a similar subscription in the Netherlands for mobile internet: you got a certain amount of GB with normal bandwidth, when you reached that quota, your bandwidth got limited to 400kbps (but unlimited amount of data).
Not for home internet though.
You can still watch YouTube at 600Kbs, at 480p. I know because I’m a paying customer of TMobile, and I get capped at that every month, after about three days of sweetness.
Calling it affordable broadband while throttling people to 600 Kbps after 50 GB is like selling a discounted bus pass that turns into a pair of shoes after four rides. And hiding the plan from search engines? Apparently the cheapest way to provide low income internet is making sure nobody can find it.
isn’t is basically just a phone plan without a number?
Thats what all cellular plans are these days, an internet connection.
yeah, but cellular data is usually limited in the USA
This why regulation is good
Municipal Broadband would be nice to have.
So they broke the law, so somebody there who signed off on this will be going to jail, right?
Right?
Artificial static throughput caps on modern networks are asinine and archaic, especially on shared mediums.
Network providers should permit shared best effort throughput, with a sliding temporal window which keeps a tally of usage and feeds into a ratcheting deprioritisation of slot allocations. This would permit short bursts of maximum throughput, which is more efficient and frees the channel quicker, and slots longer transfers into the remaining default channel space.
Differentiate service based on the dimensions of the monitored and enforced windows, not an arbitrary static sphincter.
Yeah but how are we going to exploit the poors with a system that works?
How would you explain that in a simple way people can understanding?
Small data really fast, big data slow
This is one reason why privacy is important, companies knowing your info directly impacts your wallet.
This particular one has nothing to do with privacy. They have to offer a specific type of plan by law, they nerfed that plan.
Which is not to say corporations knowing everything about you is good in any way, but this is simply a different issue (with corporations)
Agreed. Whether they can see your traffic or not, they can still determine how much bandwidth you’re using and what plan you’re using.
Technically under the most private way of doing things we could just lump all traffic from a geographical area into one and not let them know who is who. So then they wouldn’t even know how much bandwidth you used. They also wouldn’t be able to do seperate “plans” it would just be you paying a flat rate for access to the same internet connection everyone else uses.
I’m not sure if that would be the most equitable solution either as what would prevent Netflix or YouTube from setting their servers up in your geographical region and consuming all your bandwidth for their own profit while only paying the same rate that you do? It could also be challenging for rural regions as they’ll have a lot fewer people sharing the cost of the infrastructure over a large area.
I don’t think you understood what I meant by geographical area. I’m talking like a neighborhood. I imagine people would notice a data center next door.
This is exactly why I refuse to even consider those silly hot spot cellular based services for your home. They spend decades capping and throttling that shit. There is no trust there.
I tried to use one for a month when I cancelled Comcast. They’re garbage. For home internet, you need it to always work. Having no internet is unacceptable, especially if you work from home. Well, the cellular hotspot services go back and forth between having signal and not having signal, so the internet is routinely not working.
50 GB? That’s a couple iOS or other OS update, or just streaming video a lot. A quick check shows my house over 500GB last month.
Gonna ration data with the same ethos they restrict what people on food stamps can purchase.
It’s 30 mins at full speed.
It’s around 4.5 hours at full speed. Remember that internet speeds are in megabits, not megabytes to falsely increase the speed number as well.
Internet speeds being measured in bits instead of bytes is absolutely not to falsely represent Internet speeds, nor is there anything false about it to begin with. Measuring network transmission speeds in bits is an engineering custom used in telecommunications long before consumer internet existed and for good reason. A byte being 8 bits is the standard today, but in the past a computers byte could be anywhere from 1 to 48 bits depending on your hardware, therefore measuring internet speeds in bytes per second would be meaningless.
Even today where we’ve standardized 8 bits to a byte, measuring internet speeds in Bytes or Megabytes per second would actually be more misleading than the Megabits we use today, since not every bit in a packet is used for user data transfer nor is there even user data in every packet. 25 megabits per second is equal in size to 3.125 megabytes per second, but if you put 3.125 megabytes per second on the tin, people will expect for example to be able to download a file at 3.125 megabytes per second but they can’t. Assuming no bottlenecks and perfect efficiently, they’d only be able to download a file at a speed closer to 2.5Megabytes per second.
There are good reasons to use bits for engineers, but residential internet consumers are not engineers. In no other context do you market incomprehensible engineering details, just here because higher number is better marketing. Almost everyone I know is confused why the speeds they pay for don’t match the speed of downloads in Chrome. Marketing in bits is anti-consumer, since average consumer does not understand what actual download speed they will get when buying.
It’s not anti-consumer to advertise a product’s capabilities in the most accurate way possible. When you pay for internet bandwidth you’re not paying for download speed, you’re paying for a transmission rate. Advertising internet plans based on the speeds you get in Chrome would not be possible and therefore any attempt to do so would be deceptive to the customer.
The Internet bandwidth they pay for will never match the speed of downloads in Chrome, even if you convert bits to bytes.
What you’re missing here is that you want the number you pay for from your ISP and the number you can measure downloading a file at to match. But they never will, because they’re two completely different concepts. One of those number is a constituent part of the other number. They’re not interchangeable.
From the linked press release:
WHERE’S THE MOTHERFUCKING PUNISHMENT?! All I see is where they’re making T-mobile pinky-promise to start following the law they’ve been breaking all this time, while being allowed to keep every single goddamn penny of their ill-gotten gains!
NO mention of prison time for executives.
NO mention of punitive fines.
NO mention even of restitution to wronged customers, which is less than the bare fucking minimum!!!
The only even slightly useful part of that press release is this at the bottom, because every New Yorker should be absolutely livid about this weak-ass corporatist shit:
Contact the Governor’s Press Office
Contact us by phone:
Albany: (518) 474-8418
New York City: (212) 681-4640
Contact us by email:
Press.Office@exec.ny.gov
What do you mean? Low-income consumers who feel they were wronged have the right to fair compensation through forced arbitration.
(Tonge firmly in-cheek, if not obvious)
Any punishment to the company will be paid by it’s customers anyway… For any large company fines and legal fees are calculated in as a cost of doing business. Prison for execs will just lead to fall guys getting the job while the real beneficiaries i.e. major stakeholders will pull the string from the shadows. If you want this to stop you have to go after them. Something like community service or % of their stock holdings going to the victims would be more effective imo.
Edit: You may not like what i’m saying but deep down you know i’m right.
True. However, fining them will impact their profits, which impacts the valuation of the company and their competitiveness (due to needing to charge their customers higher prices as you mentioned, compared to their competitors), and both will hit the pockets of the shareholders. The only thing that needs to be kept in mind is that breaking the law should not increase profits more than the punishment would decrease it, so netto it should impact their profits.
And morally it is justified to compensate the victims.
In theory sure, but in practice there are ways a company can offload this burden onto the consumers with minimal impact to their bottom line, like raising prices in an area where there isn’t any competition. Hurting the competitiveness of a major player will likely negatively impact the whole market because it will allow their competition to charge more as well. Most likely it won’t impact large shareholders whose portfolio is diversified enough, as they can own stake in all players on the market simultaneously, it might even be good for them; less competitive market -> higher margins, shareholders with equal stake in T-Mobile, Verizon, AT&T win regardless of any one company’s performance.
I wonder if the low income people could get the maximum payout if they brought it to small claims?
I don’t get it, how do they know it’s illegal? Every time I hear about politicians performing legally dubious acts, our legal system is apparently a huge fucking mystery, and no one seems to know what our laws are, and if the acts really break any of them.
I wonder if this comes from phasing out 3G.
greedy mf’s, they don’t give a shit about their customers
In my country it is a normal practice that internet providers start fucking your connection up so you move to a different plan. Faking that the connection is failing, limiting downstream…
There is a reason they call themselves the uncarrier
Because they Uncare?
ISPs doing dirty tactics, what else is new?
The same companies who display in the open “up to” on all of their plans. Their speeds are never guaranteed.
work your job all day to help some ass hole boss get rich, come home to relax and your internet gets secretly slowed down - so your bosses kids can also own you online in literally any multiplayer FPS.
Remember that T-Mobile officially supported Starlink. Thus, it is a technofascist company that openly supports genocide.
Seconding the other person. Musk sucks but Starlink is objectively a good thing.
Starlink is objectively a fucking terrible thing, possibly worse than data centers.
Rural connectivity is a good thing, but why do we all pretend it’s cheaper to invent a private space company to launch disposable satellites that burn up into toxic byproducts and need to be refilled every few months so that the sky internet can be controlled and monitored by the same people that want machines to automate all the labor so they can let us die because they hate having to deal with us?
We should run fiber to every home and business.
Starlink ruins the night sky at scale, wastes a massive amount of resources to launch, and requires continuous replacement. In limited usage it is pretty good, but as the intended full replacement of glocbal networks as a whole that it was deaigned to be it is horrible.
It has its uses, but that doesn’t mean that the FCC should continue to give Musk’s company rural internet grants. Those should go to local fiber PUDs. Musk can fund it on his own.
It also means that you are supporting Musk when you use it, even if it’s the best option. It’s important to remember that.
Remember that Starlink is used in Ukraine as well as on a lot of wildfire and earthquake sites. The deduction here is a bit too rushed.
Used in Ukraine except for when Musk turns it off when Putie-beautie phones him for a favour.
As a former subscriber to both T-Mobile’s fixed wireless home internet and their subsidiary Mint Mobile’s fixed wireless home internet, this explains a lot.
Oh, Mint Mobile, as in “for just $15 a month” Mint Mobile?
I’m irrationally angry about Mint Mobile. They lean so heavily on the message that they’re cheaper than everybody else, and it is some of the most cynical, anti-consumer bullshit I’ve ever heard. You barely have to look into it at all before you see that offer is
Outside of those first 3 months, they’re charging at least as much per month as most off-contract providers.
And I understand that none of the above is unique to Mint Mobile. I guess it’s Ryan Reynolds’ smarmy delivery in their ads that makes it seem so arrogant, like, “Yeah, I’m already rich, and I’m getting richer by lying to you about a cellphone contract, what are you gonna do about it? I’m Deadpool, just buy it, you idiots!”
Fuck Mint Mobile. And Ryan Reynolds, too.
I’m going to be completely serious here:
I signed up for Mint Mobile’s fixed home wireless service because I’d had such a great experience with their phone service. I’ve used their phone service for a long time, and it’s been rock solid.
It’s really weird, but their mobile service is fantastic. Their fixed home wireles service was absolutely awful. There’s literally no reason why it should have been bad, but I prepaid for three months of their fixed home wireless, and switched to a different provider very soon after signing up. Their mobile service is still very good, and absolutely worth it. It literally is $360 per year. One payment, once a year, unlimited. Works well.
I was completely baffled why their fixed wireless was so bad.
Sign in to comment. Sign in