Skip to content

Comment on Democrats need to fix these three weaknesses before 2028 | Dustin Guastella

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Also throwing cash at young families, isn’t an answer. A one time check isn’t going to help anyone, they need sustained community support, reasonable and consistent work hours, safe and consistent housing that isn’t getting sold out from under them every other year and rents that don’t double every 6 months.

    You can’t raise a family in a perpetual crisis. Everyone misses the one thing that makes life so much more difficult now for young families. Inconsistency. No one can lay down roots or raise a family when everything is in a state of constant disruption. Even in some of the most desperate eras of the past, you could be reasonably certain most of the things that were true when you were 20, would still be how things worked when you were 65. You can’t get a home loan when you’re pulling in 6 figures one year, and then homeless the next. You can’t pick a college major or a trade when entire industries are disappearing randomly. People are people, not fungible assets. Expertise, family, and community take time and work. Prices skyrocketing is a big part of the problem too, but it’s really just one part of a bigger problem.

    7
    • You donʻt wait to control bleeding to give fluids in the ER. Its almost always a “both and” response.

      6
      • Look, no one is going to say no to a check. You can’t let them starve to death while you’re cooking up a banquet, but under no circumstances should we consider that “doing something.”

        1
        • but under no circumstances should we consider that “doing something.”

          This is incredibly fucking stupid, and deeply toxic.

          Putting money into peoples pockets is literally doing not just something, but the actual thing.

          See: COVID payments, Child Tax Credit, Social security.

          And on the other side see: 2008/9 bank bailouts, the foreclosure crisis, and on and on…

          Fucking miss me with this heritage fucking society fucking bootstraps bullshit. If we want people out of poverty, make direct payments to poor people so they donʻt have to live in poverty. Its simple as.

          This neoliberalism/ neoconservatism needs to be kicked to the curb.

          3
          • You can keep downvoting me, but you know I’m right. What we need is systemic overhaul and that includes effective support systems. I’m not a neoliberal, I’m more socialist than you are likely. I’m saying you don’t fix this with a bandaid. We need reform that prioritizes the working class and a promise of stability. We need medicaid for all because it decouples healthcare from work and creates stability for people. We need community housing and public options that put pressure on rent seekers to control costs and create circumstances where people can settle for 20 years without having to worry if they’re going to be homeless next month for reasons completely outside their control. We need support for community institutions; libraries, youth groups, and social spaces. We need controls on worker exploitation and wage theft, and limits on time-abuse to give people the opportunity to USE those public institutions, and consequences with teeth for corruption.

            And yes, direct support to those who need it is going to be a part of it, but it’s not a cure-all.

            1
            • No, you are NOT fucking right and you aren’t addressing my principal point. UBI or any other thing that outs money into people’s hands right now isn’t just a solution for right now, it’s also fundemental to those issues down the line.

              It’s also fundemental to Democrats building a bigger majority in 2028, in that they need to do something right now to make a palpable, sensible, difference in people’s lives they can feel right now

              0
              Continue this thread 9 more replies
          • They’re not going to make regular payments, they’re going to try a one time check and pretend that fixes things. A real consistent program to support young people isn’t even on the table and you know that.

            -1

Sign in to comment. Sign in