Well if they sell to the military, they get involved yes. But it is not calculated on paper, so let’s cut the whataboutism and stay with the fact that they directly sell to the military to build weapon systems.
It’s not “whataboutism” to draw logical parallels when making a point.
I agree its a GPU can be a component in a weapon system. I don’t think that makes it arms, and saying it does is a marketing strategy the big AI firms are pushing to make their software sound more capable than it actually is.
“Soldiers dont shoot people, their guns do” energy.
The gpu sits somewhere in the middle. Command gives an order, Soldiers press the
Buttons, the hardware calculated the target,the computer script fires when the target is locked in.
And their now looking to eliminate the soldiers to fully automize the process and get rid of pesky individual morals.
Soon enough war will be ai fighting ai and humans just collateral.
That’s hardly the point I’m making. If a GPU is “armaments”, then you might as well call an envelope with sealed orders “arms” as well. The road an army convoy drives down is “arms” now too. Air is arms. Can’t fight if you can’t breath. Stands to reason.
I get your point, were not trying to villify gpus as some immoral technology.
But an envelop does not enable people more then if they didnt have an envelop.
High end gpus are required to build advanced ai systems which wreck destructions much faster and eassier then ever before.
A real world analog is fertilizer, many of those are under tight laws and restrictions because they can be used to make explosives.
Where i live farmer communities can get the large amounts of fertilizer they need, but mandatory need to call police if a stranger suddenly comes ask to buy large quantaties.
Dont get me wrong, i dont want customers to not be allowed to buy a gpus for legit usecases but their is a logical argumt to restrict them in large quantaties.
Comments
Arms are used to kill people. How do you kill someone with graphing hardware?
They sharpen pretty well
Hitting someone in the head with a 5090 can do serious damage.
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/e8677e30-e1ef-4a8b-8329-77973e60c889.jpeg
You calculate where the bombs go
You can do that with pen and paper too. Is Office Depot an arms dealer now?
Well if they sell to the military, they get involved yes. But it is not calculated on paper, so let’s cut the whataboutism and stay with the fact that they directly sell to the military to build weapon systems.
It’s not “whataboutism” to draw logical parallels when making a point.
I agree its a GPU can be a component in a weapon system. I don’t think that makes it arms, and saying it does is a marketing strategy the big AI firms are pushing to make their software sound more capable than it actually is.
They have been calculating where the bombs go for a longer time than LLMs exists.
“Soldiers dont shoot people, their guns do” energy.
The gpu sits somewhere in the middle. Command gives an order, Soldiers press the Buttons, the hardware calculated the target,the computer script fires when the target is locked in.
And their now looking to eliminate the soldiers to fully automize the process and get rid of pesky individual morals.
Soon enough war will be ai fighting ai and humans just collateral.
That’s hardly the point I’m making. If a GPU is “armaments”, then you might as well call an envelope with sealed orders “arms” as well. The road an army convoy drives down is “arms” now too. Air is arms. Can’t fight if you can’t breath. Stands to reason.
I get your point, were not trying to villify gpus as some immoral technology.
But an envelop does not enable people more then if they didnt have an envelop.
High end gpus are required to build advanced ai systems which wreck destructions much faster and eassier then ever before.
A real world analog is fertilizer, many of those are under tight laws and restrictions because they can be used to make explosives.
Where i live farmer communities can get the large amounts of fertilizer they need, but mandatory need to call police if a stranger suddenly comes ask to buy large quantaties.
Dont get me wrong, i dont want customers to not be allowed to buy a gpus for legit usecases but their is a logical argumt to restrict them in large quantaties.
Ask a college student.
Sign in to comment. Sign in