Yes. Space is big. Very big. People vastly underestimate how much room there is even in LEO. We haven’t even scratched the surface of how much we can put up there; and in LEO, Kessler syndrome is not really an issue. It will be decades, if not centuries, before the number of satellites becomes a real issue.
Let’s try to put a little perspective on this. Currently, there are ~20,000 satellites in orbit. Seems like a big scary number. But let’s actually think about this. Imagine if there were only 20,000 cars on the road across the entire US, or the EU if that’s easier to think about. 20,000. Across ALL the roads. It would probably feel pretty empty right?
Well, most satellites are smaller than cars and the amount of available space in orbit is exponentially greater than the amount of space on all roads. Literally not a problem.
But you’re wrong. Because you seem to think that “too many” is only a matter of
when collisions start to occur, but that’s a completely arbitrary threshold. The fact is that the huge increase in number of satellites in orbit, compared to before Starlink, is having a significant detrimental effect on the ability of telescopes to gather data for astronomy. They are indeed a “star shield”, because they’re shielding us from properly being able to see and study the stars. They make our collective horizon smaller.
I knew this argument was coming. Satellites showing up in telescopes is essentially a non problem. Ever since astrophotography switched to digital, we have easily been able to filter out satellites and airplanes (which are a much bigger nuisance btw). You get the occasional article or post that has a picture of what happens when you take a super long exposure and DONT filter out the satellite/plane streaks, and it’s used as click bait going “See!? Look at what our hubris of launching satellites has brought! You should be mad! You should be afraid! You should be afraid AND mad!”
Now, to be fair, when trying to look at EXTREMELY distant or faint objects, satellites do start being a problem; but those kinds of observations are difficult even with clear skies, that’s why we have space-based telescopes like Hubble and the JWST. But those are edge cases. For the vast majority of ground-based star gazing, it’s been a solved problem for a long time now.
@Malyca@Mihies There should be international consensus on the number of satellites allowed globally at Starlink altitudes, per country. If there is oversaturation by any one country, the excess should be shot down. 🤷
Like US or any other bigger country would agree. But yes, how is a foreign country launching satellites in low orbit all over other countries is beyond me. Why EU keeps silent…
Maybe actually informing oneself before posting stuff like that? Ariane 6 is perfectly capable of launching a strategic satellite communication network. Will the launching itself cost a bit more? Likely but the extra launch costs are wildly exaggerated. Which is exactly why the EU is creating such a satellite network as we speak. The network should become operational in 2029/2030. In the meanwhile there is a gap solution of GOVSATCOM which started this year. We can of course debate till eternity how that is too late but decision makers have woken up at least in the aftermath of the 2nd Ukraine invasion in 2022.
Now if we had listened to those that were talking day and night how Europe should throw away its Ariane 6 launcher because it is not reusable, we would be really fucked. Luckily those were ignored, as were the voices that were calling Galileo a waste of money.
PS: Falcon 9 list price in 2026 is apparently 74 Mio USD. Reports of Ariane launch prices are thin but one can find numbers from 72 to 115 Mio EUR.
Price per launch is only part of the equation. Price per kg, and available launches are two others. Ariane 6 has a payload capacity of about 10 tonnes to LEO. Falcon 9 has a payload capacity to LEO of about 25 tonnes. Obviously SpaceX is charging what the market will bear, and making bank in the process with their higher cadence. Also, none of this has any bearing on the benefit to national security that the EU enjoys by having their own launch vehicle.
Ariane 6 64 has about 22t LEO payload at reported launch costs of 115 Mio EUR. The price disadvantage is blown way out of proportion. Contrary to your claims launching is not extremely profitable for SpaceX. It is profitable but there is no indication they are charging way over because they can.
Edit: Apparently the SpaceX launch business was even operated at a loss in Q3 2026, it was a small loss, so they are basically managing to cover their costs.
10,000 satellites are needed to have the same coverage.
With 100 satellites per launch that’s 100 times $50 million more expenses. It’s doable, but the money cannot be spent on drones, ai or medical research.
Comments
May be don’t depend on the infrastructure build, owned and operated by a ketamin addicted fachist billionaire?
Build. Your. Own.
It is a known science, he is not reinventing the wheel. He just put them in leo.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IRIS² TLDR: EU, Norway and Iceland want to have a domestic alternative to Starshield up and running by 2030
That’s crazy! Wheels in LEO? Everyone knows they need traction to work!
No one company owns all the fiber, no one company should own all the space infrastructure.
Transfer ownership to an international NGO. There’s no reason to have a hundred companies all maintaining independent 1,000+ satellite constellations.
Indeed, IRIS 2 should have been launching over a decade ago. That’s what we get for relying on a fucking pedo neo-Nazi.
what is why decentralization is important!
Then we should launch ours yesterday.
Is there even room? Between musk and bezos, the sky is full of them.
Yes. Space is big. Very big. People vastly underestimate how much room there is even in LEO. We haven’t even scratched the surface of how much we can put up there; and in LEO, Kessler syndrome is not really an issue. It will be decades, if not centuries, before the number of satellites becomes a real issue.
Let’s try to put a little perspective on this. Currently, there are ~20,000 satellites in orbit. Seems like a big scary number. But let’s actually think about this. Imagine if there were only 20,000 cars on the road across the entire US, or the EU if that’s easier to think about. 20,000. Across ALL the roads. It would probably feel pretty empty right?
Well, most satellites are smaller than cars and the amount of available space in orbit is exponentially greater than the amount of space on all roads. Literally not a problem.
But you’re wrong. Because you seem to think that “too many” is only a matter of when collisions start to occur, but that’s a completely arbitrary threshold. The fact is that the huge increase in number of satellites in orbit, compared to before Starlink, is having a significant detrimental effect on the ability of telescopes to gather data for astronomy. They are indeed a “star shield”, because they’re shielding us from properly being able to see and study the stars. They make our collective horizon smaller.
I knew this argument was coming. Satellites showing up in telescopes is essentially a non problem. Ever since astrophotography switched to digital, we have easily been able to filter out satellites and airplanes (which are a much bigger nuisance btw). You get the occasional article or post that has a picture of what happens when you take a super long exposure and DONT filter out the satellite/plane streaks, and it’s used as click bait going “See!? Look at what our hubris of launching satellites has brought! You should be mad! You should be afraid! You should be afraid AND mad!”
Now, to be fair, when trying to look at EXTREMELY distant or faint objects, satellites do start being a problem; but those kinds of observations are difficult even with clear skies, that’s why we have space-based telescopes like Hubble and the JWST. But those are edge cases. For the vast majority of ground-based star gazing, it’s been a solved problem for a long time now.
Thank you for explaining, that’s actually pretty comforting to learn.
Sure, Iris2 is coming.
@Malyca @Mihies
There should be international consensus on the number of satellites allowed globally at Starlink altitudes, per country. If there is oversaturation by any one country, the excess should be shot down. 🤷
Like US or any other bigger country would agree. But yes, how is a foreign country launching satellites in low orbit all over other countries is beyond me. Why EU keeps silent…
That was the best time. Second best is now.
We don’t have reusable rockets which makes launching the fleet prohibitively expensive.
The EU pays for the weapons in Ukraine while the US makes the profits.
It’s a trap. There is no easy way out. The EU can’t buy their way to prosperity and if it could, it wouldn’t have the politicians to do so.
We can fill one hole but then we don’t have the resources to fill the others.
Any ideas what could be done?
Maybe actually informing oneself before posting stuff like that? Ariane 6 is perfectly capable of launching a strategic satellite communication network. Will the launching itself cost a bit more? Likely but the extra launch costs are wildly exaggerated. Which is exactly why the EU is creating such a satellite network as we speak. The network should become operational in 2029/2030. In the meanwhile there is a gap solution of GOVSATCOM which started this year. We can of course debate till eternity how that is too late but decision makers have woken up at least in the aftermath of the 2nd Ukraine invasion in 2022.
Now if we had listened to those that were talking day and night how Europe should throw away its Ariane 6 launcher because it is not reusable, we would be really fucked. Luckily those were ignored, as were the voices that were calling Galileo a waste of money.
PS: Falcon 9 list price in 2026 is apparently 74 Mio USD. Reports of Ariane launch prices are thin but one can find numbers from 72 to 115 Mio EUR.
Price per launch is only part of the equation. Price per kg, and available launches are two others. Ariane 6 has a payload capacity of about 10 tonnes to LEO. Falcon 9 has a payload capacity to LEO of about 25 tonnes. Obviously SpaceX is charging what the market will bear, and making bank in the process with their higher cadence. Also, none of this has any bearing on the benefit to national security that the EU enjoys by having their own launch vehicle.
Ariane 6 64 has about 22t LEO payload at reported launch costs of 115 Mio EUR. The price disadvantage is blown way out of proportion. Contrary to your claims launching is not extremely profitable for SpaceX. It is profitable but there is no indication they are charging way over because they can.
Edit: Apparently the SpaceX launch business was even operated at a loss in Q3 2026, it was a small loss, so they are basically managing to cover their costs.
Internally launches could be as cheap as $20 million for SpaceX. https://innotechinsider.com/spacex/spacex-launch-business-margins-q3-2026-analysis/
https://orbitalradar.com/how-many-starlink-satellites
10,000 satellites are needed to have the same coverage.
With 100 satellites per launch that’s 100 times $50 million more expenses. It’s doable, but the money cannot be spent on drones, ai or medical research.
We can fill some holes but not all.
Trump and Elon are Putin puppets. Don’t depend on them.
I was saying this back in the Motorola Iridium days
Impossible! No one could have predicted it was a bad idea to put all of our trust in techbro US billionaires!
Sign in to comment. Sign in