Comment on What would a 3rd person shooter equivalent be to "Boomer Shooters"
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
With your logic Breath of the Wild is a Jump’n Run, because you can jump and run in the game??
Edit: Let me explain this differently. Doom is a shooter, because the main game element is a shooter. If you robbed Tomb Raider the shooting element away, it would be still the same game. Because that is not what defines to be Tomb Raider. The shooting element doesn’t make it a shooter genre.
Lemme guess: You consider it to be an RPG?
Do you even know what RPG means? If you had read my previous replies, then you would know that Tomb Raider is an Action Adventure game. It’s more comparable to a Zelda game than a Doom game. Edit: Explanation can be found here: https://lemmy.ml/post/55246936/29003366
Games can be more than one genre. If you read my replies, you’d understand that many action adventure games are also THIRD PERSON SHOOTERS. TLOU: Action adventure 3rd person shooter. Uncharted: Action adventure 3rd person shooter. Tomb Raider: Action adventure 3rd person shooter. Metroid Prime: Action adventure FIRST person shooter. Borderlands: First-Person Shooter Action RPG.
These differentiate from games like Zelda, which are action adventure but nothing else. Soulslikes are closer to Zelda than Tomb Raider, TLOU, or Uncharted are and it all comes down to how the action is handled. Shooters vs melee focused combat.
GTA is a racing game, because you have cars. Breath of the wild is a third person shooter, because you have a bow and can shoot. Is that where are at? Oh did I already mention that Breath of the Wild is a Jump’n Run too, because you can jump and run? As said, the shooting element of Tomb Raider is not what it makes to be a Tomb Raider. Therefore calling it a shooter is wrong. It is an Action Adventure. You totally ignore the context in what we are discussion:
3rd person shooter equivalent be to “Boomer Shooters”
And Tomb Raider is not that. The shooting element doesn’t matter for the genre it is in. Off course games can be categorized in one or more genres. But depending on the game, its not important for the genre.
You clearly misunderstood the question OP is asking. Doom is the granddaddy of “boomer shooters.” OP is asking what the granddaddy of TPS are, not what TPS games are similar to boomer shooters. And Tomb Raider is literally defined as a 3rd person shooter action adventure game by Eidos themselves, making it one of the earliest games that could have been the basis of inspiration for others in the genre.
It’s also ironic you keep wanting to use “GTA is a racing game” as an argument. You do realize that GTA originally was born from a racing game, right?
Sign in to comment. Sign in