Skip to content

Comment on Leaked screenshot shows Graphite reading your Signal, WhatsApp, and Telegram - directly from your phone

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • At some level, you have to accept that there’s no panacea to the panopticon. At least, none at the retail level.

    Ffs, flock cameras and facial recognition make even MeatSpace a shitshow of privacy violations.

    Ultimately, the real defense against spying is irrelevance. 99.99% of people simply aren’t interesting enough to monitor in a way that matters.

    6
    • And that’s the real point.

      Make irrelevance desirable and notoriety risky and you’ve got a compliant people

      11
      • even if 99.99% of the populace is irrelevant to them they are still going to collect the data and use it against you if they need to.

        5
        • Massively easier to find/create relevance now that LLMs can be run against the data. Now imagine all the mistakes it could make.

          4
          • We don’t have to imagine, it’s already making those mistakes. But don’t worry, taxpayers will fund the settlements…

            4
      • But also make notoriety a source of revenue and irrelevance a job security risk.

        You’ll get enthusiastic compliance, as evidenced by the last two years.

        But you’ll also get a groundswell of nobodies who are super pissed at you. All this surveillance is ineffectual when defiance occurs at scale.

        When everyone’s acting in opposition, nobody gets punished.

        2
    • If you have noting to hide you have nothing to fear?

      Where have I heard that before.

      1
    • But security through obscurity is no security at all. On top of that, as companies continue to automate spying and the price for spying on an individual falls, we’ll be spied on more and more whether we’re noteworthy or not

      0
      • But security through obscurity is no security at all.

        The survivability onion disagrees.

        https://thumb.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/8/85/Survivability_Onion.png/250px-Survivability_Onion.png

        On top of that, as companies continue to automate spying and the price for spying on an individual falls, we’ll be spied on more and more whether we’re noteworthy or not

        Just because I can read your email doesn’t mean I can distinguish what’s important from what’s spam.

        The most important element of the flock camera system is your DMV’s license plate record system. Without that, none of it works. Even with it, you need an enormous ground presence to make it meaningful.

        Looking unremarkable is absolutely critical in a surveillance state. You should be aware of what takes you off the radar relative to what makes you stick out.

        4

Sign in to comment. Sign in