Skip to content

Comment on blastQR: send files completely offline over QR codes. Up to 1.4 MB/s

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • I don’t see a lot of use cases where blastQR beats LocalSend. The ones I do see are mostly about surreptitious data exfiltration against the will of device and/or data owners, and those are still complicated by the need to install your client on the sending side.

    1
    • If you’re in an environment where turning on your cell radios could compromise you then you’d like something that operates through something other than radio. Two people sharing data at a protest for example.

      9
      • LocalSend uses wifi rather than cell but you’re right that a protest could be a good place not to turn on any radios. It’s also a good place not to bring a phone at all, even if you’ve thought in advance to install a visual data transfer program like this. But you have a good point.

        1
        • There’s a wide range of threat levels someone could be managing at a protest. Lots of people don’t feel particularly at risk from being grabbed and having their phone cracked, but still don’t want to be added into a database of people opposed to a regime because an automated mass surveillance system sniffed their radio signature. If you’re not expecting a personal assault phones can be useful for documenting police, promoting the event afterward, and accessing emergency services.

          I don’t think the “don’t bring a phone to a protest” advice is good unless you think it’s likely you could be in a position to lose control of it. The tradeoffs for that level of safety don’t make it worth doing for random citizen protesters. I do think concealing your face and turning off your radios is a good idea, because those are very realistic threat vectors for a generic citizen protester. Of course you could have the best of both worlds by getting a burner phone, but I don’t think many people are that prepared.

          3
    • Funfact: localsend works between two smartphones if on is on hotspot mod

      4
    • Could be for airgapped devices

      1
      • Sure, that’s covered by my commentary about data exfiltration against the wishes of data or device owners, and about the difficulty of installing the client on the airgapped device.

        I believe there are a few legitimate use cases that don’t have a faster/better alternative, but they’re very niche.

        -1
        • I’m talking about intentional data transfer between airgapped devices. Airgapped usually just means no networking. Often people will still need a way to occasionally transfer data to/from the device. A common one is USB, but USB has tons of security issues (BadUSB). Using a camera + QR codes is an interesting alternative.

          So you’re effectively choosing between the security of networking stack or the camera stack.

          4

Sign in to comment. Sign in