I don’t see a lot of use cases where blastQR beats LocalSend. The ones I do see are mostly about surreptitious data exfiltration against the will of device and/or data owners, and those are still complicated by the need to install your client on the sending side.
If you’re in an environment where turning on your cell radios could compromise you then you’d like something that operates through something other than radio. Two people sharing data at a protest for example.
LocalSend uses wifi rather than cell but you’re right that a protest could be a good place not to turn on any radios. It’s also a good place not to bring a phone at all, even if you’ve thought in advance to install a visual data transfer program like this. But you have a good point.
There’s a wide range of threat levels someone could be managing at a protest. Lots of people don’t feel particularly at risk from being grabbed and having their phone cracked, but still don’t want to be added into a database of people opposed to a regime because an automated mass surveillance system sniffed their radio signature. If you’re not expecting a personal assault phones can be useful for documenting police, promoting the event afterward, and accessing emergency services.
I don’t think the “don’t bring a phone to a protest” advice is good unless you think it’s likely you could be in a position to lose control of it. The tradeoffs for that level of safety don’t make it worth doing for random citizen protesters. I do think concealing your face and turning off your radios is a good idea, because those are very realistic threat vectors for a generic citizen protester. Of course you could have the best of both worlds by getting a burner phone, but I don’t think many people are that prepared.
Sure, that’s covered by my commentary about data exfiltration against the wishes of data or device owners, and about the difficulty of installing the client on the airgapped device.
I believe there are a few legitimate use cases that don’t have a faster/better alternative, but they’re very niche.
I’m talking about intentional data transfer between airgapped devices. Airgapped usually just means no networking. Often people will still need a way to occasionally transfer data to/from the device. A common one is USB, but USB has tons of security issues (BadUSB). Using a camera + QR codes is an interesting alternative.
So you’re effectively choosing between the security of networking stack or the camera stack.
Comments
I don’t see a lot of use cases where blastQR beats LocalSend. The ones I do see are mostly about surreptitious data exfiltration against the will of device and/or data owners, and those are still complicated by the need to install your client on the sending side.
If you’re in an environment where turning on your cell radios could compromise you then you’d like something that operates through something other than radio. Two people sharing data at a protest for example.
LocalSend uses wifi rather than cell but you’re right that a protest could be a good place not to turn on any radios. It’s also a good place not to bring a phone at all, even if you’ve thought in advance to install a visual data transfer program like this. But you have a good point.
There’s a wide range of threat levels someone could be managing at a protest. Lots of people don’t feel particularly at risk from being grabbed and having their phone cracked, but still don’t want to be added into a database of people opposed to a regime because an automated mass surveillance system sniffed their radio signature. If you’re not expecting a personal assault phones can be useful for documenting police, promoting the event afterward, and accessing emergency services.
I don’t think the “don’t bring a phone to a protest” advice is good unless you think it’s likely you could be in a position to lose control of it. The tradeoffs for that level of safety don’t make it worth doing for random citizen protesters. I do think concealing your face and turning off your radios is a good idea, because those are very realistic threat vectors for a generic citizen protester. Of course you could have the best of both worlds by getting a burner phone, but I don’t think many people are that prepared.
Funfact: localsend works between two smartphones if on is on hotspot mod
Could be for airgapped devices
Sure, that’s covered by my commentary about data exfiltration against the wishes of data or device owners, and about the difficulty of installing the client on the airgapped device.
I believe there are a few legitimate use cases that don’t have a faster/better alternative, but they’re very niche.
I’m talking about intentional data transfer between airgapped devices. Airgapped usually just means no networking. Often people will still need a way to occasionally transfer data to/from the device. A common one is USB, but USB has tons of security issues (BadUSB). Using a camera + QR codes is an interesting alternative.
So you’re effectively choosing between the security of networking stack or the camera stack.
Oh I see what you mean. Niche but important. Thanks for the explanation.
Sign in to comment. Sign in