Comment on Jeffries dragged for 'serious leadership problem' as Hegseth impeachment bid falls 7 votes short with 11 Dem no-shows
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments
Comments
Proposal submitted by a republican
Speaker is republican
Impeachment now would be dumb because republitards would get to pick his replacement…
The left: FUCK DEMOCRATS REEEEEEEEEEEE
Absolute troglodytes…
I’m confused by your line of thought. My complaint isn’t that the vote didn’t pass specifically, it was that someone who is presuming to take over leadership in 2027 didn’t make an effort to show leadership.
No matter if it was this Congress or the next one, the vote is mainly to feel out if Republicans are defecting from Trump at all. After the House passes an impeachment, the Senate has to vote 2/3rds to kick him out of office. All that effort isn’t going to happen before the new Congress is sworn in and if Republicans were looking to replace Hegseth before 2027, he is able to resign without being impeached.
They’re not looking to replace him, Dems are. But that’s impossible right now in a congress owned by republicans. Ofc you’re confused, this was a vote initiated by a republican and brought to the floor by a republican speaker, but you’re convinced that this is about Dem leadership.
I guess I’ll rephrase. Jefferies is the presumed speaker of the house in 2027. Which shows better ability to lead:
A. Miss a vote that would pass a Republican led house impeaching Hegseth for it to die in the Senate B. Have a Democrat led house impeach Hegseth to die in the Senate
You’re ignoring impeachment takes 67 senators voting for it. Maybe you’re more optimistic 12 republican senators will flip.
Your A. scenario would never happen because Johnson never would’ve brought it to the floor the moment he did if he knew Dems had the numbers…Yes, I’m more interested and optimistic for the version of events that is more likely to pass in the senate and allows Dems to block a replacement.
Yea I’m annoyed that this didn’t pass because it should’ve been a slam dunk for democrats and would’ve only added to their momentum after the midterms. But I also don’t like how it’s being presented as a sign of things to come. The newly elected congress isn’t even in session and everyone’s trying to pin it on them.
How would this passing add any “momentum” or be considered a “slam dunk”?
Wins, no matter how small, add momentum. That’s how it works. And it’s a ‘slam dunk’ because it’s a bill proposed by a Republican that dems could have easily gotten passed.
You’re under the illusion that there was a possible win to be had. If Johnson knew that Dems had the numbers, he’d never bring the proposal to the floor in the first place. If he did, it would be because the republicans would bring their majority, cuz incase you forgot, they still own congress.
Well Massie didn’t need Johnson’s permission to bring it to the floor it was a privileged resolution. So guess you’re under the illusion you know how parliamentary politics works.
So you think people’s lives are just numbers on a screen? Is politics a game for you? Oh well we losing this time so might as well not try. PEOPLE ARE DYING. Israel is killing people every single day. Ice is killing people everyday. There are thousands of immigrants sitting in concentration camps. They are getting raped and tortured EVERY SINGLE DAY. This isn’t a fucking game. It’s not about winning and losing. We have an obligation to uphold justice and protect as many people as we possibly can.
Tell me you don’t know how the process works without telling me. The only person acting like it’s a game is you. I’m arguing for effective action, you want pointless theatre. Go ahead and explain how that would be accomplished or just keep virtue signaling into the void.
still requires super majority in the Senate so he likely won’t get ousted before or after new senators are seated (without 10+ Republican defections)
still, there’s enough representation to refer him to the Senate for prosecution and a strong inquiry to made
Yea, but after the new members are present it’s more likely to get a supermajority and they’ll get to block any unhinged replacement after. Trying to do it now is just pointless.
1st stipulation still feels like a stretch but maybe you’re right. 2nd is plain wrong as there is always value in delivering justice.
it wouldn’t be pointless but could be materially worse if the replacement was indeed more unhinged. but that’s as hypothetical as a successful impeachment so either way it’s speculative.
Sign in to comment. Sign in