size is not what made reddit bad. commercialization is.
cross-posted from: https://feddit.org/post/37870004
reddit got bad because spez (the reddit admin) restricted API access to the platform for third-party apps, such that people would be forced to use the official app or web UI, both of which display advertisement and collect user data (e.g. scroll behavior).
the reason why this happened is because reddit is a for-profit company and tries to extract money out of the userbase, at the expense of the users.
another example of a bad decision that reddit made was to push a lot of ragebait (“Am I The Asshole?”) because company shareholders want to see “engagement numbers” go up, and if somebody writes an angry reply to a post, that’s “engagement”. but it makes you angry at the stupidity of the “Asshole”, so it makes your day worse. that is another example how reddit makes money at the expense of the users.
size (number of monthly active users) is not what made reddit bad. commercialization is.
we should probably get rid of the “don’t make lemmy grow, it will ruin the platform if we grow” idea.
Comments
I kinda miss the size from reddit actually. So many niche communities blooming. But still, no way I’m going back
Reddit has many problem. You touch on some of them here.
Another is how moderation is handled. Free moderation is fine up to a point, but then communities get large and it becomes a job and Reddit starts monetizing you without paying. That and one sweaty dork with an ax to grind holding ultimate authority over multiple communities. Reddit is another multi-billion dollar company (/wave Meta) that should be hiring and training hundreds of moderators but figured nah, a worse service and slightly larger yacht instead.
Reddit basically has fucked over their voluntary mods. If you have a bigger subreddit with several millions of users modding that is nearly impossible. You’ll get all those trolls, crazy people, nazis and fanatics with too much time. You’ll have to deal with astroturfing campaigns from companies with millions of dollars of budget and state sponsored desinfo campaings. You also will have do deal with all that cultural war bullshit. You subreddit can be about cute baby cats, but you will have to deal with MAGA bullshit, somebody will bring the war in Gaza into your place or post Putin with a cat. Karmafarming bots. Users will really insult you and accuse you of powertripping and being a Nazi.
You will have to do everything in your free time. Reddit will not pay you. Reddit will not really support you. You are alone responsible to build a mod team. You can’t pay them either. Spez will laught at you while earning millions. He will insult you if you speak up. You can’t close your sub. And then you will get burned out and leave. The sub will then be overrun by absolute trash.
This was my final straw. They broke the mod toolbox. Without that moderating became a chore. Then they expected us not only to mod for free, but also to let ourselves be a monetized commodity via forcing us all to the ad ridden app.
Back in the day the subreddit at least belonged to you. You could do anything you wanted with it, but the mod removals after the API protests made it clear that the communities we created aren’t actually ours anymore. So what’s the point? It’s like paying someone to let you work.
Yeah - and the whole rhetoric during the mod strike really made clear that they like the free work, but please do not stand in the way of the company. That was a huge fuck you and totally drove a lot of passionate mods away who were the heart of their subreddits. You really saw a lot of those go to shit afterwards
Every now and then I end up on that site (usually from searching for something and then absent-mindedly clicking to the homepage from there) and get whiplash at just how horrific the whole front page is even on its default logged-out setting for racism, misogyny, transphobia, homophobia, and other far-right talking point news stories.
There was a quiet exodus during the_donald era. That whole time from 2016 - 2020 was very strange. Nobody talks about it. Except for the minority of us from the before times.
For reddit corporate there was a serendipitous confluence of events.
Basically reddit corporate got a free reset. One that Digg could have only dreamed of. Much of the old unprofitable userbase left. Ragebaiting trolls overran the platform. Fresh userbases flooded into the site. Social media psychological manipulation/addiction mechanisms had a field day on those unsuspecting doomscrollers.
You old timers ever notice how reddit’s demise is a perpetually sliding window? You can tell when someone started using reddit based on when they think it was good and when it went bad.
Most users today talk about relaunch/redesign era as the good times. They think only relatively recently has it turned bad. None them have any clue about the pre-2020 era because they had no clue about reddit before.
All that being said. I don’t think it’s only commercialization that killed it. The type of users killed it too. That isn’t mutually exclusive from userbase size.
Commercialization relies on engagement tricks like ragebait. That requires users who will engage with that too. The old reddit userbase was more skeptical and cognizant of commercialization tactics. The userbase today doesn’t hate it. Some even seem to relish in it.
They like the tabloid posts. They like the emotional clickbait. They like to gossip. They like the drama.
There’s academic articles proving negative posts get more interaction. Some people just want to fight, they love the negativity. Life’s hard enough ffs. It’s disappointing cos it used to be a great place to hang out
In the attention economy, you don’t need ads to have ads. As long as you’re paying attention to someone, someone could be getting paid because of that.
Even if you block the ads and ignore them the site is so heavily botted with these bots pushing all sorts of products.
One of the most useful aspects of reddit used to be getting other perspectives on products you were interested in. This is no longer useful because of the massive networks of bot farms. You simply can no longer tell what’s real on that site and what isn’t.
The accounts posting fake product reviews to promote products are usually not bots. They are either actual people from ad agencies/brands, posting as a part of the campaign and other people from the agency upvoting (sometime also using engagement farms).
I don’t know how much activity on reddit is bot driven, but logically it makes little sense to me to run bot campaigns there. Until 2020, reddit was quite small and insignificant in terms of how many people you could reach. And now, reddit has made their API increasingly more expensive, making it prohibitive for large scale bot posting. Even scraping data is hard and very expensive, let alone posting at scale.
There might be engagement farms and content farms mass posting, but that is manual, not bots, and happens on all social media platforms.
I don’t buy it. Reddit is a prime target, and has been for a very long time.
Reddit allegedly had 400 million unique monthly users back in 2012 already: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/reddits-visitors-skyrocket-in-2012-with-37-billion-page-views/
Even if those numbers are inflated (which they almost certainly are), Reddit has had a very large audience for a very long time, even if it wasn’t fully recognized as mainstream.
And now, the price of pushing fake reviews has done nothing but drop. API calls to Reddit and LLM providers are surely cheaper than an engagement or content farm of real people.
There’s no way that the platform isn’t riddled with bots these days.
Hi, The article mentions 400M unique visitors for all of 2012, putting MAU at 400/12= ~33-34M MAUs?
Facebook it seems was doing a billion MAUs at this time, so 1000/33 = ~ 30. So reddit was approximately 30 times smaller than Facebook.
Now Facebook as far as I remember has always been a logged in experience. Back in the early days of reddit a lot of visitors did not sign up (because it was a link sharing website like digg), and I am not sure how good cookies and user attribution was back then but surely a lot of those 400M unique views weren’t unique people. But this is just my guess. Ignoring this stil makes reddit much smaller than fb.
Marketers btw, still consider reddit to be a niche social media. Look at this post here - https://www.reddit.com/r/redditstock/comments/1vj4i4i/just_learned_reddits_ad_revenue_is_lower_than/
Reddit get less money from advertisers than Bing and Yahoo in 2026. You might tell me that marketers are not paying for ads and instead using bots to pay for free and even that is the case, it’s much much smaller than other mainstrem social media (Facebook, Instagram, TikTok)
Yep it used to be you could hop on and get great guidance on products. Now you never know what’s real
Reddit admins repeatedly asked mods how to make like for them better. And then repeatedly ignored almost every single answer they got, rolling out features nobody wanted and taking away things people used. It was the years and years and years of putting in hours and hours of time working against the enshittification that made me tired, and then it was the stupid fucking over-reaching AI moderation that caused me to leave after my accounts started being banned for no good reason with appeals failing.
It took far too long for them to drive me away, as I know it did for a lot of others.
The two naturally tend to go hand in hand. Advertisers want lots of people to see their shitty ads, and reddit had a lot of traffic, which was marketable to advertisers. Reddit gets paid to keep the servers online (in addition to what they already made from reddit gold, awards, etc. which was just basically people paying for an emoji) and line their pockets so they don’t have much of an incentive to say no.
I want to wage a holy war on advertisers. They ruin just about everything that they touch with the stink of commercial consumerism. Simply blocking them doesn’t seem to be enough anymore.
I don’t know, size made it pretty bad. Subreddits with hundreds of thousands or more users create environments where no one is trying to have a discussion. People are just vying for attention. That creates an environment where comments are either all jokes, or all snark. It’s really, really hard to have anything that resembles a human experience in a place like that. People stop recognizing each other as people, and just treat everyone as an audience.
That makes for a pretty bad experience.
yes, assuming you are there for a discussion and not entertainment.
most folks are on reddit for entertainment, let’s not kid ourselves. very tiny sliver of the users were there for discussion.
First
This.
Yeah size isn’t what made the culture, politics and capitalism is.
Reddit was always shitty from when
The only reason the jailbait sub came down was do to main stream media pressure - if you missed jailbait was a “SFW” sub for posting reveling photos of other people’s children to be gooned over. It was voted “Subreddit of the year” in 2008
the mod who ran jailbait was an ICON on reddit for years and he also modded dozens of other equally questionable subs
The insane redditor backlash to them banning FatPeopleHate sub - which for those who missed it was a sub dedicated to posting photos of overweight people without their knowledge so the internet could mock them. This was mostly made up of - yes you guessed it - mostly photos of fat women getting mocked.
Leaving up the BeatingWomen sub that is specifically for posting videos of women getting beat up for 10+ more years after jailbait came down.
leaving up the Creepshots sub, a sub dedicated to upskirt and down-shirt photos of unsuspecting women, for YEARS and only taking it down due to to it hitting the main stream news and forcing their hand. This sub was also modded by the Jailbait mod.
the RAMPANT sexism and racism as thinly veiled intellectualism that has gone on for DECADES
Ghislaine Maxwell was a moderator on worldnews- I cannot back this claim up so I am removing it.The API thing and forced logins is probably one of the least shitty things this site has done.
At least back then they didn’t ban you for suggesting nonces like trump should be fed into woodchippers or that its time for guillotines.
Reddit started becoming shitty because people are shitty.
It started long before the API restrictions, long before the commercialisation.
No, it started failing when the influx of new users grew exponentially, but the systems to support it didn’t.
Subreddits were no longer communities, they became information and discussion hubs.
With the influx of people, further moderation was needed. But mod vetting isn’t that easy, and a lot of people who had absolutely no business moderating communities, let alone social hubs, got a whiff of power that drove them crazy.
And that leads to splinter communities, some abandoned, some forced to give up, and an overall mess to this all.
Splinter communities are one of the simplest, easiest ways to solve issues associated with growing too large. It’s incredibly frustrating that FOMO apparently drives users, turning splinter communities either into deserts or just the new overcrowded space.
100 spaces with 500 active users are more active, more interesting, and more manageable than 1 space with 50,000, but users seem to think their choices is to subscribe to one big group, or 100 small ones, and not just the one small one that vibes with them best.
Yes I think you’ve put your finger on it there. This obsession with being able to see EVERYTHING in some kind of omega feed.
Like I was showing a friend lemmy and he was like “how can I see ALL the communities [in the whole world]?” or “what if there are duplicate communities?”
He didn’t get that it’s GOOD that you don’t automatically connect to every single lemmy server, or that it’s actually fine if two servers have the “same” community. They’ll just end up being their own thing.
Control is crucial. I think there should be a foundation to own the development but controlled by a board of moderators. Something like the concorde agreement is needed.
I quit Reddit because of the ultra leftist moderators. You can’t have a different opinion or you get banned.
Elaborate on “ultra leftist”? Literally where are you on the compass if Reddit moderators are “too leftist” for you?
Oh, and I despise “You’re either with us, or against us”
That would also depend a lot on when and why you left.
Shutting down jailbait
Shutting down Trumps sub
Banning the word retard
Or instead what if its about some of the things they continue to allow? While not universally allowed, some posts like these can be made
Pro Luigi posting
Memes about kirky boy
Eat the rich
Each of these, if that is “too leftist” could be quite different. You may not agree with any of them, but what it implies about someone would be different.
I’m in the middle. I don’t like Tate fans, I don’t like hypocrite Thunberg.
Reddit got bad long before they restricted API access. That’s what was the final drop for many people, but it wasn’t the beginning at all.
I agree that growing would be a benefit for Lemmy though. While I wouldn’t dismiss the dangers of a growing community entirely, we can just defederate from or block problematic parts in theory. So I wouldn’t say we’re in quite the same danger as centralized platforms.
they ovvereached with thier AI-moderation/filtering bans, so now theres even less content. AI isnt finding reddit useful to scrape anymore, because they are getting Ai content instead.
What made reddit… reddit: The people running it, and a lot of the people using it.
No, what made Reddit bad was incivility, bots, trite comments, and theme accounts (and my axe!). It was massively popular, which exacerbated this stuff, and it incentivized upvotes.
Lemmy has upvotes but people seem less interested in them.
Here, we have the ability to mute toxic groups (defederate). We are decentralized, so it’s not just one dickhead in charge. Our users are, for the most part, civil and somewhat intelligent and funny.
I was with Reddit from 2012-2015ish and then lurking on and off until the API shit storm, and we are nothing like Reddit in my opinion - not that that was the intent of the original post but still
the “I also choose this guys dead wife” is what gave the site character
We know… we were there.
https://i.imgur.com/8Qu1cIh.png
Just amused by the juxtaposition, obviously they weren’t contradicting you (or replying to you). lol.
I’m easily amused. :)
reddit is still great
what did you get ejected for?
I can’t even moderate my communities anymore without their shitty app because they’ve removed all functionality from everything else to force use of said app.
I’m still there on my OG account for a few niche gaming subs. Only because I still have RIF working through revanced. If that finally stops working I guess I’ll have to lose those communities.
I refuse to use their app so I abandoned everything I moderated except my main one I grew by hand for over ten years, but it’s more or less unmoderated at this point. I glance at it once a week. My other mods all left for similar reasons.
My Reddit account is 18 years old and I can tell you that Reddit hasn’t been “great” since 2013; the year of Drumpf vs HIllDawg for US President. Heck I still have over 2 years of “Reddit Premium” from the zillions of tokens I got back when they gave those away.
I was never ejected, still haven’t been, and I moderated some noteable subs. The API debacle and the shutdown of unofficial apps was my last straw. I removed myself from all the mod teams I was on and bailed over to Lemmy.
Reddit still has some cool communities but as a platform it’s best days are long gone. At this point its coasting on inertia just like Facebook.
“Sad”
Reddit is genuinely terrible now. Have you visited recently? All is removed, posts and comments default to sorting by best instead of hot (which mixes minutes-old posts with week-old posts), there’s an algorithmic For You feed, there are constant popups to log in or use the app…
And after all that, the content you’re looking at was probably posted by a bot.
The amount of AI generated content on Reddit is egregious.
There might be some kind of case to be made that reddit did get too big for what it was, but lemmy won’t have to worry about that until it’s at least a hundred times its present size.
Lemmy is already struggling with many of the same issues as Reddit; poor and / or objectionable moderation or moderators, bots and bot activity, politically motivated disinformation, groupthink, brigading, and censorship.
Scale makes the problems more noticeable because it makes them happen more frequently but it doesn’t create the problems. It’s the same with Commercialization, it’s doesn’t create those problems it simply highlights them.
i think the main problem with lemmy, is theres too little content and too little users. and especially users being so fickle they immediately jump to an even smaller platform.
And many of those problem are here because it’s the same people. There’s a significant fraction of the Lemmyverse that is made up of people who object to effective moderation, who see being censured for breaking rules around behaviour or decorum as unacceptable “power tripping”, and a significant fraction who are authoritarian by nature and see the ban hammer as the first line of defence. A large chunk of the current population are also into groupthink and political disinformation.
There’s just a… frustrating number of bad faith actors hanging around. They used to hang around on Reddit, and helped plant the seeds of Reddit’s culture. Now they’re here.
thats why i block and avoid those instances and communities. its impossible to do this on reddit.
I started with BBSs back in the late '80s, moved to the Internet in the early 90s, then the WWW in the mid-late 90s, and was doing Admin / Mod work on forums by the year 2000. So believe me when I tell you those “those people” have always been online. ALWAYS. Those users are not a Reddit creation and I know because I was encountering them for decades before Reddit existed.
Hop on the wayback machine and cruise back to the earliest ./ posts if you want a taste.
The larger that Lemmy gets the more of “those people”, however you define that group, will show up here and increasingly they will not be Reddit Refugees.
Commercialization is a consequence of size. As such, size is ultimately what made reddit bad.
It was a consequence of the IPO. Yes, they needed some revenue to keep afloat but after getting shareholders they are legally obligated to try and suck as much money out of that site as possible.
reddit sucks because their standards suck. They don’t ban nazis.
By not banning one, you allow them all. Then it’s a nazi place.
It’s the Nazi Bar.
Yep. Zero tolerance is the only way.
Except I’ve never once seen a place that actually enacts that policy.
Btw tankies claim that anyone who isn’t a tankie is almost literally a Nazi, hence we are a Nazi bar in their eyes (particularly Lemmy.World), while we are a tankie bar in the eyes of anyone else.
Which I guess makes Lemmy.ml “not” a Nazi bar? (In their own eyes at least, somehow despite their rooting for Trump)
What servers allow Nazis?
World is pretty bad yeah, but I don’t believe they would allow actual Nazis.
Reddit was fine if you stuck to the right communities. This morning my browser session suddenly got blocked though, forcing me to download the app (which I won’t do).
So… not fine then, after all.
Even if size does become a problem (SufferringFromSuccess.meme), we can always defederate a smaller Lemmy/Piefed network and call it Fedi Classic.
I’ve been here for over 3 years and I have some questions about “Fedi Classic”. You are commenting into an instance (lemmy.world) that has a defederation list multiple pages long and some of the entries on it are undeniably “OG”.
So in this “Fedi Classic” will you be bringing back such classics as ExplodingHeads or FedditMoe? What about commonly blocked instances like ML and HexBear?
Why not have multiple Fedi Classics? That’s part of the beauty of the fediverse, after all. It’s great to be able to connect across instances, but it’s also great to not have to.
In fact, .ml, .grad, and Hexbear might be on their way to becoming something like this “Fedi Classic”, although not by their choice :P
I mean, for me their need to filter out left wing viewpoints is why I’ll never join .world, or use PieFed.
The latter is more troublesome, since they’re defaulting the software, not just the instance.
Tbf, most of those choices are opt-in, these days. There was a huge outcry demanding that.
So now, as always before, it is your choice if instance admin that matters much more than choice of platform.
Plus there’s PyLova too! It flat-out removed those choices from the code altogether.
PieFed blocks Hexbear and ML out of the box - they’re opt-out, not opt-in.
https://join.piefed.social/2026/08/13/what-piefed-blocks-out-of-the-box-and-how-to-unblock-it/
ExplodingHeads is already brought back, sort of. HilariousChaos is continuation of it and federates with l.w. Although it does not troll that much as then.
Sign in to comment. Sign in