Skip to content

Comment on can we shout out to the fediverse developers, for making the fediverse possible

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • So a few corrections:

    1. Tankies aren’t a bad thing, and it’s a nazi dogwhistle as pointed out by your link.

    2. Being a ‘Tankie,’ isn’t a bad thing, it’s being anti-nazi. The Term was invented by nazis, to criticize the soviet union crushing a nazi uprising with tanks, barely a decade after they won WWII.

    3. The tanks in Tiannamen square were the good guys. Objectively so. Maybe don’t root for the CIA?

    Please be smarter than you are. The people that own every aspect of your life are obviously going to lie to you to keep you under their ownership. It takes very little to debunk their lies.

    0
    • False:

      1. “Tankie” was coined by orthodox communists to describe and criticize party members who supported the Soviet Union’s use of military tanks to brutally crush the Hungarian Revolution of 1956. And, since you really love sources,

      The term “tankie” was originally used by dissident Marxist–Leninists to describe members of the Communist Party of Great Britain (CPGB) who followed the party line of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (CPSU). Specifically, it was used to distinguish party members who spoke out in defence of the Soviet use of tanks to suppress the Hungarian Revolution of 1956 and the 1968 Prague Spring, or who more broadly adhered to pro-Soviet positions.

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tankie 2. The Tiannamen Square protests are led by a vast majority of students. Reading the article you cited, it states: “…and are clear that the “protesters” (rioters) initiated the deadly violence in Beijing (none of which occurred in Tiananmen Square itself).” You can see that this mofo denies the massacre happening because it literally didn’t happen in the Square (true, but a non-sequitur). Secondly, that the protestors initiated the violence. The protests were peaceful, until the Chinese government declared martial law and ordered thousands of People’s Liberation Army (PLA) troops into Beijing. 3. Sure. The article is fucking misleading. Let’s assume it is right, and even then, your (3) is yet again a non-sequitur: because the protestors initiated the violence does not make the massacre justified.

      0
    • this is literal misinformation

      0
      • Be more specific, and please link explicit examples with sources, instead of using thought terminating phrases that your owner taught you when something clashes with their programming.

        0
        • @Adniem@thelemmy.clubOP· · edited

          just duckduckgo it

          1: the word “tankie” was made by reformist communistsm not nazis

          2: you have a million pieces of evidence about the tanks killing normal people

          3: and no, Democracy is a real thing, and capitalism can be regulated with rules (Genius for your chicken strips brain, but not for me), most of the EU is an example

          4: there is no thought in communism, communism is the most vague thing on earth, it cannot pair with democracy since it’s so vague

          your odor lingers on

          0
          • the word “tankie” was made by reformist communistsm not nazis

            Answered in the First link, calling the CGRB ‘reformist communists’ is the same as calling nazis ‘reformist socialists’ because they have socialist in the name.

            you have a million pieces of evidence about the tanks killing normal people

            No, you don’t. In fact, you don’t have a single one, because that was never the claim for Tiannamen square. The tanks sheltered the soldiers from gunfire during the rebellion. This is answered in the second link.

            and no, Democracy is a real thing,

            Correct, and all forms of socialism have democracy built in, as socialism is democracy applied to the economy.

            and capitalism can be regulated with rules (Genius for your chicken strips brain, but not for me), most of the EU is an example

            The same EU that uses slave labor for most of its wealth? [1]

            Regulated capitalism still requires exploitation in order to function, because it is still capitalism, which is exploitative by nature.

            there is no thought in communism

            There’s more thought in communism than there is in capitalism, as communism is based on the scientific method, and capitalism is built on the idea some people are born better than others. [2]

            your odor lingers on

            I hope you realize your place and the fact you will never be a capitalist. Education is free and easy these days.

            0
            • 1: of course your using 3 links referening to communist newspapers and others (what did i expect), Having No Evidence

              2: go to this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1989_Tiananmen_Square_protests_and_massacre#Citations, then look and read them all (the ones written in english)

              3: no all communist and socialist countries, are not actual democracies in being free

              4: there is no evidence with the EU encouraging any form of slave labor, that wasn’t in the 1700s, and also many of those companies that exploit are likely gonna become illegal by some day

              5: then why are all those soviet union countries and china and communist nations, exploit people, kill them, and many more, if there was thought in it, none of that would happen

              6: your fart lingers on

              7: communism hides the issues with its economy, capitalism doesn’t

              0

Sign in to comment. Sign in