Idk what these other people are fucking talking about, but you’re right. Legitimately, they cannot name a connection between Tupac and Jeffries other than that the men are black.
Never pretend that leftists are immune to racism, sexism, homophobia, or any other bigotry. We aren’t. But man, does it seem like our brand of bigotry is just as hard to admit to.
It’s always been a problem in left wing and especially internet left wing spaces. There’s a reason that traditionally black revolutionaries and white revolutionaries tend not to collaborate that much, unfortunately. Intersectionality is difficult for everyone to adapt to.
It’s pretty racist, given the only connection to Tupac would be his race. Absolutely not a single other detail is the same between the two. Jeffries doesn’t even claim to have been poor or from ‘the hood’ or anything that might make a plausible excuse to use the nickname.
It’s pretty racist, given the only connection to Tupac would be his race. Absolutely not a single other detail is the same between the two.
AI(PAC) Tu(pac).
Race is certainly a secondary factor, however the term was coined by a black man. If you think a black man calling another black man a nickname based on a third black man is racist then you should think calling Stephen Miller ‘Pee-wee Himmler’ is equally racist.
I don’t think even the rotating villains of capital want Hegseth involved in the military (and its not like he would be removed if this had passed). This seems more an issue of broader failures of democrats even when aligned.
The vote was rushed. There was a police led motorcade that blocked numerous Reps from getting to be present and vote. Pelosi was ironically honoring vets, in CA, so that’s a fail. And Jeffries could have ‘whipped up’ the vote, so that’s a fail. And anyone could have expected some shenanigans from the gopers, so that’s a fail.
It’s crazy how many bots Israel gives Hakeem Jeffries, the genocide enthusiast. It’s totally understandable when you remember he’s their best paid candidate as well.
The GOP told you when the vote was ahead of time. Doesn’t matter if it was rushed, leadership’s job is to respond to it and make sure that on important votes, your party is there to counter the fuckery.
This leadership that wants to continue being a leader didn’t step up. But they sure did make sure they stepped up to gut the Clean Waters Act though so there’s that.
I had a doctors note and I still got fired the first time I called out
I’d be generous and give them 3 non-doctor’s note call out days per term. Anymore than that then their seat and pay goes to one of their staff members for the rest of the term. They can come back after getting reelected so the voter’s are still sovereign if they want them.
Call outs by the way. If they don’t call in with a good excuse before hand then that would be instant replacement for the rest of the term. Same for if they couldn’t produce a doctor’s note.
This is absolutely bullshit. With something like this coming up you either spend the night in your office or leave 2 hours early. This is our fucking country and our lives. We voted for you to do this. The movie No Way Out has Gene Hackman as a senator, I believe, who is waiting for someone for a meeting in Washington DC. The person is late and blames traffic. Hackman looks at him and says “why didn’t you account for it?”. These motherfuckers have no excuse for this.
My guess is that they would rather wait until after the new congress gets sworn in to Impeach Hegseth because the extra time is good for their allies in the war industry, and because they have some dumb political game theory about how it helps them if it happens on their preferred schedule.
I don’t think that 11 similarly-minded reps somehow had an oopsie-daisy on the day of the big vote.
There are only two explanations for what happened:
Jeffries is too incompetent of a leader to get asses in seats to vote for important shit when the time comes.
Jeffries is a competent, traitorous leader to have arranged for there to be excuses to have not had the votes.
In both cases, he should be disqualified for even attempting to lead the party. He’s either too much of a little pissboy bitch or he’s a purchased stooge begging to be the appetizer of our meal of eating the rich.
Because we literally do have to. It’s entirely up to the Congress members at this point, and they’ve decided this is the best path forward
I’ve done nothing but lay out what seem to be the reasoning and benefits of this choice for progressives, but ultimately no one is running against Jefferies. We don’t have a vote in this, it’s not a very good system, but it’s the one we have right now
I mean, you could write to your congresspeople, but I think getting scheumer out is way more important. There’s benefits to keeping Jefferies, but they do not apply to Schumer… He’s proven willing and able to ratfuck us in a matter of hours
A call for a removing the speaker of the house can happen at any time by a simple majority. We are not confined to just one january election for this. We need to be consistent now and in the future that leadership records like this one dont represent the people and are flatly unacceptable for any democrat to serve. Shrugging and moving forward as if this can never ever happen is a recipe for continuing to lose. We have to put our foot down and leave it down. If we dont have the votes now we need to build the support for it over time by bringing it up every single day on every single issue until ignoring it is untenable. This is a marathon, not a sprint with a finish line. If theres one thing the republicans will get behind, its removing a dem speaker-- just for the thrill of doing it.
If we dont have the votes now we need to build the support for it over time by bringing it up every single day on every single issue until ignoring it is untenable.
Why? Those priorities are completely backwards. Passing other bills will establish junior members and create political momentum for progressives. Postponing progress to remove Jefferies is ass backwards
The entire reason progressives are doing so well is the demand for action from the people - if Jefferies becomes an obstruction to that, then it becomes the priority to remove him. If he doesn’t, we get to make the county better… That’s the entire reason we need progressives in power in the first place
This is a marathon, not a sprint with a finish line.
Exactly…What does removing Jefferies give us right now? The momentary satisfaction of firing him? He’s one asshole among many
It doesn’t matter who sits in the fancy chair, what matters is the work.
We need to unfuck our country, and if it means letting Jefferies get on the progressive bandwagon and save his political career, fine.
If it means we need to oust Schumer, fantastic, but not because of how satisfying it’ll be - it’s because Schumer is a major obstacle to the work.
Everything that doesn’t move us closer to our goals is a distraction.
A call for a removing the speaker of the house can happen at any time by a simple majority.
So why do this now? Starting a fight with Jefferies at this stage would be a distraction. He’s met with progressive leaders and they were convinced them he’d work with them, and a cooperative Jefferies is the best case scenario (for now) - it means a more cohesive voting block and a scapegoat to take the heat while progressives will claim the victories
Jefferies will get a chance to improve his popularity and maybe continue his political career beyond his next election, but he’s a weak leader and has no charisma. He can’t be trusted, but he can be used and safely set aside when the time comes
Currently keeping Jefferies is to our advantage. When that changes, we change Jefferies
Compromise means we get something and weegxve something. What are we saying we get? Plum committee assignments in return for no progressive bill ever passing the House?
Imma keep it real with you Jeffries, I’m going to extend the exact same forgiveness I get from my boss when I miss big work responsibilities because I had trouble with the bus: exactly none. Be at work on time, and then police motorcades won’t be a problem.
I’m up at 5:30 every day, I don’t start work 'till 8. By the time I get to sit down after work, it’s 8 pm at least. There is absolutely no excuse for missing a vote. You leave yourself plenty of time to get there, then you don’t have to worry about being late.
If this vote happened and Hegseth was impeached, couldn’t Trump and the current GOP Senate just back-fill his cabinet position before January with no opposition from Democrats?
In other words, wouldn’t it be better to impeach after Democrats have control of Senate where there is a 51 confirmation requirement?
It doesn’t matter it takes 67 senate votes to convict, he can’t be removed either now or later. The point of the vote was whether Massie gets to make everybody in the House go on record voting whether they support illegally starting two wars, murdering 200 elementary school children, and massacring Caribbean fishermen under no quarter. Which is why a lot of these Democrats sat it out, they were the ones cheering Hegseth on when he did all that shit and don’t want to have to stand by it now that they’ve noticed the peasants are unhappy.
A) Now that the articles have been introduced they can be brought up for a demand vote by the Speaker at any time, including in January when the speaker chances.
B) This is about creating and destroying political capital, as the other user said. Those 11 dems now explicitly endorse Pete Hegseth and the Trump regime, including all of its crimes. It’s on record now, and that record will be used by both republicans and dems against them when they’re up for reelection. It’s a vote to show your hand and your donors.
For (B) I still don’t quite get it because, for example, Pelosi is a lame duck retiring anyway come January. What did she have to lose by voting Yes for posterity, especially when substantively it would’ve led to nothing happened given the Senate vote threshold?
Pretty obvious how badly this looks – I mean Hegseth is pretty universally unliked.
What did she have to lose? Her fortune, her family’s assets, any and all legitimacy she has. While you say she’s a lame duck, she’s still ‘respected’ by representatives in power. By making this stance clear, it’s another thing that can be used against representatives that think Pelosi and her choices have any positive impact on democrats or society - aka, it’s a cudgel people can hit AOC on the head with the next time she tries to defer to centrist dems on something.
Pelosi might be gone, but her legacy of ‘raising’ junior reps is not, and those junior reps, for ‘some’ reason keep doing her bidding even when it goes against the mandate they were elected for.
Wasn’t this some sort of play by Republicans to try and sneak a vote in, which is why a bunch of people couldn’t make it? Correct me if im wrong.
Seems like something designed to make progressives look bad for asking for representation in government. Isreal must be shitting their pants about losing control of the wheel.
No, not really. This vote was scheduled a couple days in advance, so everyone had time to figure out how to get there on time. One of the Democrats that missed the vote blamed a traffic jam, but a reporter saw him on the capital steps several minutes before the deadline. He could have easily just walked inside and cast his vote before the deadline, but just… didn’t.
They are on a rotation. They have already figured out who to sacrifice based on if they’re up for reelection or not, and whomever they chose because they can afford to take the heat.
It’s all a game. It’s a big club and you ain’t in it. They pay by rules you don’t even know exist. Decisions are made behind closed doors, and we are told there was a vote or whatever. The truth is not out there, it’s locked behind a FOIA request that gets denied or redacted beyond recognition.
Jeffries is in charge right now until January, you think he doesn’t have the votes already in place? He will try to stay in power at any cost.
They’ll get it all from you sooner or later ‘cause they own this fuckin’ place. It’s a big club and you ain’t in it. You and I are not in the big club. By the way, it’s the same big club they use to beat you over the head with all day long when they tell you what to believe. All day long beating you over the head with their media telling you what to believe, what to think and what to buy. The table is tilted, folks. The game is rigged and nobody seems to notice. Nobody seems to care. Good, honest, hard-working people: white collar, blue collar, it doesn’t matter what color shirt you have on. — George Carlin
There was a massive traffic clusterfuck that delayed a busload of Democrats from returning from an event across town (multiple Republicans also got delayed). This included some of the loudest Democratic supporters of the effort.
The House GOP exploited this by closing the vote as soon as they had the majority; if it had been the other way around, they would have just held it open for hours until they had enough votes to defeat it. The absent Dems didn’t actually change the outcome.
This specific vote was driven by outgoing Republican Thomas Massie, there’s nothing preventing Democrats from introducing their own in January. In fact it’s arguably better – an impeachment now would have managers appointed by Republicans and go before a Republican-controlled Senate. I’d much rather have Democratic managers and 56 Democrats in the Senate. Especially if Hegseth somehow is fired or resigns and Trump is able to appoint a new Defense Secretary with the current Senate.
Even in the case of a 2027 impeachment though, you’d still need 11 Senate Republicans to vote to convict (12 if Fetterman defects), which is extremely unlikely given who’s left in the caucus. This whole effort is ultimately symbolic, not something with a real shot at removing Hegseth.
Acting like this was some nefarious plot by AIPAC to maintain the war is absurd.
Definitely wasn’t called short, I watched it happen. It was a 5 minute vote, the vote was known about the day before, and even after the 5 minutes was up they still let people vote.
If all the GOP and all the Dems voted, then the Dems would have failed by 2 votes. But 7 GOP didn’t vote while 11 Dems didn’t vote. Dems could have struck down the effort to send the impeachment to committee, but they couldn’t even bother to show up for work.
I don’t give a shit what excuses they had, I don’t get to make excuses to miss work during critical moments, why the fuck should our overpaid reps get different treatment? Especially when all I’m doing most of the time is enshittifying a website for some corpo shmuck, meanwhile these fucking people are supposed to be running our country!!!
This is just another example of why DSA and progressives built up so much momentum in the midterms. The neolib establishment dems are utterly useless in the face of real progress.
Your diatribe is exactly my point. I’m not onboard for Jeffries. I emailed my future Blue rep asking her to oust him from leadership. But sadly, we have to work with corpo dems to get anything done until they are all gone.
My point is these types of articles fit in with the GOP strategy, to cause rifts in the “left”
Quotes on “left” because of pedants, who keep yelling at me that there is no “left” in the USA.
The only wedge this drives though is with the vast masses against the corporatist zionist wing of the party…which IMO is the energy people need to keep up.
I don’t know of any meaningful constituency of voters that is out there angry that people are getting mad at Hailey Stevens for making her dreams of Israel come true and up and leaving, or Nancy Pelosi ironically skipping the vote to end an illegal and unjust war to get a lifetime achievement award from a veterans organization.
If I missed a crucial meeting at my work that was pivotal for positioning the future of the company, I would expect to reprimanded far more consequentially than some mean words.
And the way you change that overton window and shift those pressures leftward is thru sustained outside pressure
Corporate Dems have no real incentive to betray their actual constituents, donors, especially when their former main lovers(tech oligarchs and Israel) are sending all the signals their pocketbooks will open back up for them if they play nice, and if voters as a whole just go back to brunch, guess who easily wins that influence battle?
So while there is a type of corporate media propaganda that I think undermines the left, this is one of those rare instances I think this sort of coverage is actually helping. As it is keeping focus on who the villains inside the tent are and that they can’t be trusted(which they can’t). And right now they are banking on people going quiet and falling in line so they can maneuver behind the scenes and preserve their power and the status quo dynamic.
I think people are getting a little too up in arms about this whole thing. This is still the 119th Congress, the same one we’ve had for two years. Impeachment was always a long shot until the 120th is seated.
I actually don’t like that move by Massie because if there’s enough public pressure against a cabinet member then Trump may be inclined to fire them and get a replacement in while he still potentially has the votes to confirm them. That would end in January.
The reason to wait is that if the administration sees enough public pressure then Trump could fire cabinet members and potentially squeeze in a replacement while he still has the Senate. We want any removals to happen after January when Democrats will have control of the confirmation.
And the leader of the Democrats in the 119th Congress is bidding for leadership of the 120th Congress. The point of impeachment being a long shot isn’t the issue here, the fact that Massie introduced it isn’t the issue here, the fact that it was a quick turn around for this vote to advance it isn’t the issue here.
The issue is the complete failure of the 119th Congress’ Democratic leadership when your job is to ensure that on important votes, you make sure that your members are there to vote for it. When you ensure everyone can make time to advance a shitty bill that neuters the Clean Water act then you can damn well ensure that on the vote to advance impeachment of a guy who you’ve constantly said was unfit for the job, you make damn well sure that everyone is there to vote and not pussyfooting around getting stuck in traffic. And that same failure of a leader is running for the leadership of the 120th Congress too so no, we are right to be up in arms about this because if you can’t be arsed to do you damn job now, you aren’t going to be arsed to do the job latter when it actually matters.
The failure from Democrats pisses me off too and I hope to see somebody else as Speaker than Jeffries.
But in the end it was functionally irrelevant to the vote. There were also Republicans held up for the same reason as Democrats, and if they had all voted it still would have failed. Johnson would have extended the vote because he’s still Speaker and the Republicans still have control of the House.
This was just a mic drop by Massie on his way out. We were always going to have to wait until January for meaningful things to start happening.
But had ALL the Dems showed up, the vote on sending it to committee would have passed by too narrow a margin, and the process would have automatically progressed the eight articles of impeachment to a floor vote.
They COULD have pulled a win out of a loss, forcing each member of the House to vote on the articles of impeachment individually and thus be seen for what they are, and chose not to.
And again, the fact that Republicans were also stuck in some traffic doesn’t matter. The fact that the vote you think was irrelevant doesn’t matter. The fact that Johnson is still Speaker doesn’t matter. The fact that Massie wanted to have a final say really doesn’t matter.
All of that is just excuses and whataboutism doesn’t address the point that the current leader failed in providing leadership on a important vote, especially when the vote failed by a mere seven votes.
Comments
Love how the headline seems to imply that the blame is misplaced…
Thank you AIPAC Shakur!
Just a reminder AIPAC Shakur sounds good but is rather racist and disrespects the Shakur name dramatically.
Idk what these other people are fucking talking about, but you’re right. Legitimately, they cannot name a connection between Tupac and Jeffries other than that the men are black.
Never pretend that leftists are immune to racism, sexism, homophobia, or any other bigotry. We aren’t. But man, does it seem like our brand of bigotry is just as hard to admit to.
It’s always been a problem in left wing and especially internet left wing spaces. There’s a reason that traditionally black revolutionaries and white revolutionaries tend not to collaborate that much, unfortunately. Intersectionality is difficult for everyone to adapt to.
It isn’t racist, but it is stupid and disrespectful.
It’s pretty racist, given the only connection to Tupac would be his race. Absolutely not a single other detail is the same between the two. Jeffries doesn’t even claim to have been poor or from ‘the hood’ or anything that might make a plausible excuse to use the nickname.
AI(PAC) Tu(pac).
Race is certainly a secondary factor, however the term was coined by a black man. If you think a black man calling another black man a nickname based on a third black man is racist then you should think calling Stephen Miller ‘Pee-wee Himmler’ is equally racist.
I don’t, personally.
Yeah, black people can be racist to other black people, have you heard of Clarence Thomas or ever heard Jeffries speak at any point?
It doesn’t stop anything.
What are you talking about? The connection is AIPAC sounds like Tupac. It’s literally nothing to do with race.
Cool, so I can call Chuck Shumer APAIC Shakur?
Its genuinely pathetic that neoliberal dems think this was a smart strategy. How many people need to die for Pelosi’s pride?
Yet another complete failure by Democratic leadership.
Sounds like leadership got what it wanted. How’s that a failure?
I don’t think even the rotating villains of capital want Hegseth involved in the military (and its not like he would be removed if this had passed). This seems more an issue of broader failures of democrats even when aligned.
Make the MAGAts vote to protect this asshole
Give them nothing for free
The vote was rushed. There was a police led motorcade that blocked numerous Reps from getting to be present and vote. Pelosi was ironically honoring vets, in CA, so that’s a fail. And Jeffries could have ‘whipped up’ the vote, so that’s a fail. And anyone could have expected some shenanigans from the gopers, so that’s a fail.
That was already called as a lie by another Democrat. One stood on the steps for eleven minutes. Please stop spreading disinformation.
Yet another complete failure by Democratic leadership.
It’s crazy how many bots Israel gives Hakeem Jeffries, the genocide enthusiast. It’s totally understandable when you remember he’s their best paid candidate as well.
Wait, are you saying, “Yet another complete failure by Democractic leadership.”?
Its a small silver lining, but at least they tried this time. Usually they assume they’ve already lost and don’t even make an attempt.
Meanwhile, the GOP is happy to spend years running headlong into failed attempt after failed attempt until something finally lands.
no, they did not
Democrats didn’t even try in the first place, a Republican brought the articles.
Yup, a Republican that tossed Democrats the ball and our illustrious captain dropped it like it’s hot.
The GOP told you when the vote was ahead of time. Doesn’t matter if it was rushed, leadership’s job is to respond to it and make sure that on important votes, your party is there to counter the fuckery.
This leadership that wants to continue being a leader didn’t step up. But they sure did make sure they stepped up to gut the Clean Waters Act though so there’s that.
The 11 took AIPAC money.
They were all just stuck in traffic. I’m sure if they get a do-over they’ll remember to leave early this time.
What a name
Kushner: Hey buddy. Let’s hang out again.
Hakeem: Really? Ok I’ll be right there!
…
Hakeem: Hey I’m here! So where’s the party bro?..Bro?
If i miss a shift, i get fired. Anyone who doesn’t show up to work on time doesn’t represent voters.
It was worse the 11 were not there due to attending an event hosted by AIPAC! Fuckers are traitor to our country.
One of them was due to medical issues, which is a whole other problem.
I had a doctors note and I still got fired the first time I called out
I’d be generous and give them 3 non-doctor’s note call out days per term. Anymore than that then their seat and pay goes to one of their staff members for the rest of the term. They can come back after getting reelected so the voter’s are still sovereign if they want them.
Call outs by the way. If they don’t call in with a good excuse before hand then that would be instant replacement for the rest of the term. Same for if they couldn’t produce a doctor’s note.
This is absolutely bullshit. With something like this coming up you either spend the night in your office or leave 2 hours early. This is our fucking country and our lives. We voted for you to do this. The movie No Way Out has Gene Hackman as a senator, I believe, who is waiting for someone for a meeting in Washington DC. The person is late and blames traffic. Hackman looks at him and says “why didn’t you account for it?”. These motherfuckers have no excuse for this.
Neoliberals are conservatives. Always have been.
Conservative and Facist, the two political parties in America.
Personally, I’m skeptical that this was by accident.
The reps who missed this seem to have common political alignments.
My guess is that they would rather wait until after the new congress gets sworn in to Impeach Hegseth because the extra time is good for their allies in the war industry, and because they have some dumb political game theory about how it helps them if it happens on their preferred schedule.
I don’t think that 11 similarly-minded reps somehow had an oopsie-daisy on the day of the big vote.
There are only two explanations for what happened:
In both cases, he should be disqualified for even attempting to lead the party. He’s either too much of a little pissboy bitch or he’s a purchased stooge begging to be the appetizer of our meal of eating the rich.
Neolibs now in power and hitting the ground sitting down as expected.
HOLD THESE PEOPLE ACCOUNTABLE WITH THE PEOPLES EXECUTIVE BRANCH.
Further proof Jeffries is incapable of true leadership.
No one has ever accused him of leadership, but at least he can’t whip votes to backstab everyone
I don’t like or respect Jefferies, but he’s a compromise I could live with
Schumer on the other hand…
Why should any of us “live with” a compromise when we dont have to?
Because we literally do have to. It’s entirely up to the Congress members at this point, and they’ve decided this is the best path forward
I’ve done nothing but lay out what seem to be the reasoning and benefits of this choice for progressives, but ultimately no one is running against Jefferies. We don’t have a vote in this, it’s not a very good system, but it’s the one we have right now
I mean, you could write to your congresspeople, but I think getting scheumer out is way more important. There’s benefits to keeping Jefferies, but they do not apply to Schumer… He’s proven willing and able to ratfuck us in a matter of hours
A call for a removing the speaker of the house can happen at any time by a simple majority. We are not confined to just one january election for this. We need to be consistent now and in the future that leadership records like this one dont represent the people and are flatly unacceptable for any democrat to serve. Shrugging and moving forward as if this can never ever happen is a recipe for continuing to lose. We have to put our foot down and leave it down. If we dont have the votes now we need to build the support for it over time by bringing it up every single day on every single issue until ignoring it is untenable. This is a marathon, not a sprint with a finish line. If theres one thing the republicans will get behind, its removing a dem speaker-- just for the thrill of doing it.
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/01216d6a-84e0-4232-b4af-16237990d0a1.png
Why? Those priorities are completely backwards. Passing other bills will establish junior members and create political momentum for progressives. Postponing progress to remove Jefferies is ass backwards
The entire reason progressives are doing so well is the demand for action from the people - if Jefferies becomes an obstruction to that, then it becomes the priority to remove him. If he doesn’t, we get to make the county better… That’s the entire reason we need progressives in power in the first place
Exactly…What does removing Jefferies give us right now? The momentary satisfaction of firing him? He’s one asshole among many
It doesn’t matter who sits in the fancy chair, what matters is the work.
We need to unfuck our country, and if it means letting Jefferies get on the progressive bandwagon and save his political career, fine.
If it means we need to oust Schumer, fantastic, but not because of how satisfying it’ll be - it’s because Schumer is a major obstacle to the work.
Everything that doesn’t move us closer to our goals is a distraction.
So why do this now? Starting a fight with Jefferies at this stage would be a distraction. He’s met with progressive leaders and they were convinced them he’d work with them, and a cooperative Jefferies is the best case scenario (for now) - it means a more cohesive voting block and a scapegoat to take the heat while progressives will claim the victories
Jefferies will get a chance to improve his popularity and maybe continue his political career beyond his next election, but he’s a weak leader and has no charisma. He can’t be trusted, but he can be used and safely set aside when the time comes
Currently keeping Jefferies is to our advantage. When that changes, we change Jefferies
Compromise means we get something and weegxve something. What are we saying we get? Plum committee assignments in return for no progressive bill ever passing the House?
Imma keep it real with you Jeffries, I’m going to extend the exact same forgiveness I get from my boss when I miss big work responsibilities because I had trouble with the bus: exactly none. Be at work on time, and then police motorcades won’t be a problem.
Besides; we pay these motherfuckers full time to be at work maybe 5 full months out of the year?? Make it make sense.
Ostensibly so* they don’t take bribes. Realistically, they take
bribesquid pro quo.I’m up at 5:30 every day, I don’t start work 'till 8. By the time I get to sit down after work, it’s 8 pm at least. There is absolutely no excuse for missing a vote. You leave yourself plenty of time to get there, then you don’t have to worry about being late.
This. If I have a downtime, I have to be there on time. Full stop.
Blue no matter who! It will definitely work!
My god he is pathetic.
Looking for clarification on something:
If this vote happened and Hegseth was impeached, couldn’t Trump and the current GOP Senate just back-fill his cabinet position before January with no opposition from Democrats?
In other words, wouldn’t it be better to impeach after Democrats have control of Senate where there is a 51 confirmation requirement?
It doesn’t matter it takes 67 senate votes to convict, he can’t be removed either now or later. The point of the vote was whether Massie gets to make everybody in the House go on record voting whether they support illegally starting two wars, murdering 200 elementary school children, and massacring Caribbean fishermen under no quarter. Which is why a lot of these Democrats sat it out, they were the ones cheering Hegseth on when he did all that shit and don’t want to have to stand by it now that they’ve noticed the peasants are unhappy.
A) Now that the articles have been introduced they can be brought up for a demand vote by the Speaker at any time, including in January when the speaker chances.
B) This is about creating and destroying political capital, as the other user said. Those 11 dems now explicitly endorse Pete Hegseth and the Trump regime, including all of its crimes. It’s on record now, and that record will be used by both republicans and dems against them when they’re up for reelection. It’s a vote to show your hand and your donors.
For (B) I still don’t quite get it because, for example, Pelosi is a lame duck retiring anyway come January. What did she have to lose by voting Yes for posterity, especially when substantively it would’ve led to nothing happened given the Senate vote threshold?
Pretty obvious how badly this looks – I mean Hegseth is pretty universally unliked.
What did she have to lose? Her fortune, her family’s assets, any and all legitimacy she has. While you say she’s a lame duck, she’s still ‘respected’ by representatives in power. By making this stance clear, it’s another thing that can be used against representatives that think Pelosi and her choices have any positive impact on democrats or society - aka, it’s a cudgel people can hit AOC on the head with the next time she tries to defer to centrist dems on something.
Pelosi might be gone, but her legacy of ‘raising’ junior reps is not, and those junior reps, for ‘some’ reason keep doing her bidding even when it goes against the mandate they were elected for.
It would be nice if Pelosi just went the fuck away. She has done irreparable harm and aided facism at every turn.
Wasn’t this some sort of play by Republicans to try and sneak a vote in, which is why a bunch of people couldn’t make it? Correct me if im wrong.
Seems like something designed to make progressives look bad for asking for representation in government. Isreal must be shitting their pants about losing control of the wheel.
No, not really. This vote was scheduled a couple days in advance, so everyone had time to figure out how to get there on time. One of the Democrats that missed the vote blamed a traffic jam, but a reporter saw him on the capital steps several minutes before the deadline. He could have easily just walked inside and cast his vote before the deadline, but just… didn’t.
“Missed”
They are on a rotation. They have already figured out who to sacrifice based on if they’re up for reelection or not, and whomever they chose because they can afford to take the heat.
It’s all a game. It’s a big club and you ain’t in it. They pay by rules you don’t even know exist. Decisions are made behind closed doors, and we are told there was a vote or whatever. The truth is not out there, it’s locked behind a FOIA request that gets denied or redacted beyond recognition.
Jeffries is in charge right now until January, you think he doesn’t have the votes already in place? He will try to stay in power at any cost.
Why would they initiate a vote now, before all the new people get sworn in?
Soundbites, attention, etc. These people aren’t politicians, they’re just actors kayfabing as leaders
A republican initiated the impeachment, and he won’t be there next year.
This is so dumb.
There was a massive traffic clusterfuck that delayed a busload of Democrats from returning from an event across town (multiple Republicans also got delayed). This included some of the loudest Democratic supporters of the effort.
The House GOP exploited this by closing the vote as soon as they had the majority; if it had been the other way around, they would have just held it open for hours until they had enough votes to defeat it. The absent Dems didn’t actually change the outcome.
This specific vote was driven by outgoing Republican Thomas Massie, there’s nothing preventing Democrats from introducing their own in January. In fact it’s arguably better – an impeachment now would have managers appointed by Republicans and go before a Republican-controlled Senate. I’d much rather have Democratic managers and 56 Democrats in the Senate. Especially if Hegseth somehow is fired or resigns and Trump is able to appoint a new Defense Secretary with the current Senate.
Even in the case of a 2027 impeachment though, you’d still need 11 Senate Republicans to vote to convict (12 if Fetterman defects), which is extremely unlikely given who’s left in the caucus. This whole effort is ultimately symbolic, not something with a real shot at removing Hegseth.
Acting like this was some nefarious plot by AIPAC to maintain the war is absurd.
One of them already admitted there was no traffic jam.
Maybe some of you don’t realize this, but while I don’t like the Dem party, this is clearly news bait to drive a wedge in the left.
The vote wasn’t whether or not to impeach, it was whether or not to move the impeachment to committee.
It was also called short, before Dems that COULD’VE been present could arrive.
The GOP loves playing games, this is them playing games and you’re falling for it.
Definitely wasn’t called short, I watched it happen. It was a 5 minute vote, the vote was known about the day before, and even after the 5 minutes was up they still let people vote.
If all the GOP and all the Dems voted, then the Dems would have failed by 2 votes. But 7 GOP didn’t vote while 11 Dems didn’t vote. Dems could have struck down the effort to send the impeachment to committee, but they couldn’t even bother to show up for work.
I don’t give a shit what excuses they had, I don’t get to make excuses to miss work during critical moments, why the fuck should our overpaid reps get different treatment? Especially when all I’m doing most of the time is enshittifying a website for some corpo shmuck, meanwhile these fucking people are supposed to be running our country!!!
This is just another example of why DSA and progressives built up so much momentum in the midterms. The neolib establishment dems are utterly useless in the face of real progress.
Pasting my comment from a similar reply…
Your diatribe is exactly my point. I’m not onboard for Jeffries. I emailed my future Blue rep asking her to oust him from leadership. But sadly, we have to work with corpo dems to get anything done until they are all gone.
My point is these types of articles fit in with the GOP strategy, to cause rifts in the “left”
Quotes on “left” because of pedants, who keep yelling at me that there is no “left” in the USA.
The only wedge this drives though is with the vast masses against the corporatist zionist wing of the party…which IMO is the energy people need to keep up.
I don’t know of any meaningful constituency of voters that is out there angry that people are getting mad at Hailey Stevens for making her dreams of Israel come true and up and leaving, or Nancy Pelosi ironically skipping the vote to end an illegal and unjust war to get a lifetime achievement award from a veterans organization.
If I missed a crucial meeting at my work that was pivotal for positioning the future of the company, I would expect to reprimanded far more consequentially than some mean words.
Sadly, progressives will have to work with corpo dems to make anything happen. At least it’s possible to sway them…
It’s not possible to sway the Repubs in Congress for the most part.
I’m sorry we don’t live in an ideal world but these type of news articles produce apathy, which is the enemy of progress.
Ah yes, the good ol’ Centrist war cry of “But Repbulicans are mean so let’s not try at all!”.
Maybe stop being a coward always worrying about what Republicans will do and worry about what Democrats should do.
I’ve said nothing to do with whatever you are arguing about.
Your anger at me is my point exactly
I read your second line as the indicating why centrists would be not passing things progressives would be proposing.
If that’s not what your intent was then I do apologize.
And the way you change that overton window and shift those pressures leftward is thru sustained outside pressure
Corporate Dems have no real incentive to betray their actual constituents, donors, especially when their former main lovers(tech oligarchs and Israel) are sending all the signals their pocketbooks will open back up for them if they play nice, and if voters as a whole just go back to brunch, guess who easily wins that influence battle?
So while there is a type of corporate media propaganda that I think undermines the left, this is one of those rare instances I think this sort of coverage is actually helping. As it is keeping focus on who the villains inside the tent are and that they can’t be trusted(which they can’t). And right now they are banking on people going quiet and falling in line so they can maneuver behind the scenes and preserve their power and the status quo dynamic.
Ok
Cool, more democrats-in-disarray being played up by the “liberal media”.
Headlines like this seem to be missing some rather important details.
This is the type of thing having Jeffries in charge will constantly enable because he is incapable of doing the job.
I think people are getting a little too up in arms about this whole thing. This is still the 119th Congress, the same one we’ve had for two years. Impeachment was always a long shot until the 120th is seated.
I actually don’t like that move by Massie because if there’s enough public pressure against a cabinet member then Trump may be inclined to fire them and get a replacement in while he still potentially has the votes to confirm them. That would end in January.
No, NOW is the time to put as much pressure on the Democrats as possible. There’s zero reason to wait.
Get up and arms NOW, and EVERY SINGLE TIME they let us down.
If they keep fucking up, then primary them in 2 years and replace them with someone that will actually show up to work.
The reason to wait is that if the administration sees enough public pressure then Trump could fire cabinet members and potentially squeeze in a replacement while he still has the Senate. We want any removals to happen after January when Democrats will have control of the confirmation.
Yeah, because waiting on Trump to do the right thing is such a great strategy.
Massie helped show which Dems are willing to be controlled opposition with this move though. I’ll give him that.
We need to keep calling our reps and demand that they don’t vote for Schumer or Jeffries.
Massie continues to stick to his guns and I’ll give him that.
And the leader of the Democrats in the 119th Congress is bidding for leadership of the 120th Congress. The point of impeachment being a long shot isn’t the issue here, the fact that Massie introduced it isn’t the issue here, the fact that it was a quick turn around for this vote to advance it isn’t the issue here.
The issue is the complete failure of the 119th Congress’ Democratic leadership when your job is to ensure that on important votes, you make sure that your members are there to vote for it. When you ensure everyone can make time to advance a shitty bill that neuters the Clean Water act then you can damn well ensure that on the vote to advance impeachment of a guy who you’ve constantly said was unfit for the job, you make damn well sure that everyone is there to vote and not pussyfooting around getting stuck in traffic. And that same failure of a leader is running for the leadership of the 120th Congress too so no, we are right to be up in arms about this because if you can’t be arsed to do you damn job now, you aren’t going to be arsed to do the job latter when it actually matters.
The failure from Democrats pisses me off too and I hope to see somebody else as Speaker than Jeffries.
But in the end it was functionally irrelevant to the vote. There were also Republicans held up for the same reason as Democrats, and if they had all voted it still would have failed. Johnson would have extended the vote because he’s still Speaker and the Republicans still have control of the House.
This was just a mic drop by Massie on his way out. We were always going to have to wait until January for meaningful things to start happening.
Not necessarily. Impeachments are privileged and handled differently than a regular bill. This was not a vote on the impeachment itself; this was a vote on whether to send it to committee (where it would obviously time out and die) or to advance it to a full floor vote. Eleven Dems and seven Rs skipped the vote, and it passed 211 to 204.
But had ALL the Dems showed up, the vote on sending it to committee would have passed by too narrow a margin, and the process would have automatically progressed the eight articles of impeachment to a floor vote.
They COULD have pulled a win out of a loss, forcing each member of the House to vote on the articles of impeachment individually and thus be seen for what they are, and chose not to.
And again, the fact that Republicans were also stuck in some traffic doesn’t matter. The fact that the vote you think was irrelevant doesn’t matter. The fact that Johnson is still Speaker doesn’t matter. The fact that Massie wanted to have a final say really doesn’t matter.
All of that is just excuses and whataboutism doesn’t address the point that the current leader failed in providing leadership on a important vote, especially when the vote failed by a mere seven votes.
Massie is leaving in January and I guess he counted on some GOP members taking their shot at distancing from Maga after the midterm results.
Yeah, and turns out they didn’t.
Sign in to comment. Sign in