0
Warning: NextDNS causes major DNS leak
It apprears that NextDNS has removed No Google, No Facebook, and other blocklist without notifying users. One person said the NSA blocklist was also down. The company had made no responses to complaints on the community server when I checked earlier. Crickets…
I noticed Android and Linux being unable to access the app and web interface to confirm connections, starting some time on November 4th. I was able to switch DNS providers on Android and switch back, after which NextDNS seemed to work. On Linux however, systemd confirmed it was enabled but it went right to google’s webpage with no block.
If you’re on NextDNS, go check your domain filters ASAP. I switched to RethinkDNS, and it’s been decent so far. What is everyones preferred solution?
Comments
Host your own.
Bet your ass I will now!
Best practice is to host 2 PiHole instances, if 1 DNS sinkhole fails you can fallback to another one (Primary & Secondary DNS Server) that way you don’t lose internet access.
Certainly read and try to interpret the documents as best as you can, I suggest going the Docker Compose route for hosting as it’s quite straight forward and a great tool to learn if you want to selfhost other software, fiddle around with 1 DNS sinkhole before you jump head first into getting the second one up though.
Thanks for this suggestion. I’m taking your advice and have ordered two servers. Should have them soon. So do I just use a Linux OS like Diet Pi with a Docker container using pihole for domain filtering and then run another container with Unbound for DNS resolving?
How did you do it?
IMO if you want aggressive blocklists that the average person might get frustrated by like no google then running adguard home for yourself is the way to go.
I think I’m going to try redunant Pi Holes and maybe have one agressive for me and a fallback less aggressive for family members who can’t be bothered with the inconvenience of not funding fascists by using Facebook. My fallback would be less agressive one while it would be their primary. Just an idea. We’ll see how it goes.
Got two servers on the way!
That’s what I do essentially, the less aggressive one is just the build in DNS adblock on my Unifi router, and my own is Adguard home running a bunch of blocklists for my devices only.
From their git closed tickets:
NSA: https://github.com/nextdns/blocklists/pull/105
Google and Facebook:
https://github.com/nextdns/blocklists/issues/235
From the git activity (diff linked in case anyone wants to copy and paste):
Google and Facebook: https://github.com/nextdns/blocklists/compare/8e36cfa267930a7dba8e27b0501e199c8a02b0b3...439d8b5a053aab0f93a7ad4341798ebfd1f17a0b
I can’t see a lot of this. Might be MS outage.
Edit: Also, thanks for posting these. I’ll check them out later.
The long and the short is that those blocklists were unmaintained for years and one of them was tied to a person nextdns doesn’t like (I don’t know, I didn’t read it because I don’t care).
That’s the real problem with set-and-forget dns blocklisting, it has to be someone’s job to keep the lists up to date. That person could become compromised, change their guiding principles or just stop working on the thing you rely on.
I shifted to ControlD long time ago and have been very satisfied. Also it is a Canada company instead of a US company.
I have recently cancelled my subscription with them. I have learnt that their setup is not HA (because their outage took my internet with it for a bit) and you can’t make it HA either, you get assigned to 1 endpoint and if that’s down your DNS is gone, even when they have loads of other working endpoints around you (and their suggestion to this is to add a different DNS as a fallback). Frustrating, as I did like their service for the price.
Kind of even more annoying was that while I was their customer I couldn’t get through their AI support bot to a person to just raise this as a problem and get a proper response, but as soon as I cancelled an actual human reached out to ask why.
My Pihole couldn’t reach all the old NextDNS blocklists I subscribe to a few days ago. Makes sense now.
Bummer! Thanks for the heads up.
We should be able to manually enter them all. We should save them while we still can.
I just fork all the repos of lists I use in github and created a repo for my personal blocklist and blacklist and have my AGH pull from those. That way they keep updated, if one of them fucks up I can always go back a version (same thing if any of them disappear). It’s been working great.
Might want to use Codeberg or Disroot since MS owns github. I can’t see jack in github presently with all the outages.
I swear if I was an MS employee who had been laid off, I’d ask for a 100% raise to be hired back on as a consultant and with a 5 year contract.
Yeah, for my own projwcts I use codeberg and gitlab, but for easy of maintaining the forks I keep the lists on github. I do keep them mirrored on codeberg as well, but I’ve been too lazy to change the URLs in my AGH lately.
I need to follow your suggestion and get it done, for sure.
This is a privacy Lemmy group, why are people using a third party DNS server? There is Adgaurd Home, I do not use it I tried it but did not like it more than the alternative but I hear people like it. There is also Pi-Hole, I do use this and I have finally tuned it. I actually have pihole’s one for primary DNS and one for secondary DNS.
*edit: I should appologize I should really have noticed the pihole was my gateway service into self hosting and privacy. It took years for me to notice how additing the simple ad blocking was and than some movements for me to start moving more services to self hosted. I just realized it has only been months that I have set up my firewall, and now I just cannot believe I have ever lived without it.
“I am a fucking genius. Let me teach these fuckers how it’s done and save humanity once and for all”.
That doesn’t work, makes you look like a prick, and you are not helping anyone.
We have all come in here, and otherr places, asking for help from people that have already crossed the red sea, this is exactly what the OP and some others are doing.
As a community we’re supposed to help, thus giving back some of what was given (and may be given in the future) to us by others.
Seems like that’s an alien concept for you, uh?
He redeemed himself in an edit. I’m always cool if someone takes a step back to reflect. No worries.
Thanks for having my back!
You should realize that your piholes call to 3rd party DNS servers unless you use something like unbound which queries root DNS servers.
And by the way, those root queries are unencrypted too.
So when you say root DNS servers, does that mean the ones we host? Or Unbound just updates resolvers by using queries to external DNS servers?
So instead of querying a recursive dns service like cloudflare or google you query the 13 root DNS servers such as https://a.root-servers.org/
This way no data goes through 3rd parties. However, this is a poor idea since none of the root servers support encrypted DNS queries.
You can use DoH or DoT. DoT already has its own port 853 which can be firewall blocked. So then DoH can be harder to block because it uses port 443 same as HTTPS hence the name.
So the best way of doing it is either using ODoH which uses a proxy to ask on your behalf, but the proxy knows your IP address.
DNS privacy is in my opinion a farce because someone knows your IP address and someone knows your queries. The best way is to hide in numbers and the external promise of no logs queries.
So for me, I just pick the fastest encrypted no logging DNS servers. And the top 3 for my location is
https://dns.nextdns.io/
https://freedns.controld.com/uncensored
https://95.85.95.85/dns-query
I used this tool to help pick the fastest encrypted servers.
https://center2055.github.io/DNS-Hop/
Good luck and happy labbing
I use e/OS on my phone with a fake IP address. I wonder if an integrated IP spoofing tool would get the job done.
If you change often then maybe. But with header and java script, a fingerprint could be made.
Sign in to comment. Sign in