This thread is depressing. I am always sad to find out how widespread AI usage is still even. You can live your life with so little AI usage and should. Programmers have put so many industries in these tiny, fragile little bubbles.
I’m a musician and it ruined music for me because a lot of musicians are also “just using a little to alleviate the crunch” or whatever. It’s all manufactured consent to fund companies that were all jockeying for Trump money the last two years.
But now it supports the Trump military AND it’s ruined the market for digital artists.
The primary use case for House House’s use of LLMs was to research, via chatbots, issues we encountered with third-party code. If you’re technically-minded, and curious, here’s an example. We needed to cull shadow casters by distance from the camera, but Unity URP only allows culling shadow casters by distance in camera forwards, so shadow casters behind the player were being rendered at an infinite distance. This made our game run 50% slower for around 20 seconds at sunrise and sunset. We researched the problem extensively, and we looked at the URP code ourselves, but we couldn’t find a way. Then, we were able to speak directly to an engineer at Unity, who asked around and ultimately concluded that what we wanted wasn’t possible. Finally, we posed the question to an LLM chatbot. After a few dead ends, it suggested a possible fix, and while we had to modify the suggestion extensively, it worked. This fix represented about 10 lines of code inside URP.
asking a LLM for a fix that added about ten lines of code after heavily modifying the LLM output is exactly how AI should be used. They exhausted all other options and still had to tinker with the LLM code to make it work. if that’s not real coding, idk what real coding is anymore
for those that don’t approve of this, why? just curious, no hate 🙂
If that’s the extent of their AI use then that’s fine I mean that’s basically just googling stuff on steroids. That’s all I ever use AI for.
This is why I find Valves AI disclosure tag to be slightly problematic, I don’t think it really drills down enough to define what “AI used in this game” means, so then it’s up to the individual developer to make a value judgment and not everyone will agree with where they particularly draw the line. We need a line in the sand that everyone can agree upon or at least everyone understands.
On a side note, how on Earth does unity not have the ability to cull shadows that are outside of the view frostrum, that’s unbelievably stupid. I’m pretty sure City Skylines 2 has a similar issue.
Valve’s disclosure policy is very specific. It’s about visual assets (models and textures), audio (music and VA), script writing (not explicitly translation or subtitling either), and that’s it. There is no requirement to disclose AI-assisted, AI-researched, or fully AI-generated code.
The assets stuff also is specifically about the final game. If a studio uses AI for placeholders and doesn’t ship them in the actual Steam game, it’s not required to disclose that process.
In this case, this AI usage in on the Unity team. House House is paying for Unity support, and got no help (wouldn’t be surprised if the help itself was also AI, but a different model), then had to rely on LLMs. It’s a systemic issue: game developers are relying on a small number of game engine vendors, that can push for enshittifying pretty easily without much repercussion.
It’s never about their use case. Its about how ai steals everything in order to provide any answer at all, and how destructive even providing that answer ends up being.
This might seem reasonable on its face, but who did the LLM company steal the answer from without accreditation? Who’s neighbourhood is being ruined by the data centre?
It’s that ultimately there is no ethical use of LLMs
Well id argue local llms + don’t support the people making them is probably fine, so long as you’re not letting it do web searches constantly so you aren’t ddosing the internet.
They absolutely do. Just because you took the plagiarism machine offline after it stole everything and then destroyed ecosystems and neighborhoods to produce the resulting dataset doesn’t mean it’s any better than the fascist empowering online ones. It’s exactly the same. Being ever so slightly better because you’re using your own power from the power company instead of someone else isn’t worth the destruction caused to get to a point where your offline sycophant machine can sometimes confidently not lie to you.
How? I’m not paying any of the companies or supporting the people who made it in any way. This is the equivalent of a vegan eating some meat that was about to be thrown in the trash. I’m also only using it for coding some personal use slop anyway, and most of the stolen code was GPL / MIT license which means for personal use there isn’t even a license issue. Me using it offline and telling everyone not to pay for it and that the data scraping is terrible is nowhere near the same as someone paying and supporting these companies.
Google search is using AI at this point, but prior to that should summarize popular results when it wasn’t just pointing at SEO’ed crap or various stack-overflow/EE/Quora articles.
AI for a similar purpose - finding and collating publicly available information - seems ok to me. I’m more interested in the various solutions I’ve contributed online being available and useful to somebody than attrition.
But if course the models themselves are built on a lot more than that, unfortunately. Still, AI doing basic search and analysis to provide suggestions versus actually writing the core software seems like a good evolution of “search” functionality
As a developer, I really think the reactionary response to AI is muddying the waters. Their stated use-case seems perfectly reasonable, as their options were “shit optimization with even the unity devs clueless” or fixing the bug. AI makes a great tool for some applications. No, it should not be used to vibecode entire apps alone, but it does have the power to search and aggregate sources far, far better than humans can. It will likely take some tweaking afterwards, because their output must not be trusted, but using AI as a research tool for solving esoteric dev problems seems perfectly reasonable to me. I would much prefer we not punish the people that are fully disclosing their (very limited) use, when many of the competitors simply aren’t disclosing.
Developers House House told Aftermath via email that “LLMs were used sparingly by House House to help work through difficult technical challenges and bugs”, and that they “estimate that well under 0.1% of Big Walk’s code had anything to do with this usage”.
Meh, if that were enough to exclude a game from GotY awards, you’d end up with a very short list of mostly unknown games, half of which probably did use LLMs for those sorts of tasks and are just lying about it.
And honestly, if AI-debugging can replace having to spend days of horrible crunchtime fixing those bugs, I’m all for it! That’s what AI should do, making people’s lives easier and not replacing their creativity.
Nah, I didn’t imply anything of the sort. First up, I was never talking about “people who say they hate AI”, but game developers. Second, I never said or implied that they would be “embarassed”. They don’t disclose it because there’s no benefit to disclosing it, as should be very apparent here.
Let me spell it out as clear as possible: The vast majority of commercial game developers use AI in some ways. Most don’t vibecode, but using it for the kinds of things that House House did is ubiquitous. Modern development tools like Visual Studio use it in ways where you might not even realise that an LLM is behind it.
You don’t have to take my word for it: Look at the sites that were essential resources to get help with bugs before LLMs were around, like StackOverflow. Its usage has declined by over 99% since 2020. Unless you know of another place where people now ask all their development questions, I think we can both take a pretty educated guess of where they went.
I think the example cases they’ve provided are pretty good example of where an LLM can actually be useful. For example, if you need to find and fix a bug in third-party code, it can be an absolute pain, as just getting a basic understanding of an unknown codebase by yourself could take days or weeks. An LLM can analyze the code in seconds and if not fix the bug, at the very least point out locations where to look for it. It’s not necessarily about telling the LLM to overcome the technical challenge by itself, but it can definitely assist in it.
I’ve just started to ignore those “AI slop” parrots. There’s nothing you can say to them to change their minds similar to how a religious person believes their religion is the correct one.
Comments
This thread is depressing. I am always sad to find out how widespread AI usage is still even. You can live your life with so little AI usage and should. Programmers have put so many industries in these tiny, fragile little bubbles.
I’m a musician and it ruined music for me because a lot of musicians are also “just using a little to alleviate the crunch” or whatever. It’s all manufactured consent to fund companies that were all jockeying for Trump money the last two years.
But now it supports the Trump military AND it’s ruined the market for digital artists.
asking a LLM for a fix that added about ten lines of code after heavily modifying the LLM output is exactly how AI should be used. They exhausted all other options and still had to tinker with the LLM code to make it work. if that’s not real coding, idk what real coding is anymore
for those that don’t approve of this, why? just curious, no hate 🙂
If that’s the extent of their AI use then that’s fine I mean that’s basically just googling stuff on steroids. That’s all I ever use AI for.
This is why I find Valves AI disclosure tag to be slightly problematic, I don’t think it really drills down enough to define what “AI used in this game” means, so then it’s up to the individual developer to make a value judgment and not everyone will agree with where they particularly draw the line. We need a line in the sand that everyone can agree upon or at least everyone understands.
On a side note, how on Earth does unity not have the ability to cull shadows that are outside of the view frostrum, that’s unbelievably stupid. I’m pretty sure City Skylines 2 has a similar issue.
Valve’s disclosure policy is very specific. It’s about visual assets (models and textures), audio (music and VA), script writing (not explicitly translation or subtitling either), and that’s it. There is no requirement to disclose AI-assisted, AI-researched, or fully AI-generated code.
The assets stuff also is specifically about the final game. If a studio uses AI for placeholders and doesn’t ship them in the actual Steam game, it’s not required to disclose that process.
Seems like it’s just punishing devs that know they used AI for something not typically considered “AI use”, but are honest enough to admit it.
Would be nice to see what parts were tagged with AI so people could make their own judgements.
In this case, this AI usage in on the Unity team. House House is paying for Unity support, and got no help (wouldn’t be surprised if the help itself was also AI, but a different model), then had to rely on LLMs. It’s a systemic issue: game developers are relying on a small number of game engine vendors, that can push for enshittifying pretty easily without much repercussion.
It’s never about their use case. Its about how ai steals everything in order to provide any answer at all, and how destructive even providing that answer ends up being.
This might seem reasonable on its face, but who did the LLM company steal the answer from without accreditation? Who’s neighbourhood is being ruined by the data centre?
It’s that ultimately there is no ethical use of LLMs
Well id argue local llms + don’t support the people making them is probably fine, so long as you’re not letting it do web searches constantly so you aren’t ddosing the internet.
They absolutely do. Just because you took the plagiarism machine offline after it stole everything and then destroyed ecosystems and neighborhoods to produce the resulting dataset doesn’t mean it’s any better than the fascist empowering online ones. It’s exactly the same. Being ever so slightly better because you’re using your own power from the power company instead of someone else isn’t worth the destruction caused to get to a point where your offline sycophant machine can sometimes confidently not lie to you.
How? I’m not paying any of the companies or supporting the people who made it in any way. This is the equivalent of a vegan eating some meat that was about to be thrown in the trash. I’m also only using it for coding some personal use slop anyway, and most of the stolen code was GPL / MIT license which means for personal use there isn’t even a license issue. Me using it offline and telling everyone not to pay for it and that the data scraping is terrible is nowhere near the same as someone paying and supporting these companies.
This. I’d love to see how a model trained 100% on resources that are out of copyright or permissive licensing might actually work out.
There’s actually a lot of historical media and plenty of code that could qualify
Google search is using AI at this point, but prior to that should summarize popular results when it wasn’t just pointing at SEO’ed crap or various stack-overflow/EE/Quora articles.
AI for a similar purpose - finding and collating publicly available information - seems ok to me. I’m more interested in the various solutions I’ve contributed online being available and useful to somebody than attrition.
But if course the models themselves are built on a lot more than that, unfortunately. Still, AI doing basic search and analysis to provide suggestions versus actually writing the core software seems like a good evolution of “search” functionality
Almost all content providers would disagree. Anyway, I don’t use Google because of this.
Because this site is filled with butthurt programmers lol
As a developer, I really think the reactionary response to AI is muddying the waters. Their stated use-case seems perfectly reasonable, as their options were “shit optimization with even the unity devs clueless” or fixing the bug. AI makes a great tool for some applications. No, it should not be used to vibecode entire apps alone, but it does have the power to search and aggregate sources far, far better than humans can. It will likely take some tweaking afterwards, because their output must not be trusted, but using AI as a research tool for solving esoteric dev problems seems perfectly reasonable to me. I would much prefer we not punish the people that are fully disclosing their (very limited) use, when many of the competitors simply aren’t disclosing.
Meh, if that were enough to exclude a game from GotY awards, you’d end up with a very short list of mostly unknown games, half of which probably did use LLMs for those sorts of tasks and are just lying about it.
And honestly, if AI-debugging can replace having to spend days of horrible crunchtime fixing those bugs, I’m all for it! That’s what AI should do, making people’s lives easier and not replacing their creativity.
“Everyone who says they hate AI is actually using it and embarrassed” is THE biggest cope I’ve ever read.
I guess so, but I’m not sure where you’ve read it because I sure haven’t written it.
That’s complete bullshit lmao you heavily implied it. You’re such a tool.
Nah, I didn’t imply anything of the sort. First up, I was never talking about “people who say they hate AI”, but game developers. Second, I never said or implied that they would be “embarassed”. They don’t disclose it because there’s no benefit to disclosing it, as should be very apparent here.
Let me spell it out as clear as possible: The vast majority of commercial game developers use AI in some ways. Most don’t vibecode, but using it for the kinds of things that House House did is ubiquitous. Modern development tools like Visual Studio use it in ways where you might not even realise that an LLM is behind it.
You don’t have to take my word for it: Look at the sites that were essential resources to get help with bugs before LLMs were around, like StackOverflow. Its usage has declined by over 99% since 2020. Unless you know of another place where people now ask all their development questions, I think we can both take a pretty educated guess of where they went.
“Difficult technical challenges and bugs” is what I find AI is the worst at in my experience.
I think the example cases they’ve provided are pretty good example of where an LLM can actually be useful. For example, if you need to find and fix a bug in third-party code, it can be an absolute pain, as just getting a basic understanding of an unknown codebase by yourself could take days or weeks. An LLM can analyze the code in seconds and if not fix the bug, at the very least point out locations where to look for it. It’s not necessarily about telling the LLM to overcome the technical challenge by itself, but it can definitely assist in it.
I’ve just started to ignore those “AI slop” parrots. There’s nothing you can say to them to change their minds similar to how a religious person believes their religion is the correct one.
Sign in to comment. Sign in