You misunderstand, from my perspective it’s the trolley problem. You’re just the guy tied to the other tracks.
The main difference is that I can’t actually sacrifice you to save people on the organ donor waiting list, I can only tell you that that is the correct solution and hope you act accordingly.
A healthy person isn’t at risk of immediate death.
This is a choice between 1 dying or 5. A healthy person isn’t about to die.
The equivalent medical situation would be if you were seconds from absolutely certain death and someone took your organs without consent a moment before death.
Yep. This is a choice between allowing five people to die, or killing one to save them. The trolley problem doesn’t talk about healthy or not healthy. It’s a very simple equivalent: do we let people on the organ donor waiting list die, or do we kill you to save them?
The correct choice is to kill one person to save five, as you pointed out. You just happen to be the one person who must be killed. If I had a switch that I could flip, and you would die and your organs would be given to people that need them, I would be flipping that switch. Unfortunately, I do not have that switch, and you must carry out the dying part yourself by your own free will.
Do you no longer think the correct answer is to kill one to save five? What happened?
But you introduced healthy or not healthy by changing the trolley problem into sacrificing a healthy person to save 5 unhealthy people.
In the trolley problem one person is going to die if the switch isn’t thrown. In your organ donation problem, the healthy person is not going to die. It’s no longer the same trolley problem.
Comments
Ya know, if we butcher you for spare parts, we can save a few people on the donor waiting list.
What the hell are you waiting for? Seven pounds yourself.
That’s not the trolley problem. That’s Batman jumping in front of the train to save 5.
You misunderstand, from my perspective it’s the trolley problem. You’re just the guy tied to the other tracks.
The main difference is that I can’t actually sacrifice you to save people on the organ donor waiting list, I can only tell you that that is the correct solution and hope you act accordingly.
A healthy person isn’t at risk of immediate death.
This is a choice between 1 dying or 5. A healthy person isn’t about to die.
The equivalent medical situation would be if you were seconds from absolutely certain death and someone took your organs without consent a moment before death.
Yep. This is a choice between allowing five people to die, or killing one to save them. The trolley problem doesn’t talk about healthy or not healthy. It’s a very simple equivalent: do we let people on the organ donor waiting list die, or do we kill you to save them?
The correct choice is to kill one person to save five, as you pointed out. You just happen to be the one person who must be killed. If I had a switch that I could flip, and you would die and your organs would be given to people that need them, I would be flipping that switch. Unfortunately, I do not have that switch, and you must carry out the dying part yourself by your own free will.
Do you no longer think the correct answer is to kill one to save five? What happened?
But you introduced healthy or not healthy by changing the trolley problem into sacrificing a healthy person to save 5 unhealthy people.
In the trolley problem one person is going to die if the switch isn’t thrown. In your organ donation problem, the healthy person is not going to die. It’s no longer the same trolley problem.
Sign in to comment. Sign in