But what if there are 3 sinking boats, 1 has a person you must save but the other 2 boats only have a goat on board, and you don’t know which is which. You chose 1, and it’s revealed that one of the other 2 has a goat. Do you stick to the boat you chose hoping that it has the person, or do you change to the other unknown boat?
Here’s the way I see it. At the start, there are three scenarios. The person is equally likely to be on boat 1, boat 2, or boat 3. Say you pick boat 1, you have a 1/3rd chance of being correct. Then, the goat revealer comes along. They only reveal a boat with a goat that is not the boat you’ve picked. Which means they’re never able to eliminate the possibility of the person being on your chosen boat, but can do it for the other two. When boat 2 is revealed to have a goat, the possibility of a person being on boat 2 is eliminated, and the possibility of a person being on boat 3 is not eliminated when it could have been. The possibility of the person being on boat 1 remains unaffected. The 2/3rds initial chance of the person being in another boat remains unaffected, so the probability pools into the remaining unpicked boat. At least, that is how it works in the monty hall problem.
It’s different if the goat could be revealed in any boat (including the one you picked) or if the goat is not always revealed, or so on. The goat reveal has to have other information behind it for it to not collapse the possibilities to 50/50.
It starts with a 1/3 chance and they only show you the door if it is the wrong answer. So your first choice was 1/3 and stays that way but the other door becomes a 2/3 chance.
I still think it is weird that it works that way, but that is how it goes.
This one becomes very intuitive if you change it from 3 doors to 100.
You’re on a game show with a bag of cash behind one door. You pick #42 because you’re a geek. Then your host, who knows where the money is, walks down the line of doors, opening door #1, #2, #3, all the way up to #100, only skipping #54.
So which door is the money behind? The one you picked as a shot in the dark at a 1/100 chance, or the one the person with real information chose to avoid out of the 99 others? Pretty obvious now, right?
Comments
But what if there are 3 sinking boats, 1 has a person you must save but the other 2 boats only have a goat on board, and you don’t know which is which. You chose 1, and it’s revealed that one of the other 2 has a goat. Do you stick to the boat you chose hoping that it has the person, or do you change to the other unknown boat?
You always switch for reasons I forget. Stupid fucking doors.
Here’s the way I see it. At the start, there are three scenarios. The person is equally likely to be on boat 1, boat 2, or boat 3. Say you pick boat 1, you have a 1/3rd chance of being correct. Then, the goat revealer comes along. They only reveal a boat with a goat that is not the boat you’ve picked. Which means they’re never able to eliminate the possibility of the person being on your chosen boat, but can do it for the other two. When boat 2 is revealed to have a goat, the possibility of a person being on boat 2 is eliminated, and the possibility of a person being on boat 3 is not eliminated when it could have been. The possibility of the person being on boat 1 remains unaffected. The 2/3rds initial chance of the person being in another boat remains unaffected, so the probability pools into the remaining unpicked boat. At least, that is how it works in the monty hall problem.
It’s different if the goat could be revealed in any boat (including the one you picked) or if the goat is not always revealed, or so on. The goat reveal has to have other information behind it for it to not collapse the possibilities to 50/50.
It is a math thing.
It starts with a 1/3 chance and they only show you the door if it is the wrong answer. So your first choice was 1/3 and stays that way but the other door becomes a 2/3 chance.
I still think it is weird that it works that way, but that is how it goes.
This one becomes very intuitive if you change it from 3 doors to 100.
You’re on a game show with a bag of cash behind one door. You pick #42 because you’re a geek. Then your host, who knows where the money is, walks down the line of doors, opening door #1, #2, #3, all the way up to #100, only skipping #54.
So which door is the money behind? The one you picked as a shot in the dark at a 1/100 chance, or the one the person with real information chose to avoid out of the 99 others? Pretty obvious now, right?
Sign in to comment. Sign in