I’ve always viewed myself as a utilitarianist but feel it’s hard to determine a correct utilitarian choice at the small personal scale like the fat man trolley problem so I revert to a more deontological/humanist framework. Like with the fat man trolley problem a lot of people might just focus on the six people involved, but I start thinking about the news headlines, the impacted families who lost whoever, and spiral. Where do you cut it off? That’s why I feel utilitarian falls apart small scale because it’s never actually small scale.
That is the hard part with the different viewpoints is that ultimately you can arrive at the same conclusion from very different starting points so does that make them both correct or does it hint at a universal truth since both arrive at the same answer? Aaaaand where off to the depths of philosophy and why it’s still a thing lol.
The calculus of felicity can be an unending spiral of implications 😅 Utilitarianism is very useful, living up to its name, but sometimes it becomes heavy due to that forecasting it demands.
That’s it exactly, there’s a saying in the scientific community: “science is never done.” I think that holds true for ethics as well in many ways. Sometimes all that really functionally matters is arriving at the right conclusion, but what really makes it the right conclusion? Is our reasoning sound? Or did we stumble upon the right path though imperfect or limited reasoning? Will that same logic lead us to a good conclusion next time as well, or somewhere else? It’s a wild ride, one of my favorite subjects. I like to imagine it as you describe, one monolothic, objective morality that we small humans are shining lights on to and grasping limited portions of through our philosophical efforts, slowly piecing together the greater whole as we combine theories and efforts.
Comments
I’ve always viewed myself as a utilitarianist but feel it’s hard to determine a correct utilitarian choice at the small personal scale like the fat man trolley problem so I revert to a more deontological/humanist framework. Like with the fat man trolley problem a lot of people might just focus on the six people involved, but I start thinking about the news headlines, the impacted families who lost whoever, and spiral. Where do you cut it off? That’s why I feel utilitarian falls apart small scale because it’s never actually small scale.
That is the hard part with the different viewpoints is that ultimately you can arrive at the same conclusion from very different starting points so does that make them both correct or does it hint at a universal truth since both arrive at the same answer? Aaaaand where off to the depths of philosophy and why it’s still a thing lol.
The calculus of felicity can be an unending spiral of implications 😅 Utilitarianism is very useful, living up to its name, but sometimes it becomes heavy due to that forecasting it demands.
That’s it exactly, there’s a saying in the scientific community: “science is never done.” I think that holds true for ethics as well in many ways. Sometimes all that really functionally matters is arriving at the right conclusion, but what really makes it the right conclusion? Is our reasoning sound? Or did we stumble upon the right path though imperfect or limited reasoning? Will that same logic lead us to a good conclusion next time as well, or somewhere else? It’s a wild ride, one of my favorite subjects. I like to imagine it as you describe, one monolothic, objective morality that we small humans are shining lights on to and grasping limited portions of through our philosophical efforts, slowly piecing together the greater whole as we combine theories and efforts.
Sign in to comment. Sign in