Skip to content

Comment on Batman vs The Trolley Problem [Existential Comics]

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • Todd didn’t do it. Instead he tried proving a point to Wayne and got his ass kicked.

    Was that the storyline where the Joker brainwashed him or was that a different Robin?

    4
    • @Stolas@lemmy.ca· · edited

      Depends on the timeline. There is one comic series where Jason does actually kill Joker.

      But what most people tend to think of is Under the Red Hood from 2010, where Jason is kidnapped and beaten by the Joker in the beginning before supposedly murdered. He survives in secret, returns as the Red Hood, and at a confrontation with Batman discusses how he’s upset that Joker could kill him and that Bruce refuses to kill the Joker in return.

      It’s a common theme. In another timeline one iteration of Selina leaves Bruce because he was willing to risk their lives to save the Riddler despite how he was entirely responsible for the situation that got himself killed.

      You know who does kill Joker in a lot of timelines though? Superman. He usually ends up going a bit authoritarian afterwards but Bruce will even admit in some of those situations that Joker’s death is necessary.

      9
      • You know who does kill Joker in a lot of timelines though? Superman. He usually ends up going a bit authoritarian afterwards

        I really liked the Injustice arc

        6
        • Injustice was really solid as long as you focus on the main cast. I do think a lot of people were disappointed with how Damian was handled.

          There’s also the Justice Lords, where Batman reluctantly complies with Superman’s regime and where Superman’s preferred method of punishment is lobotomizing villains.

          5
      • Unironically, Injustice was good until Chapter 5(?) Where Superman and WW show up to forcibly break up a protest against their actions

        Up until then they were doing actual good. But of course every story has to go “absolute power corrupts” OT whatever and before you know it

        Spoiler

        Superman becomes a Yellow Lantern to McGuffin him surviving getting shot with a Kryptonite bullet, and his half of the JLA still support him unconditionally

        3
    • That was Tim Drake, Robin #3.

      3
      • What did Todd do in the story you mentioned?

        1
        • @Tattorack@lemmy.world· · edited

          Jason Todd got killed by the Joker by way of repeated contact with a crowbar and a close encounter with some explosives.

          Ras Al Guhl for some reason decided to revive him in the Lazarus Pit. It didn’t go so well as Jason’s mind was a little broken at first and he ran off.

          Some years go by and he eventually learns Joker is still alive, still killing people, and Batman Just keeps throwing him in Arkham.

          So, Jason creates a plot to get the attention of both the Joker and Batman by taking up Joker’s old persona; The Red Hood. Joker is going to get very intrigued by someone masquerading as something from his past, and Batman will get involved because he’s Batman.

          The end goal was to force Batman in a situation where he’d be forced to kill the Joker. A situation where either Batman kills the Joker, or he does it himself.

          Batman of course ends up defending the Joker and saving him from Jason.

          Edit: writing this entirely from memory, so there might be some bent details.

          9

Sign in to comment. Sign in