I actually agree with that analysis completely. If you really press me, I would say yes, pull the lever in the trolley problem. But the problem is trying to take that as a principle to be applied to other situations. When we actually look at practical situations, there are all sorts of other factors specific to that situation that need to be evaluated, and it’s rare that the difference actually comes down to whether or not you’re applying a utilitarian framework. That sort of thinking also limits what kinds of solutions we’re prone to consider.
The actual, real world solution to the trolley problem would be first of all tracking down whoever’s tying people to tracks and making them stop, and implementing better safety mechanisms to prevent trolleys from getting out of control. These solutions are things pretty much everyone can agree with, regardless of their moral framework. And I would expect that even if someone in that situation made the wrong decision from a given framework, people would see them as faced with an impossible choice in a traumatic situation, and even if they made the right decision, it wouldn’t be considered “problem solved.”
What is more useful in informing our actual moral decision making is to pull examples from actual reality, in cases that are actually relevant to the decision in question. Because of the doctor example, you cannot just say, “This is like the trolley problem so we should do this,” in practical cases, because real life is more complex.
Comments
I actually agree with that analysis completely. If you really press me, I would say yes, pull the lever in the trolley problem. But the problem is trying to take that as a principle to be applied to other situations. When we actually look at practical situations, there are all sorts of other factors specific to that situation that need to be evaluated, and it’s rare that the difference actually comes down to whether or not you’re applying a utilitarian framework. That sort of thinking also limits what kinds of solutions we’re prone to consider.
The actual, real world solution to the trolley problem would be first of all tracking down whoever’s tying people to tracks and making them stop, and implementing better safety mechanisms to prevent trolleys from getting out of control. These solutions are things pretty much everyone can agree with, regardless of their moral framework. And I would expect that even if someone in that situation made the wrong decision from a given framework, people would see them as faced with an impossible choice in a traumatic situation, and even if they made the right decision, it wouldn’t be considered “problem solved.”
What is more useful in informing our actual moral decision making is to pull examples from actual reality, in cases that are actually relevant to the decision in question. Because of the doctor example, you cannot just say, “This is like the trolley problem so we should do this,” in practical cases, because real life is more complex.
Sign in to comment. Sign in