Skip to content

Comment on I-638 Supporter Clarifies They’re Not Anti-Trans, Just Anti-Female

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • Sir, this is Taco Bell The Needling, Seattle’s Only Real Fake News

    Edit: …wait, this is a real bill though? Look, these Onion flavored articles are getting too real. Its unironically getting difficult to tell when theyre joking and not.

    Not to take too serious of a turn on all this, but I remember as a young boy needing to get a physical every year to do sports, which included the doc needing to feel something on my scrotum while I turned my head and coughed. I always imagined the girls needing to have something comparable checked.

    Would this bill drive a more invasive test than that?

    Edit 2: according to Ballotopedia:

    The ballot initiative required students seeking to participate in athletic activities designated for female students to submit documentation from their healthcare provider verifying “the student’s biological sex [based on]… reproductive anatomy, genetic makeup, or normal endogenously produced testosterone levels.”[

    However, the link to the citation appears to be broken

    0
    • They don’t really do this anymore unless you have hernia symptoms and, from what I understand, to check for ovaries in girls requires a much more invasive procedure involving an ultrasound from the inside. You can’t feel for them from outside.

      0
      • I suppose “reproductive anatomy” leaves room for interpretation. Checking for ovaries does feel really invasive and is more than I would have assumed, but suppose I’m no doctor (let alone a maliciously minded one that thinks this is all necessary), so who’s to say what one of those would deem necessary in the moment.

        0
        • The sort of Doctor I would want my child seeing would be aghast at this type of unnecessary procedure.

          Plus isn’t there the matter of privileged medical information?

          So a young girl who goes to a Doctor and is told that there is something that would make her run afoul of these ballot measures won’t be outed, they will just not progress with joining sports. The external difference between a “trans” individual and a girl that won’t or can’t comply will be nil. They aren’t going to get a gotcha, they are just going to get reduced participation.

          Does this mean when the fascist pricks that have pushed this shit don’t have hard figures on how many trans kids they have barred from sport they will just take that whole number and claim they have kept that many “trans kids” from sneaking into women’s sports?

          Fuck this whole steaming pile of shit gets worse the more I think about how a maximally evil person could manipulate this to push a fictional world view.

          0
    • Checking for hernias, something that could give you a lot of grief if it went bad. Arguably not that big a deal not something I hear being done a lot these days. I had to do the same when I was doing flight training. The intent was to prevent a medical issue from blowing up into a much bigger deal, and while potentially embarassing it was minimally invasive.

      This, this is not medically necessary this is solely informed by culture war nonsense and transphobia. And once the transvestigators get involved how many girls families will be expected to spend thousands of dollars on genetic and hormone testing? This is being presented as defending women’s sports but it’s actually a potentially massive impediment.

      Conservatives and Christians turning women’s sports into the Battle of Bến Tre. What a time to be alive.

      0

Sign in to comment. Sign in