Skip to content

Comment on I-638 Supporter Clarifies They’re Not Anti-Trans, Just Anti-Female

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • The actual answer is because karyotype testing (testing of biological sex determinations) results in a whole bunch of cis people discovering that they are intersex.

    Similarly to why they stopped doing eye color punnit squares in schools, because there are a few more factors in eye color and it was leading to kids thinking they were the result of an affair. Any time there is a test that would uppend the life of the person being tested for no real good reason, we err on the side of not causing a problem if we don’t need to.

    Should go without saying, but this test should also be included in that, and genital testing should never be a requirement for something as low stakes as sports. We don’t test for hyperflexibility, naturally high T levels, or any other genetic advantage someone could have, and any “advantage” a trans person could have (which has never been proven in any scientific study) pales in comparison to the natural advantage some cis people have over other cis people.

    2
    • I mean, if they’re not on hormone therapy a trans woman would absolutely have an advantage over a CIS woman. Testosterone is a hell of a drug.

      0
    • Thanks for the thoughtful reply, they should just mind their own fucking business.

      0

Sign in to comment. Sign in