Gamers really need to learn about IP law. Y’all never owned anything. A CD was just a transferrable license. Buying games from steam is a non-transferrable license. Sucks, but that’s what you get when you have IP laws as pervasive in the US. Gamers need to move on to the acceptance stage that you will never own your software.
Yes what we want is transferable licenses, that’s what we are losing and or lost with digital storefronts. We want to own the license. We want a physical, tangible thing
Technically yes, in the legalese context the term people should be using is ‘license’, but for most people that’s what the game is, it’s always been that, but that’s not the term people use. “owning the game” is the exact same thing as the legal term “owning a transferable license”.
What we want is that tangible transferable license, aka owning the game. We don’t want the source code, or the IP. We just want to be able to own the game that lets us trade, borrow/lend, sell, or buy ‘used’ games.
But boiling it down to just “license” allows for that terms of the license to be changed because corporations have been given the power to change the terms of every license ever to fit their own whims without the real consent of both parties. We’ve seen that shit already with digital license games. Sony can just up and remove the game from your account without consulting you or even informing you the second party of the license. They don’t have to give you a reason, they can just up and change the agreement without you needing to agree to the changes. And even if they do ask you to agree to the changes, they only present you with 2 choices: agree or lose access. That’s bullshit.
I sympathize for those who think that Sony is breaking the law, but I also sympathize with those who regard the situation as broken, and demand the law be changed.
I do kind of get the reasoning behind digital licenses being non-transferable. But overall, with people’s libraries getting deleted as a consequence, altogether too much control is on the license holder’s side.
Saying we own the disc never meant that we owned the right to the game. Just that we owned the disc and could therefore play whenever we want.
I do not understand why it is so difficult to understand that our money means something to us, and the word “buy” did indeed mean a binding contract between two parties.
They actually have a point. People are pissed that they don’t own their games anymore. So guarantee ownership. Give us recourse when servers shut down. Let us trade, sell, borrow second hand games. Let us play games without an account. We should be free to do with a game whatever we want
It became a metaphor back around when they released Empire, Total War, (edit: 2012 ish maybe,) and the disk meant nothing and just sent you to Steam to download it, forcing you to keep steam on your computer that tried to run at all times, and make you ask for permission every time you wanted to play the game, revocable at any moment I presume.
It’s a metaphor in the sense that if they didn’t get rid of physical disks, they would still be putting games on them that don’t work without an internet connection and cannot be resold.
I’m not one to subscribe to conspiracy theories, I try to think myself as someone who can process information in an objective1 , level-headed, reasonable (scientific) manner. Occam’s razor and all - and pretty much every theory fails these simple tests of logic.
(1Objective in thinking, not in opinion. Opinions are by definition subjective)
But I can’t help coming back to the “forced no local computing” theory that’s been going around for about two years, where people theorised that the entire DRAM/NAND/chip shortage is just a ploy to move computing power away from ownership by people and towards corporate hosted services.
Which is obviously dumb because what company would say “you know what, B2B is enough for us, why should we sell for B2C?”, what company would axe half its market just so the other half can sell a service instead of a product?
Especially when you consider some of the heaviest computing dependent things: gaming being the foremost leader, followed by various other 3D rendering requisites (from artistic through engineering modelling, physics test frameworks for about a dozen major industries that use them indirectly, including construction, aerospace, radio technologies and so on), compute heavy processing of data, hell, code compilation or even complex map rendering…
But then all of a sudden the big gaming giants began faltering. Xbox had three layoffs from Xbox and a new one is rumoured as they’re “restructuring” the department from gaming-focused work to ‘digital media creation’… Sony is doing their best to lose customers, and Nintendo… well they didn’t change a bit.
Every single major gaming studio/publisher seems to be running straight into the forest of dicks with a wide open mouth. And it can’t just be greed and stupidity. Some companies doing this, I’d agree, but all the major ones, at the same time? This looks more and more like an intentional attempt at destroying the primary consumer market for high end computer hardware. Destroy the demand, wait 5-10 years, restart game studios (consolidated into 2-3 megacorps of course), and sell games as a service. No ownership, no modding, no piracy, no need for “loud and hot local hardware”, just a display and a controller. Wet dream of business execs…
Which is obviously dumb because what company would say “you know what, B2B is enough for us, why should we sell for B2C?”, what company would axe half its market just so the other half can sell a service instead of a product?
I think he’s correct that it’s a mentality issue: but the issue is with Sony’s mentality, not the consumer. If the PlayStation store operated like gog.com there wouldn’t be as much of an issue.
I think he also underestimates the advantages of a separate disk per game, especially when he mentions hardware prices in the same breath…
The only people upset about not having a physical copy are the same with control issues in all other aspects of their life. Probably preppers too 😂 friggin boomer mentality.
It wasn’t a metaphor until the games became too large for the storage media that the console manufacturers chose. They could choose better storage media.
I mean he is right that it’s a metaphor for owning games.
And he is very wrong that it’s a mentality issue.
Honestly I even believe him that physical discs are not feasible anymore to produce, but then again I ask: “don’t we have a point in making sure we still own a copy of the product we bought?” It’s not like we don’t have a reason to be anxious about this.
And then if we go back to the discs, if you get rid of that, what’s the point of consoles? The differences between PC and console get slimmer by the day, and this exacerbates it.
It’s always pathetic when these super old guys dye their hair constantly, like Steven Seagall, he’s like 80 without a single grey hair, and not grey roots even, meaning he is dying like all the time.
Everyone ages, at some point, just embrace it. After 60, 70 tops, just go with the grey.
I think GTA, and this most anticipated release of a game in perhaps ever, really fucked up in screwing over their union right before the release, (last I heard, in passing,) and are similarly just asking to be pirated.
He’s half right. An all-digital future is an inevitability, one way or another. In a world where games have a long tail of updates and DLC, what’s printed on the disc is often quickly obsolete anyway, it’s not necessarily the version you want to preserve and won’t be that useful by itself in 50 years time when all servers are gone.
But consumers are angry because you haven’t given us an alternative that lets us trust that we own our games. The problem is that we don’t trust you or the industry, not when the industry is actively fighting against ownership with DRM and games being shut down left and right. If you want to earn our trust, show us what your solution to these problems is. Don’t just tell us we’re wrong to want to own our games, solve the problem.
The only issue with gog is its a centralised source that will probably be forced to introduce age verification which isn’t a problem on th e disc second hand market.
We’re already a lot closer to it than you think. Do you know how many modern games don’t even fit on the disc in the first place? Or ship incomplete because in order to meet a target release date they have to start pressing discs before 1.0 is actually finished? And what about all the updates and DLC?
In 50 years time, when servers are all gone and you can’t redownload the data that wasn’t on the disc, do you still own your games?
I wasn’t speaking to price, you said modern games don’t fit on discs. I was simply offering an alternative format that would hold it, it’s not some impossibility.
No one is trying to claim they own the IP, and no one is claiming they own the source code to the game either.
That seems to be the way all these fucking companies try to frame things to justify telling you to pay them and then fuck off. They’re trying to justify having you pay them for nothing, and then enforce it legally.
I think SpiceDAO struggled with this, but that’s not “a soul” lol. They bought some rare Dune book or something thinking it gave them rights to it? I don’t remember the specifics.
Pointing to a group of plainly delusional idiots is technically a counterexample.
See also those crypto-dolts who (IIRC) made a knockoff of Magic The Gathering: Online and dismissed legal threats by figuring they’d make so much money they could just buy Wizards Of The Coast.
Digital book markets are why I will never fully switch from physical books. I prefer to own my shit and give it away if I want, can’t do that with an ebook or a downloaded game.
I don’t know how to do that. Liked I’m glad the tech exists, but I don’t have the motivation to learn how to do that or start a server, I just want to read 😅 I just go to the library or one of the many independent bookstores close to me.
“A mentality issue that we’ve built a business model around. Now that our exploitive behavior is laid bare, you want to complain about it. I just don’t understand why you’re so attached to the ‘metaphor’ of ownership that we’ve been using to extract money from you.”
It’s true tho, we never owned games, music, or movies on physical media either. We owned the revokable rights to view/use that copy of the media for private usage.
Every teacher that showed a movie in class broke a federal law.
It was just one of those things that was unenforceable and no one understood.
It doesn’t mean we should accept not owning media, it just means we have zero chance of fixing it if we never understand it. A purchase should be lifetime usage, regardless of media. What you’re buying is a license to view/use it, method doesn’t matter.
Like how some people back in the day would only download a movie if they owned the DVD. That should be legal.
No, that’s literally how software/media has always worked…
If you “own” code, then you can copy, distribute, and profit off of it 100% legally.
That’s why software/media you “buy” is a license for personal use.
That’s the entire point of the issue…
Did you think Blockbuster or any other rental store could buy a copy from Walmart and rent it out? Those were different licenses and the rental stores paid a shit ton more for their copies to be able to rent them.
Because it’s never been about the physical media, but the license attached to it that determines fair usage
It hasn’t always worked the way it does today. I know you buy a “license”. But when you bought that cd rom or floppy or dvd or whatever physical media, you didn’t have to do anything else to make it work. That copy ALWAYS worked, and you could sell it when you no longer needed it. Or you could let your friend borrow it.
“Fair usage” doesn’t really work the way it used to.
My point is that those producing media should not be able to sell you something that you are not allowed to control to some extent, and use at your disposal.
Did you think Blockbuster or any other rental store could buy a copy from Walmart and rent it out?
YES! That’s how it fucking worked! For the exact same reason libraries can just buy a book, and then lend it out, because they fucking own it. That’s what the money was for!
Rental chains only developed contractual relationships with movie studios because it’s otherwise kind of difficult to buy five thousand copies of one tape. Studios sued, and lost, and came back with a truce.
The first sale doctrine is over a century old. Every medium has tried insisting it’s special, and been slapped down as just another product. Software has been long awaiting that slap. Their excuses aren’t anything new. Your rights have not changed.
Did you think Blockbuster or any other rental store could buy a copy from Walmart and rent it out? Those were different licenses and the rental stores paid a shit ton more for their copies to be able to rent them.
Correct. If you own some data, nothing stops you from writing it to whatever media you want, be it laser discs, ribbon or HDD. Do console gamers own anything? Most probably not.
You mean the same guy that told people to work two jobs for the honor of buying his five hundred and ninety nine dollar console in 2006? Oh yeah, he’s an asshole.
Comments
Ok boomer
Gamers really need to learn about IP law. Y’all never owned anything. A CD was just a transferrable license. Buying games from steam is a non-transferrable license. Sucks, but that’s what you get when you have IP laws as pervasive in the US. Gamers need to move on to the acceptance stage that you will never own your software.
Yes what we want is transferable licenses, that’s what we are losing and or lost with digital storefronts. We want to own the license. We want a physical, tangible thing
Technically yes, in the legalese context the term people should be using is ‘license’, but for most people that’s what the game is, it’s always been that, but that’s not the term people use. “owning the game” is the exact same thing as the legal term “owning a transferable license”.
What we want is that tangible transferable license, aka owning the game. We don’t want the source code, or the IP. We just want to be able to own the game that lets us trade, borrow/lend, sell, or buy ‘used’ games.
But boiling it down to just “license” allows for that terms of the license to be changed because corporations have been given the power to change the terms of every license ever to fit their own whims without the real consent of both parties. We’ve seen that shit already with digital license games. Sony can just up and remove the game from your account without consulting you or even informing you the second party of the license. They don’t have to give you a reason, they can just up and change the agreement without you needing to agree to the changes. And even if they do ask you to agree to the changes, they only present you with 2 choices: agree or lose access. That’s bullshit.
I sympathize for those who think that Sony is breaking the law, but I also sympathize with those who regard the situation as broken, and demand the law be changed.
I do kind of get the reasoning behind digital licenses being non-transferable. But overall, with people’s libraries getting deleted as a consequence, altogether too much control is on the license holder’s side.
What do boots taste like?
Saying we own the disc never meant that we owned the right to the game. Just that we owned the disc and could therefore play whenever we want.
I do not understand why it is so difficult to understand that our money means something to us, and the word “buy” did indeed mean a binding contract between two parties.
They actually have a point. People are pissed that they don’t own their games anymore. So guarantee ownership. Give us recourse when servers shut down. Let us trade, sell, borrow second hand games. Let us play games without an account. We should be free to do with a game whatever we want
So, Ken, got any jiggalicious PH neutral seven spice aubergine conditioner to go with your foul snake oil opinions?
Good job Onion, nailed it aga…
Wait this isn’t satire, he actually said that?
Whelp, that’s reason enough to repost it at /c/NotTheOnion.
Yeah, the fact that you call it a “metaphor” proves you don’t understand it at all.
It became a metaphor back around when they released Empire, Total War, (edit: 2012 ish maybe,) and the disk meant nothing and just sent you to Steam to download it, forcing you to keep steam on your computer that tried to run at all times, and make you ask for permission every time you wanted to play the game, revocable at any moment I presume.
It’s a metaphor in the sense that if they didn’t get rid of physical disks, they would still be putting games on them that don’t work without an internet connection and cannot be resold.
True.
They’re trying so hard to implode. All we have to do is nothing and they’ll be gone in a few years.
It really makes me worried to be fair.
I’m not one to subscribe to conspiracy theories, I try to think myself as someone who can process information in an objective1 , level-headed, reasonable (scientific) manner. Occam’s razor and all - and pretty much every theory fails these simple tests of logic.
(1Objective in thinking, not in opinion. Opinions are by definition subjective)
But I can’t help coming back to the “forced no local computing” theory that’s been going around for about two years, where people theorised that the entire DRAM/NAND/chip shortage is just a ploy to move computing power away from ownership by people and towards corporate hosted services.
Which is obviously dumb because what company would say “you know what, B2B is enough for us, why should we sell for B2C?”, what company would axe half its market just so the other half can sell a service instead of a product?
Especially when you consider some of the heaviest computing dependent things: gaming being the foremost leader, followed by various other 3D rendering requisites (from artistic through engineering modelling, physics test frameworks for about a dozen major industries that use them indirectly, including construction, aerospace, radio technologies and so on), compute heavy processing of data, hell, code compilation or even complex map rendering…
But then all of a sudden the big gaming giants began faltering. Xbox had three layoffs from Xbox and a new one is rumoured as they’re “restructuring” the department from gaming-focused work to ‘digital media creation’… Sony is doing their best to lose customers, and Nintendo… well they didn’t change a bit.
Every single major gaming studio/publisher seems to be running straight into the forest of dicks with a wide open mouth. And it can’t just be greed and stupidity. Some companies doing this, I’d agree, but all the major ones, at the same time? This looks more and more like an intentional attempt at destroying the primary consumer market for high end computer hardware. Destroy the demand, wait 5-10 years, restart game studios (consolidated into 2-3 megacorps of course), and sell games as a service. No ownership, no modding, no piracy, no need for “loud and hot local hardware”, just a display and a controller. Wet dream of business execs…
Micron, one of the three major RAM and SSD manufacturers.
I think he’s correct that it’s a mentality issue: but the issue is with Sony’s mentality, not the consumer. If the PlayStation store operated like gog.com there wouldn’t be as much of an issue.
I think he also underestimates the advantages of a separate disk per game, especially when he mentions hardware prices in the same breath…
Owning a disc hasn’t been synonym with owning a game in a long time. And that was already an issue!
The only people upset about not having a physical copy are the same with control issues in all other aspects of their life. Probably preppers too 😂 friggin boomer mentality.
CEO has CEO opinion, news at 11!
It wasn’t a metaphor until the games became too large for the storage media that the console manufacturers chose. They could choose better storage media.
I mean he is right that it’s a metaphor for owning games.
And he is very wrong that it’s a mentality issue.
Honestly I even believe him that physical discs are not feasible anymore to produce, but then again I ask: “don’t we have a point in making sure we still own a copy of the product we bought?” It’s not like we don’t have a reason to be anxious about this.
And then if we go back to the discs, if you get rid of that, what’s the point of consoles? The differences between PC and console get slimmer by the day, and this exacerbates it.
Did too much hair dye seep into his brain?
It’s always pathetic when these super old guys dye their hair constantly, like Steven Seagall, he’s like 80 without a single grey hair, and not grey roots even, meaning he is dying like all the time.
Everyone ages, at some point, just embrace it. After 60, 70 tops, just go with the grey.
This metaphorical disc has the metaphorical bits of the game on it. Which I will metaphorically keep and backup forever. …metaphoricallly speaking.
ceos getting upset at people pirating their games is a mentality issue.
They are really asking for it.
I think GTA, and this most anticipated release of a game in perhaps ever, really fucked up in screwing over their union right before the release, (last I heard, in passing,) and are similarly just asking to be pirated.
Can I sell my digital copy to someone else? Or borrow it to them?
You keep making it different, asshole.
He’d probably argue you couldn’t legally do that with the disc copy you had though.
Lend
I’d borrow you one of my fucks, but I don’t have any.
I give you knowledge for free, broke ass
These days “borrow” can mean “lend” because it all comes down to common usage. Dictionary writers are historians of language, not arbiters of it.
I’ve only ever heard people who have English as a second or third language mix them up.
He’s half right. An all-digital future is an inevitability, one way or another. In a world where games have a long tail of updates and DLC, what’s printed on the disc is often quickly obsolete anyway, it’s not necessarily the version you want to preserve and won’t be that useful by itself in 50 years time when all servers are gone.
But consumers are angry because you haven’t given us an alternative that lets us trust that we own our games. The problem is that we don’t trust you or the industry, not when the industry is actively fighting against ownership with DRM and games being shut down left and right. If you want to earn our trust, show us what your solution to these problems is. Don’t just tell us we’re wrong to want to own our games, solve the problem.
Exactly. I don’t need a disk. If he would distribute games like GOG do nobody would bring this disk thing up.
The only issue with gog is its a centralised source that will probably be forced to introduce age verification which isn’t a problem on th e disc second hand market.
An all-digital future is not by any means inevitable…
We’re already a lot closer to it than you think. Do you know how many modern games don’t even fit on the disc in the first place? Or ship incomplete because in order to meet a target release date they have to start pressing discs before 1.0 is actually finished? And what about all the updates and DLC?
In 50 years time, when servers are all gone and you can’t redownload the data that wasn’t on the disc, do you still own your games?
SD cards instead of CDs. Problem solved.
Have you seen the prices on SD cards lately?
I wasn’t speaking to price, you said modern games don’t fit on discs. I was simply offering an alternative format that would hold it, it’s not some impossibility.
No, it’s a corporate greed issue that we don’t want to deal with. Fuck him and capitalism.
Keep doubling down Sony, you’re doing great
Again, we know that we don’t own Crash Bandicot, the IP, but, we wanna own a copy of a game that features Crash Bandicot.
best we can do is you own nothing and be happy!
No one is trying to claim they own the IP, and no one is claiming they own the source code to the game either.
That seems to be the way all these fucking companies try to frame things to justify telling you to pay them and then fuck off. They’re trying to justify having you pay them for nothing, and then enforce it legally.
And nobody struggles with this for books. Not one soul.
I think SpiceDAO struggled with this, but that’s not “a soul” lol. They bought some rare Dune book or something thinking it gave them rights to it? I don’t remember the specifics.
Pointing to a group of plainly delusional idiots is technically a counterexample.
See also those crypto-dolts who (IIRC) made a knockoff of Magic The Gathering: Online and dismissed legal threats by figuring they’d make so much money they could just buy Wizards Of The Coast.
Not true, I’m sure they are working on making it all digital and just letting us rent them. Nothing is sacred. Who is going to stop them?
Are you unaware of digital book markets?
Digital book markets are why I will never fully switch from physical books. I prefer to own my shit and give it away if I want, can’t do that with an ebook or a downloaded game.
I just strip DRM the second I download the ebook using calibre. Sharing becomes as trivial as attaching to a message.
I don’t know how to do that. Liked I’m glad the tech exists, but I don’t have the motivation to learn how to do that or start a server, I just want to read 😅 I just go to the library or one of the many independent bookstores close to me.
That cannot be revoked arbitrarily by fuckheads like this piece of trash.
“A mentality issue that we’ve built a business model around. Now that our exploitive behavior is laid bare, you want to complain about it. I just don’t understand why you’re so attached to the ‘metaphor’ of ownership that we’ve been using to extract money from you.”
It’s true tho, we never owned games, music, or movies on physical media either. We owned the revokable rights to view/use that copy of the media for private usage.
Every teacher that showed a movie in class broke a federal law.
It was just one of those things that was unenforceable and no one understood.
It doesn’t mean we should accept not owning media, it just means we have zero chance of fixing it if we never understand it. A purchase should be lifetime usage, regardless of media. What you’re buying is a license to view/use it, method doesn’t matter.
Like how some people back in the day would only download a movie if they owned the DVD. That should be legal.
But trying to explain that never goes well
Revoke my books. I fucking dare you.
Naw man, that’s just what they want you to believe because it benefits them.
We’ve de facto owned copies of whatever was purchased until the Internet changed the way ownership functions.
Laws are written by people. Traditionally, greedy people.
I think everyone understands just fine, we just won’t be able to change that until the people who write laws are changed.
De facto, yes. De jure, no.
Sure, but like I said. People write the law… Greedy people usually.
No, that’s literally how software/media has always worked…
If you “own” code, then you can copy, distribute, and profit off of it 100% legally.
That’s why software/media you “buy” is a license for personal use.
That’s the entire point of the issue…
Did you think Blockbuster or any other rental store could buy a copy from Walmart and rent it out? Those were different licenses and the rental stores paid a shit ton more for their copies to be able to rent them.
Because it’s never been about the physical media, but the license attached to it that determines fair usage
You misunderstand me.
It hasn’t always worked the way it does today. I know you buy a “license”. But when you bought that cd rom or floppy or dvd or whatever physical media, you didn’t have to do anything else to make it work. That copy ALWAYS worked, and you could sell it when you no longer needed it. Or you could let your friend borrow it.
“Fair usage” doesn’t really work the way it used to.
That is not what “fair use” means in the context of copyright.
Also most of those licenses were non-transferable which means it was illegal to sell those games secondhand. But again it was unenforceable.
What you are talking about is DRM.
I think you are also missing my point.
I’m not talking about what the law is/was.
Also, I put “Fair usage” in quotes for a reason.
My point is that those producing media should not be able to sell you something that you are not allowed to control to some extent, and use at your disposal.
YES! That’s how it fucking worked! For the exact same reason libraries can just buy a book, and then lend it out, because they fucking own it. That’s what the money was for!
Rental chains only developed contractual relationships with movie studios because it’s otherwise kind of difficult to buy five thousand copies of one tape. Studios sued, and lost, and came back with a truce.
The first sale doctrine is over a century old. Every medium has tried insisting it’s special, and been slapped down as just another product. Software has been long awaiting that slap. Their excuses aren’t anything new. Your rights have not changed.
Yes and no. They did have licensing deals for video, but for video games they relied entirely on the First Sale Doctrine. Nintendo tried to sue because they didn’t want to allow rentals, and lost.
Correct. If you own some data, nothing stops you from writing it to whatever media you want, be it laser discs, ribbon or HDD. Do console gamers own anything? Most probably not.
Oh. So he is an asshole like Elon. Good to know.
All of them are, especially when you get anywhere near the size of Sony.
You mean the same guy that told people to work two jobs for the honor of buying his five hundred and ninety nine dollar console in 2006? Oh yeah, he’s an asshole.
Right, why would anyone expect this asshole to say anything different?
Giant enemy crab
But it had Ridge Racer!
We are fools each time to expect any different :(
Sign in to comment. Sign in