Skip to content

Comment on Mickey 17 is like Alien if it was good

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • I don’t see even the silhouette of a resemblance between Alien and Mickey 17, really curious where should I look ?

    0
    • Alien is a movie about capitalists travelling space to exploit its resources, but then encountering a mysterious alien threat that kills them all until the hero neutralises the alien with cunning and violence.

      Mickey 17 is a movie about capitalists travelling space to exploit its resources, but then encountering a mysterious alien threat that just wants to be left alone, but is willing to kill them all until the hero neutralises the capitalists with diplomacy and violence.

      The fact that the creepers want peace and can be reasoned with really elevates Mickey 17 over Alien. Both of them are about how capitalism is horrible and wants to exploit everything no matter the harms. But Weyland-Yutani is only harming humans; everything nonhuman is just another metaphor for the dangers of capitalism. The Niflheim expedition is torturing both humans and aliens, often for very little reason.

      And the resolution of the movie fixes these problems, offering a way out of capitalism. Alien kinda has the Harry Potter problem in that the core political tension of the movie never gets resolved. Ripley survives against all the odds, only to go back to capitalist Earth and live through it all again in Aliens. It’s a good business move to leave the potential for the sequel open, but it does degrade the quality of the art.

      0
      • Jesus Christ where do you even begin with this one. Thanks for a quality film analysis through the Marxist lens.

        You’re absolutely right and communists would never exploit a rock for its resources or be violent towards another creature. Forget reality and read more theory.

        0
      • aha yes, makes sense under this lens !

        0
      • I wish someone would explain why you’re getting downvoted. 😔

        0
        • I wonder if more people knew that:

          would they still use downvotes as a “I don’t like this” button?

          0
          • It stifles the conversation and since they don’t like the arguments but can’t argue against them effectively, they would still. I’m of the mind that every place should easily allow you to see who votes and in which way. Responsibility is a good deterrent for silliness.

            0
            • I guess my point is that the lemmy system is less stifling, so it’s ineffective for anything but hurting feelings (especially for comments!), which is still a shitty thing to do.

              I could be misunderstanding the facts, but I don’t think base lemmy hides comments with low vote counts (and they don’t hide users with low vote counts because that’s not a thing). With posts, it does make them less visible because if your view is based on “hot” or “top” they will be ranked lower.

              0
        • It’s cause My opinion is unpopular

          0

Sign in to comment. Sign in