OccupySaaS - "They laid us off. We're rebuilding their SaaS"
I saw some discussion about this elsewhere. Here is how the project describes itself:
OccupySaaS is a protest movement in code: laid-off developers building clean-room, open-source, drop-in replacements for the SaaS giants. First up: ZeroAuthy (Auth0) and SalesCompel (Salesforce).
In 2011, Occupy Wall Street asked who the economy was really working for. In 2026 we’re asking the same question about the cloud. The tools every company runs on are now toll booths — and the people who built them were shown the door.
Two towers occupied.
Identity and CRM: the two subscriptions almost every company pays for and almost nobody loves. ZeroAuthy has shipped its first release candidate, SalesCompel is still early, and both welcome contributors today.
Who’s next?
Every category on this board is a monthly invoice somewhere. The movement picks the next target in public — bring a spec, a use case, or a grudge.
Comments
The sentiment is all very well and good, but I’m pretty confident that we’d get better results if they put their energy into improving the many, many mature open source projects that already exist to do the same things.
Oh dear. The workers are seizing the means of production, but they’re doing it with AI!
My oh my, what will Lenny decide???
Lemmy: <confused noises>
Can you really call it clean room when you don’t know exactly what the ai was trained on? There’s gotta be some ghidra decomp of these programs in the big providers’ training data.
for real, licensewashing the code through an llm doesn’t make it different code
I think the idea behind a movement like this is good. This implementation worries me. When the plan is to have the AI do the “heavy lifting” from the get-go, this smells a lot like vibes. Even if we look past the ethics, this seems risky for bedrock systems like IAM. And even then, the master’s tools will never dismantle the master’s house. I wish them luck.
I wonder what these devs think of OpenStack
Forgive me, but you must be pretty far from software development to equate any use of AI in software engineering with “vibe coding.”
In the hands of capable engineers, AI is a powerful tool that can be used responsibly to save time or eliminate tedious work. It doesn not have to be used blind and it doesn’t always dig an inescapable hole.
“Vibe coding” is when people without engineering competency fake their way through it with AI. It’s really a very different situation. The difference between aerospace engineering and a landlord special.
These seem like capable engineers with a lot of energy and experience. I think we can give them the benefit of the doubt. If anything, this is the most legit and inspiring use case for AI I’ve seen in a while.
And for people saying that they are just using the AI products of the companies that dropped them… again they must be far from the industry. There’s a small handful of companies building the leading models and those are not the companies that laid these people off. There is a huge world of SAAS companies like Altlassian and Salesforce and thousands more you’ve never heard of who build business productivity software - bloated, shitty, overpriced crap that’s ripe for displacement. Nothing to do with LLM vendors.
No. Almost all of this response is laughable, and has the same stench as the project. I was polite, I wish well-meaning projects well, and if it weren’t for the absurd evangelism that someone else might trip over and be swayed by, I’d just leave this be.
These are not high-profile developers. We don’t know their energy or their experience. We owe them nothing. And whatever this is
is completely ridiculous.
Take this meandering crap back to the bot and ask it to narrow it in on an actual point. There is no path for Claude to liberate anyone from platform capture. It’s intrinsic to the platform Claude itself. CRM will be free from Salesforce, and we’ll still owe Anthropic for the tokens. Perhaps a noble goal, but there’s no freedom in trading one master for another.
I brought decades of software experience and a polite tone to my comment. The fact that you can only reply with mockery and anger says a lot about your knowledge on this subject. I notice you did nothing to deny that you must be pretty far from the profession. Armchair bandwagoning AI hatred appears to be your only currency.
Especially because of scale. “Salesforce” is an incredibly complex group of many software applications with 80,000+ employees and many of their engineers have “unlimited” ai spend. So instead of “we’re rebuilding salesforce” they need to decompose salesforce into its individual elements and see what people need. And even when you have those products decomposed, you need to have swathes of people that understand the business needs that each one fulfills. My title is “Lead Architect: AI” for a medium sized SaaS company and our software has very specialized requirements across a number of verticals. And while salesforce is in no way a direct competitor, I know the sort of things that they’re building and the effort to “vibe code salesforce” is a Herculean task, and all the engineers at my company, many of whom have Ivy League computer science degrees, couldn’t do that in 5 years, if we dropped everything and tried, with unlimited budget for LLM assisted work.
I worry that every level has this misunderstanding, that “Salesforce” is a monolithic system that can be remade if only we pass a comprehensive test suite. Salesforce does not have 80k+ developers making a singular monolithic product. They have 80k+ employees servicing the sales demands of a massive number of customers. Excel is a perfectly fine CRM if you only have a handful of customers.
Hope you’re staying sane in the SaaS landscape. I hear a lot of horror stories.
Good luck.
It’s not so much about having a service, as having a convenient point to spy on in the USA, and practically a cartel in other areas. There’s a reason why every business seems to be on Office 365, and that’s because other people just don’t see your emails if you try and host your own. Getting it working and keeping it working is practically a full time job…
Modern computing is a fucking prison camp.
Wow, you told AI to build you two slop code bases and a website. This is embarrassing.
This “movement” will last one month max, I am sorry, but this is stupid and will change nothing.
This just won’t work if all you are building is a software but no suppory or people to talk to. Isn’t there already oss replacement for these already?
Copying my comment from another thread on this story:
I’m surprised more software hasn’t gone that way (democratic, employee-owned companies).
I have been wondering what the future holds for soo many saas products. A lot of them handle really simple things with a very complex interface. I see UI’s being less important in the age of AI. Apis will be king. Your AI will act as your UI and interface with product apis. But a lot of these SAAS tools have really weak apis. And even weaker RBAC that can support constraining what an AI can do. So I feel like they will lose out to new tools that are built to be interacted with via AI first, with the UI being more just a visualization tool.
[deleted]
Sign in to comment. Sign in