I noticed my interest in new games was rapidly declining and it correlates with the rise of AI, even if its not a direct cause and effect relationship.
So I really wouldn’t say my interest in gaming is subsiding. It just shifted in a very specific way and if it were up to me AAA gaming and games with use of AI would die.
I think it means that you’ll have to be annoyingly extra aware of how AI is used and what’s generative AI bullshit slop and what’s not. Not dissimilar to the asset flipping bullshit was even more prevalent a few years ago.
I hate the phrase “Made with AI” for many nested reasons. Some of which:
“AI” is a meaningless buzzword now.
“Made” to what extent? That could be anything line autocompletion to spammy vibecoding, from invisible diffusion prototyping/editing to horrific in-game visuals.
The tone is “Twitter accusatory.” It ropes in innocent, minimal tool usage with full-on spammers, with zero nuance.
Its a red herring for the fundamental issue: waves of games being spammy slop, which was a huge issue even before “AI.”
It also discounts the other ethical issues we were grappling with. If we are going to talk ethics, are we just going to forget what companies like EA or Blizzard and such have done?
This needs to be discussed like a spectrum, and whether the intent is malicious. Not as a purity test of “was any AI used making this game?”
Slop is a byproduct of instrumental convergence, which is a byproduct of an individualist extractive culture.
You had the same backlash around CGI and digital artwork back when those things were novel, and neither were responsible for the wave of shitty Disney animated sequels, which was a prominent form of industrial slop at the turn of the millennium.
Intelligence is collective and shared, and the support systems for creators make them dependant of claiming “ownership” which is blatantly impossible to attach to things like “style,” so you get kids on tumblr fighting each other over who had a specific anime inspired aesthetic ‘first.’
Also see how certain inventions get invented in completely different environments at the same time. A lot of invention is just luck mixed with the privilege of being allowed to comfortably explore that space while still getting to survive, so the current social structure allows those with more of such privilege to claim ownership in the entire area of thought or action, limiting everyone else for the sake of the individual, or the system which they are supporting, who got the right mix of serendipity and privilege. (mixed with personal context and probably a lot of hard work.)
So, basically our current society makes slop inevitable, while privilege the wealthy, and ensuring the poor endlessly fight for scraps while the wealthy continue to extract and hoard.
I wish people care as much about system shaping as they care about conflating artists and ‘artists’ in usage of a specific tool.
Or the software stacks the gamers are running, for that matter. The APIs, the platforms… as examples, do people really think Valve isn’t using LLMs to develop Steam? Or Nvidia/AMD/Intel/Microsoft for their graphics stacks?
And I don’t mean that as a hostile “you participate in society?” thing, just that it’s inconsistent to judge “AI or no AI” as black and white.
It also discounts the other ethical issues we were grappling with. If we are going to talk ethics, are we just going to forget what companies like EA or Blizzard and such have done?
Lost me on the last bullet point. Saying we can’t address any issue without addressing every issue is an effective way of getting nothing addressed.
It’s like saying “all lives matter”. Yes, all issues matter, but this just derails the conversation instead of letting them have their own space to be discussed.
AI is a tool at the end of the day. Like every tool in the hands of someone who knows that they doing it’s great. But in the hands of a dumbass on the other hand.
if you’re a single dev working on a game there’s likely some gap in your skill set that can be filled with AI. “made with ai = bad” is a very short sighted way to look at things that lacks any nuance.
Always hear about how theres to much competition to make an indie game, but when at least half of them are obviously trite it starts to paint a different picture.
You might as well just not buy any software after 2025.
Its unrealistic to have any developer not use ai in any way in 2025. The tool is too useful and has too much power to be ignored. Even if you wanted to, every google search on how to fix some bug comes with an ai summary. Every IDE uses autocomplete. Having an AI review my personal code has had me fix bugs before i even test.
Its true there is alot of AI slop and low effort projects, but how its being used and to what level matter. Its not black and white. Linus Torvald, the creator of linux, one of, if not the smartest programmer on earth is using it.
As a developer in critical infrastructure we are prohibited to use it. Software was written before and writing the code was never the problem, it’s nearly always scope changes
did you know autocomplete doesn’t have to use ai? we have invented this thing called a language server that can tell us about relevant things to write
I can’t avoid some of my tools or dependencies using AI in their development but I can go as far as possible in not using it when I am making my own stuff. That includes searching only in engines that won’t show me AI summaries.
Could it have been the stats for the Steam Next Fest? I think those were higher than 50%, and I’m sure there is some bias in the likelihood of making a demo to show off when you can just “chatbbt, promotionalized I viriticl splice for demo day”
I can accept vibe coded recomps, decomps and other derivative work. LLMs are pretty good in translating crap from one language to another, updating libraries and preparing the environment. But for creative work? No thank you
Yep, and memory+storage is getting there. Soon nobody will care about game quality anymore as nobody will have a decent computer anymore to play them with.
Comments
it’s always been the case that half was garbage. not much has changed except overall volume
“Half of the new games on steam are lazy cash grabs attempting to ride the coat tails of something popular”
I noticed my interest in new games was rapidly declining and it correlates with the rise of AI, even if its not a direct cause and effect relationship.
So I really wouldn’t say my interest in gaming is subsiding. It just shifted in a very specific way and if it were up to me AAA gaming and games with use of AI would die.
Only half? I’m vaguely surprised.
Already? Hard to believe
Most games being released were always slop. This changes nothing.
I think it means that you’ll have to be annoyingly extra aware of how AI is used and what’s generative AI bullshit slop and what’s not. Not dissimilar to the asset flipping bullshit was even more prevalent a few years ago.
I hate the phrase “Made with AI” for many nested reasons. Some of which:
“AI” is a meaningless buzzword now.
“Made” to what extent? That could be anything line autocompletion to spammy vibecoding, from invisible diffusion prototyping/editing to horrific in-game visuals.
The tone is “Twitter accusatory.” It ropes in innocent, minimal tool usage with full-on spammers, with zero nuance.
Its a red herring for the fundamental issue: waves of games being spammy slop, which was a huge issue even before “AI.”
It also discounts the other ethical issues we were grappling with. If we are going to talk ethics, are we just going to forget what companies like EA or Blizzard and such have done?
This needs to be discussed like a spectrum, and whether the intent is malicious. Not as a purity test of “was any AI used making this game?”
Slop is a byproduct of instrumental convergence, which is a byproduct of an individualist extractive culture.
You had the same backlash around CGI and digital artwork back when those things were novel, and neither were responsible for the wave of shitty Disney animated sequels, which was a prominent form of industrial slop at the turn of the millennium.
Intelligence is collective and shared, and the support systems for creators make them dependant of claiming “ownership” which is blatantly impossible to attach to things like “style,” so you get kids on tumblr fighting each other over who had a specific anime inspired aesthetic ‘first.’
Also see how certain inventions get invented in completely different environments at the same time. A lot of invention is just luck mixed with the privilege of being allowed to comfortably explore that space while still getting to survive, so the current social structure allows those with more of such privilege to claim ownership in the entire area of thought or action, limiting everyone else for the sake of the individual, or the system which they are supporting, who got the right mix of serendipity and privilege. (mixed with personal context and probably a lot of hard work.)
So, basically our current society makes slop inevitable, while privilege the wealthy, and ensuring the poor endlessly fight for scraps while the wealthy continue to extract and hoard.
I wish people care as much about system shaping as they care about conflating artists and ‘artists’ in usage of a specific tool.
Also, do we include dependencies too?
Because if we do… then almost every game is “Made with AI”, given now glibc has AI authored code in it too.
Or the software stacks the gamers are running, for that matter. The APIs, the platforms… as examples, do people really think Valve isn’t using LLMs to develop Steam? Or Nvidia/AMD/Intel/Microsoft for their graphics stacks?
And I don’t mean that as a hostile “you participate in society?” thing, just that it’s inconsistent to judge “AI or no AI” as black and white.
Lost me on the last bullet point. Saying we can’t address any issue without addressing every issue is an effective way of getting nothing addressed.
It’s like saying “all lives matter”. Yes, all issues matter, but this just derails the conversation instead of letting them have their own space to be discussed.
we don’t address any issue here at Lemmy. We just complain.
1000004860
I’m going to save so much fucking money.
AI is a tool at the end of the day. Like every tool in the hands of someone who knows that they doing it’s great. But in the hands of a dumbass on the other hand.
if you’re a single dev working on a game there’s likely some gap in your skill set that can be filled with AI. “made with ai = bad” is a very short sighted way to look at things that lacks any nuance.
The real news should be that 1/2 the game released are lying about not using AI.
you really think 100% of devs are using ai coding tools and ai generated content?
because I know a fuckton of devs who revile the shit. content and code generation.
I’m not a code guy but I know multiple devs who don’t even like inline suggestion stuff.
So, not all devs. There’s a bunch who really despise it all. Am one.
Always hear about how theres to much competition to make an indie game, but when at least half of them are obviously trite it starts to paint a different picture.
The problem is always visibility, which is reduced by slop and shovelwere
Just means more games I won’t buy. Ez pz
You might as well just not buy any software after 2025.
Its unrealistic to have any developer not use ai in any way in 2025. The tool is too useful and has too much power to be ignored. Even if you wanted to, every google search on how to fix some bug comes with an ai summary. Every IDE uses autocomplete. Having an AI review my personal code has had me fix bugs before i even test.
Its true there is alot of AI slop and low effort projects, but how its being used and to what level matter. Its not black and white. Linus Torvald, the creator of linux, one of, if not the smartest programmer on earth is using it.
https://www.computerworld.com/article/4235401/linus-torvalds-has-started-using-ai-to-develop-the-linux-kernel.html
As a developer in critical infrastructure we are prohibited to use it. Software was written before and writing the code was never the problem, it’s nearly always scope changes
Ah yes… critical infrastructure and games are the same…
My point isnt that ai is great or bad. Its a tool with certain uses, and treating it like black and white is a terrible take.
did you know autocomplete doesn’t have to use ai? we have invented this thing called a language server that can tell us about relevant things to write
I can’t avoid some of my tools or dependencies using AI in their development but I can go as far as possible in not using it when I am making my own stuff. That includes searching only in engines that won’t show me AI summaries.
Did you know you can do programming by making holes in punch cards?
…the question is, why would you?
last i checked my pc can’t run punch card code so weird equivalence but ok
Only half, I coulda sworn that number was higher earlier this year. Is it going down?
Could it have been the stats for the Steam Next Fest? I think those were higher than 50%, and I’m sure there is some bias in the likelihood of making a demo to show off when you can just “chatbbt, promotionalized I viriticl splice for demo day”
There could be a digital landfill with bad AI ET game packs
It’s called EPIC Store ;)
I can accept vibe coded recomps, decomps and other derivative work. LLMs are pretty good in translating crap from one language to another, updating libraries and preparing the environment. But for creative work? No thank you
I really don’t think so. Various ports and such have taken fucking forever. I tried (admittedly 2 years ago) and got shit results.
Two years is a long time in the AI field. Major developments happen in weeks.
For example, the Oracle of Time remake was released for the Switch 2 on Nov 5th. Someone had a playable PC port the next day. https://www.xda-developers.com/zelda-ocarina-of-time-reportedly-already-runs-on-pc-emulator-just-hours-afterswitch-2-release/
That problem will fix itself once the extant GPUs give up the ghost. It’s not like anybody can afford a new graphics card. Ironic, really.
Yep, and memory+storage is getting there. Soon nobody will care about game quality anymore as nobody will have a decent computer anymore to play them with.
Don’t worry - there’s a cloud gaming subscription solution for that.
Half of new games on PC are now made with compilers. How does this reflect on the gaming industry?
Sign in to comment. Sign in