Skip to content

Comment on GrapheneOS accuses Google of gatekeeping Android 17 features and security fixes

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • They don’t particularly like Linux as a platform from a security standpoint:

    https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49594106

    0
    • But somehow Android, which is based on Linux, somehow checks those points for them…

      The hipocrisy is too big to ignore and it’s true, with that mindset of just wanting and waiting for someone else to do the hard work for them to just add patches here and there… they’re doomed to fail.

      0
      • Android uses the Linux kernel but is not a GNU Linux distro if you need a distinction.

        0
      • I don’t think you understand how different Android and Linux distributions truly are.

        Linux alone refers to the kernel. There are custom AOSP kernels based on the Linux LTS versions with a few extra patches but that is basically all that connects Linux to Android.

        But absolutely everything in userland is wholly diifferent in Android than with any Linux distribution out there.

        And you can’t just replicate what Android did on top of the Linux kernel without Google amounts of resources. Which GrapheneOS does not have in the slightest.

        0
        • Yeah but I think that’s just changed with ai.

          0
        • I don’t think you understand how different Android and Linux distributions truly are.

          But they’re both things that drive on the same road, using wheels and engines and steering wheels and seats and doors!

          Yes, and one is a car and one is a semi truck. (I’m not saying either is close to those things, the point is how different Android and Linux are)

          0
    • Maybe they need to look at haiku. :-p

      0

Sign in to comment. Sign in