Skip to content

Comment on China Switches on World's Biggest Example of New, Cheap Green Energy Storage

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • If it were competitive to run that process for storage, H2 prices would take a dive. H2 prices are just a symptom, not the cause for H2 being not competitive for storage.

    Fuel cell efficiency is certainly not commonly as low as 20%. As far as I understand it is commonly 40-60%.

    Electrolysis requiring energy is the whole point of a storage technology.

    -1
    • Here your source. Well you were talking about H2 being the efficient option. There is energy efficiency, volumetric efficiency, life cycle (in the sense of how long does the plant last, wind turbines last for 20-25 years, how sustainable are the resources and are they recyclable), even plant space needed.

      As it stands now H2 prices need to go up for it to make green H2 competitive. Idk what you are on about, milk prices are a symptom of farmers wanting enough compensation for their work, that’s why you find milk for different prices depending on the form of agriculture. More land for the cow and organic will mean its more expensive, you can’t make this any more competitive because it isn’t. Grey H2 also produces energy in production and you can’t compete with that, hence the price of H2 needs to go up e.g. via CO2 tax.

      Storage storing energy is indeed the point of it, but the question is also how much money do you want to pay for the energy? Did you buy any oil recently?

      0
      • @Jiral@lemmy.world· · edited

        Appears as if I was not off that much. 60% fuel cell efficiency, 38% cycle efficiency.

        I think you got it a bit backwards. The point of storage is just that: storage. Using something that does not store energy but release energy from carbon sources is not storage. That is energy “production”. Energy storage is a highly researched subject because there is an upcoming large demand for it, both in a scale of 24h, mid-term and also seasonal. This arises from wind and solar power delivering power in a fluctuating extend.

        Renewable energies (which energy storage is a part of) is way more isolated from far off sourced oil and gas. There is a reason why Europe is massively investing in renewables, it is a strategic imperative to do so. Storage technologies are a key technological component to got from 50% to close to 100% renewable energy and insulating the energy base from exactly that world market on old dirty energy. That renewable energy is leading to an explosion in energy prices is not really supported by reality, is it? After all, gas is pushing electricity prices up right now, not wind or solar power.

        0

Sign in to comment. Sign in