Comment on Van Hollen calls to abolish Senate filibuster, rules out 2028 White House bid
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
The filibuster is the primary reason Republicans have any shot at all at national power.
Republicans thrive on voter apathy. They want voters to believe that both sides are the same, and that the government is incapable of doing anything useful.
What happens again and again is, Democrats will do the impossible. They’ll rally public support and anger and win great power on the promise of improving people’s lives. And then they manage to deliver jack shit because of the filibuster. Then they lose the next election because they never got anything done.
Yes, Republicans will be able to do more damage without the filibuster. But here’s the key - the filibuster didn’t prevent them from doing any of the horrific shit they have in the second Trump term. This is because Republicans don’t actually want to pass much legislation. The things they most want, tax and spending cuts, can be passed with a simple majority. They do everything else with the power of the presidency alone. You can gut a government program with a simple majority vote - just defund it. But establishing a new program requires 60 votes. The filibuster is inherently biased towards Republican policy priorities.
I like the accountability angle. While this is powerful, I’m not so sure about the entire premise of your remaining argument.
Specifically, you note Republicans can easily defund programs, while Democrats need 60 votes to establish them. But eliminating or reducing funding is not always the same as repealing a program.
For example, a future Republican majority might want to:
The filibuster doesn’t just determine which policies can be enacted; it affects how easily every subsequent majority can reverse them.
Bottom line: If Democrats could enact their entire agenda with 51 Senate votes, would they accept Republicans having exactly the same power in two years?
Yes. Because the entire reason we are falling into fascism is that the government can’t get shit done. Gridlock is what’s causing fascism. People feel their regular elected leaders can’t do anything, so they fall for a strong man promising to force change through.
A government that cannot pass necessary policy, one that is trapped forever in gridlock, is one that is inevitably bound for dictatorship.
Let Republican enact their terrible policies. We just saw what happens when Republicans actually manage to enact their agenda - they get massacred in the next election.
And all the stuff you listed could in turn be reversed just as easily with another simple majority vote. The rest of the world gets along just fine without the filibuster. You’re suffering from the delusion of American exceptionalism.
I was with you until the end. I don’t suffer from shit, thanks. Sorry/not sorry you don’t like people pointing out the fallacies in your arguments.
How is what they said wrong? Even if you disagree that you suffer from it, it’s absolutely American exceptionalism to say that only an undemocratic and arcane rule that only the US Senate has is somehow required for democracy.
Never said it was required. You suffer from inability to read. I also already explained how you were wrong, in clear language, at least in one of the many ways.
Sign in to comment. Sign in