Skip to content

Comment on AMD wants gamers to remember Radeon loyalty, days after declaring itself a data center-first company

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • The reasons I got an AMD GPU for my gaming machine:

    • much better support for Linux gaming

    That’s it. That’s the list.

    Neither Nvidia nor AMD (nor also-ran Intel) have come out with meaningfully novel hardware approaches in a long fucking time. It’s all horizontal scaling on the die (plus “let’s add more memory”) combined with incremental efficiency improvements in die layouts and chip lithography process / feature size.

    This is why monopolies are bad. They have a vested interest in acquiring and/or killing any company - indeed, any innovation - that has even a slight potential to disrupt their market dominance.

    133
    • meaningfully novel hardware approaches

      This isn’t really possible anymore (at least unaided by LLM). In the era of fixed function pipelines, it was possible to do something new under the hood.

      The current standards of Vulkan and DirectX have exposed a lot of inner workings to extract performance which makes it hard to make a large shift. While this makes it easy to use the HW, it also makes it hard for the devs to have a single algorithm for diff HWs, ie, each new feature will need in investment by them.

      For any novel functionality, devs will not like to work on features only on a small set of HW, unless they are aided by HW vendors. This creates a chicken egg situation: new features don’t get prioritized up by devs which makes it hard to market the features which makes it a small market which makes it likely not to be a priority by devs.

      In this era where code is cheap, perhaps we’ll see more fast moving devs and HW both

      7
      • You’re not considering FPGAs, or the analog domain. For example:

        0
        • AI needs much simpler HW (since the SW is bespoke) and that’s why we see so many startups tackling this. I’m sure as ML becomes a bigger part of gaming (via coop matrix and LinAlg), we might see analog entering the gaming HW.

          Gaming HW has a lot more cruft added on by standards and legacy SW. The number of gaming HW startups can be counted on one hand. QC and Apple have taken generations to get their HW ready. Even Intel needed 2 generations for their dGPU despite having a long line of iGPU

          FPGA are very inefficient as compared to ASIC and need dedicated programming. It feels further than analog if we’re talking about a gaming HW using them

          0
    • Nvidia has released lots of innovation. Mostly in software, but still really cool stuff. Shame about their non-Windows driver support, though.

      2
    • Collapsed, score -17 is below -5. 5 replies hidden.

Sign in to comment. Sign in