the fifth freedom is the freedom to own humans, apparently 🙃
(no, i am not making this up. yes, someone asked gnu maintainers if hypothetical code oritinating from slave labour would be fine to contribute. yes, these fucks answered YES without hesitation.)
What the fuck?
Like, no discussion or explanation of their rationale, just “must be YES” as if that’s obvious?
Come on… Free software really shouldn’t be Slave Labor GNU/AI Slop Linux.
There’s so much public attention on the enshittification of everything in computing and growing momentum around free software alternatives… I do wish the people behind big free software projects would not say this sort of shit.
From the emacs-devel mailing list (Archive). Was about to post this myself. The world deserves such a better free software movement than the one these guys have built.
I hope the Human Emacs fork goes ahead, because I love Emacs too much to give it up.
First, there is the Is–ought problem, in which an observation that the GPL is compatible with code originating from slave labor or AI is magicked into the moral imperative that such code must be accepted.
Comments
Screenshot of a question asked to a GNU maintainer: "as a hypothetical example: if i live in a territory that permits slavery, and by law i am granted sole ownership of the products of that forced labor, and then i use that to create contributions to gnu emacs, complete with copyright assignment, and it is technically correct, and, above all, you, the emacs maintainers are aware of how this was produced, would it be ethical to accept those contributions?". To which the answer from the GNU maintainer was "Our answer must be YES."
the fifth freedom is the freedom to own humans, apparently 🙃
(no, i am not making this up. yes, someone asked gnu maintainers if hypothetical code oritinating from slave labour would be fine to contribute. yes, these fucks answered YES without hesitation.)
This sort of mentality is why Linus thinks „Linux isn’t political“ is a rational statement. FLOSS is great, the dudes in it have long been not.
“I’m apolitical” is literally a political stance, making such a person political
What the fuck? Like, no discussion or explanation of their rationale, just “must be YES” as if that’s obvious? Come on… Free software really shouldn’t be Slave Labor GNU/AI Slop Linux.
There’s so much public attention on the enshittification of everything in computing and growing momentum around free software alternatives… I do wish the people behind big free software projects would not say this sort of shit.
That is wild, but I guess not totally surprising given the ethical implications of AI.
From the emacs-devel mailing list (Archive). Was about to post this myself. The world deserves such a better free software movement than the one these guys have built.
I hope the Human Emacs fork goes ahead, because I love Emacs too much to give it up.
thank you for the source!
This meme is actually my response to that discussion. Eight slaves and constantly swapping? Maybe edit.com isn’t so bad.
why wouldn’t the answer be yes?
First, there is the Is–ought problem, in which an observation that the GPL is compatible with code originating from slave labor or AI is magicked into the moral imperative that such code must be accepted.
Because it’s horrendously unethical and utterly awful to coöperate with slavers.
Sign in to comment. Sign in