Skip to content

Comment on After 26 years, the US has lost its measles elimination status

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • While I’m no fan of RFK, I don’t think you can give him ALL the credit. Our President deserves some credit as well. And then there is every single person who opted out. This was coming with or without RFK, he just hurried it along.

    20
    • If the law in the US was just, so much of what’s happening there would be illegal, so many people would have to face consequences. I truly hope this will happen one day. Start from the top, and those two guys are certainly up there.

      6
      • @arrow74@lemmy.zip· · edited

        This is absolutely the crux of the issue. RFK Jr. likely, at least from a policy standpoint, hasn’t done anything illegal in this role. Our agencies and their administration were built with a level of trust that those appointed would work for the common good. It was believed that even if the president was insane that Congress would never approve an incompetent person to head a department. Yet here we are.

        I’m sure he’s taking illegal bribes that could lead to some charges, but stuff like the constant food recalls and allowing these terrible diseases to come back likely isn’t illegal.

        There’s also probably a lot of crimes in his personal life, but causing children to die of preventable disease is perfectly legal. Very messed up situation

        5
        • Our agencies and their administration were built with a level of trust that those appointed would work for the common good.

          Germany needed one Third Reich to learn from that mistake, and its current legal apparatus is very focused on not relying on Trust Me Bro. It’s called Gewaltenteilung, which is sometimes translated as checks and balances, but I find the German term to be less ambiguous. It means Separation of powers.

          I mean most other countries also have that but Germany’s goes a few steps further, and also served as a blueprint for others. And last but not least, Americans also had a hand in the post-war process there, so … America used to be better?

          2
          • We also have checks and balances/seperation of powers, it was just assumed that all 3 branches would never be compromised at the same time.

            Basically imagine the AFD controls every power in the government. If I recall Germany has some more rigidity in the constitution with certain provisions that can never be changed. Which helps a lot, but overall the German system is strikingly similar to the American one. It is a bit more refined though

            3
            • Or that Congress would cede its power to the executive. The president is supposed to be a fairly weak position.

              The longer this goes on, the more I think we should dump the current system and adopt a full parliamentary system. Proportional representation and ranked choice voting. Make the president ceremonial again.

              4
            • We also have (…) seperation of powers

              Not so much since the Patriot Act (if ruling by decree is possible)

              Basically imagine the AFD controls every power in the government. If I recall Germany has some more rigidity in the constitution with certain provisions that can never be changed. Which helps a lot, but overall the German system is strikingly similar to the American one. It is a bit more refined though

              That’s pretty much what happened in 1933, and that’s why it’s “a bit more refined” now.

              -1
              Continue this thread 4 more replies
        • hes also deep in the epstein files himself.

          0
    • @TrickDacy@lemmy.world· · edited

      How can you possibly know this would’ve happened without RFK? But even if you’re right, hurried along isn’t really better. That’s like saying “he was going to die anyway, I just hurried that process along, it’s not murder!”

      His job is literally the opposite of hurrying disease along. Hell even if it wasn’t his job and he was some other cabinet member who accidentally influenced people to not be vaccinated one time with one misstatement, in my mind even that still should mean prosecutable culpability.

      4
    • Anti-measles vaccine sentiment has been going on a long time. Well before Trump. Saw this frequently in South Orange County, CA.

      2

Sign in to comment. Sign in