Skip to content

Comment on Trump to meet with Putin and Xi in China next week, US officials say

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • He seems to really like spending time with those two.

    57
    • He likes to think of himself as equal to them, after decades of looking up to them.

      But he is no dictator and apparently still subject to votes. Real and impostor dictators know that alike, and thus he will be subjected to the other two.

      23
      • @wheezy@lemmy.ml· · edited

        I’m genuinely curious if people think Xi is in the same ballpark of corruption and garbage as Putin and Trump. Like, do average western people think that Xi would even qualify for the Piece of Shit Olympics? Trump and Putin are actively engaging in illegal wars of aggression while the infrastructure and quality of life of the countries they rule crumble. I just feel like their taking home Gold and Silver medals and Xi is barely getting past the qualifications.

        2
        • Not being as evil as Putin or Trump is the lowest bar imaginable. China does not need to work hard to be the lesser evil, and yet they still prolong civil wars for selfish gain, even when the consequences affect their own citizens. They still let their companies do whatever they want so long as it helps the state. They still violate the sovereignty of most of their neighbors, just as they’ve historically done for thousands years. They might not be as interested in expansionary ethnic cleansing in quite the same way as America or Russia, but that’s simply because they prefer influence over occupation. They aren’t better out of benevolence, but because they have a different imperial strategy.

          8
          • yet they still prolong civil wars for selfish gain

            Would be interested in what specific conflicts you’re referring to. I am definitely critical of China for engaging in trade with essentially zero care for the conditions of the state they are trading with. Israel being the obvious criticism. Are those types of trade relations with countries what you’re referring to? I agree if that’s what you mean.

            They still let their companies do whatever

            This is in conflict to the normal complaints of China “disappearing” people. So, are you saying they don’t do that? Because the famous cases of this are from businessmen that start speaking against the party, or doing actual social crimes.

            I have criticism of China’s free speech restrictions on individual citizens. But to say that China “let’s companies do whatever they want” is in complete contradiction to the countless “violations of freedom” that the Western media speaks about. Because those are entirely made up of the capitalist of China stepping out of line with the party; or engaging in social murder like crimes.

            They aren’t better out of benevolence, but because they have a different imperial strategy.

            I hear the language of the left here being used in a non material way. If you’re someone that has the word “imperial strategy” in your vocabulary it shocks me to hear someone describe a system based on idealism as the core. “The purpose of a system is what it does.” Its odd to conclude with a point of criticism that is rooted in idealism. It is rooted in the western idea that China is just “waiting for its moment of attack” with no material reason to conclude that.

            If China wanted to start being aggressive and start it’s Imperialist expansion there was no better time than the Iran invasion. You think America was ready to defend Taiwan when it was taking interceptors out of Korea to send them to Israel? Yet China decided to “wait” and instead reduce its purchases of oil to assist it’s trade partners in East Asia.

            At a certain point this “waiting for the right moment” Imperialist China narrative needs to die. They have proven their intentions are based entirely on offering a less parasitic form of trade than the US offers. One that is entirely without the use of military conflict.

            I’m not sure how you can call that imperial strategy in a world where US Imperialism still exists. If the US was gone. Sure, it would be insane to engage in trade relations with states like Israel. But, you’re criticism is in a vacuum and not in the context of the cold war being waged against China by the west.

            4
            • It’s fascinating how you seem to assume that China is fundamentally incapable of being an empire because worse empires exist. It’s especially nonsensical when you look at how empires were understood in the past, including in China. The past dynasties of China were self defined as empires, and yet many Marxists seem to believe that those imperial systems have no influence on the modern day; that communist states have progressed beyond the way power worke. I find the assumption absurd and cannot have a discussion with people who believe in that reality.

              I also don’t believe China is “just waiting for the right moment.” They are not gonna turn into America, or even Russia for that matter. Them having “their own strategy” literally means “their own strategy.” They will do certain things like encourage companies to take the place of American companies, but this is nothing new and simply an extension of how they’ve outplayed neoliberals at their own game. They aren’t gonna suddenly invade and permanently occupy neighboring countries with distinct cultures; they aren’t gonna exterminate populations like America or displace the population of subjugated peoples in a federal system. The most they’ll do is promote Han nationalism to suppress cultures that have long been part of China. I simply believe they’ll continue to be as they are now; as an empire.

              I also don’t see how the government disappearing people is mutually exclusive with letting their pet aristocracy abuse the peasants. I’ve met members of this social class during my schooling, and they have the same difference in privileges and rights as the wealthy anywhere else. I have an ultimately limited view into what life is like in China, but from what I have seen, it’s clear that capitalism thrives, and in capitalist systems the police serve capital.

              Finally, I’m disappointed that you haven’t heard of Myanmar and how its instability has enabled extensive human trafficking that many Chinese nationals have fallen victim to. I’m not gonna pretend to know how to solve Myanmar’s problems, but I don’t see how Chinese support of their military has been anything more than safeguarding their own assets. Just like many neighboring capitalist nations, desperation leaves people vulnerable to exploitation; the only difference is that China has more ability to influence things than the rest.

              0
        • His imperial and antidemocratic features manifest a bit differently, and he has no need for that open corruption, because he is indistinguishable from the party and therefore from the state. Fine. He also has much more grounded ideological background than Trump, as the other commenter pointed out. But then, Putin has that one too. As did Mussolini. This does not make anyone a good human.

          After all that he’s still an imperial and antidemocratic autocrat. I’m not very picky with my words. Sorry if the term dictator offended you.

          9
          • Which saved them from israeli infiltration and olgarchopoly

            1
            • Are you trying to find a little light in the darkness of a system that will incarcerate and “reeducate” you as soon as you speak out against its leader, by using the old rhetorical devices whataboutism, and antisemitism?

              -1
              Continue this thread 7 more replies
        • Insecure men make for terrible leaders

          0
        • Yes. Unironically yes. They believe China is a dictatorship that reveres Xi for no reason other than he’s a ‘brutal’ dictator that ‘took charge by force.’

          Westerners unironically have no concept of how Chinese democracy works, and cannot name a single part of the Chinese government. Most people don’t even realize Xi is more educated than all US presidents and most US elected representatives, and has written more than a half dozen books explaining every bit of the current party philosophy, including all of China’s failures and his own contemporary failures and how the party has improved.

          -5
          • Most people don’t even realize Xi is more educated than all US presidents and most US elected representatives, and has written more than a half dozen books explaining every bit of the current party philosophy, including all of China’s failures and his own contemporary failures and how the party has improved.

            Sounds like Woodrow Wilson to me. Funny thing about him is that all his education and intellect did not make the liberal world order he envisioned any better, nor did it make the racism he promoted justified. It’s not like the League of Nations did anything for world peace, and I doubt you want to defend the rigid nation-state framework and neoliberal fiscal policies of the UN.

            On top of that, I can’t take the “philosophy” of politicians seriously; it coming from a head of state makes it propaganda to justify their own authority. Philosophy works best as a conversation, an open dialectic where one side of it doesn’t have the absolute authority of a superpower backing them up. It just comes across more like cult shit from a technocratic state capitalist.

            1
            • I… don’t understand how you’re arguing against the concept of education and doctoral theses along with peer-reviewed research and getting upvotes, but you do you I guess.

              0
              Continue this thread 2 more replies
      • Real and impostor dictators know that alike, and thus he will be subjected to the other two

        Huh?

        0
    • @stumu415@lemmy.zip· · edited

      You do realize even though Trump visited China twice, there has been no progress or signed agreements on anything. The Chinese are just playing him and doing their own thing. They do like trolling him for example they gave Melinia rose seeds for the rose garden, being well aware this has been paved over.

      Xi and Putin also do not have a good relationship.

      This meeting will be a big nothing burger.

      2

Sign in to comment. Sign in