Skip to content

Comment on Trump to meet with Putin and Xi in China next week, US officials say

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • Maybe, and everyone is free to write a book about that.
    Meanwhile Norway has regulation to prevent false allegations, free speech is not absolute.
    So the correct way to handle this would be to sue the publisher to have the book removed.

    I don’t give a shit if the book is right or wrong, you can’t have China demand the book removed, whether it is false or not.
    The correct path of action would be to use the regulation in place that prevent false accusations.

    It seems you don’t even grasp the concept. Just as a totalitarian regime doesn’t grasp the concept of freedom of speech.

    the request was the same internationally

    Bullshit

    -1
    • So the correct way to handle this would be to sue the publisher to have the book removed.

      I don’t give a shit if the book is right or wrong, you can’t have China demand the book removed, whether it is false or not. The correct path of action would be to use the regulation in place that prevent false accusations.

      So besides contradicting yourself… did you have a point? Did you expect China to magically understand Norway’s quite literally insane legal system where anyone can publish lies until someone spends millions suing them? Why do you think it’s unreasonable for someone to expect a government to uphold its own regulations without private lawsuits between two parties that are not the government?

      Wouldn’t it be much better to, you know, report this violation of Norwegian law, as you put it, to the Norwegian government… like China did?

      It seems you don’t even grasp the concept. Just as a totalitarian regime doesn’t grasp the concept of freedom of speech.

      I can disagree with a stupid concept while understanding it, I was hoping you’d catch on to how stupid you and other conspiracy theorists sound first. Also, Norway doesn’t have freedom of speech, on paper or in this case, using your own words.

      Bullshit

      Since the US has provided shelter for the Falun Gong (because they probably started it in the first place to try to destabilize China), China has sent requests to all countries publishing and entertaining their malicious lies to, you know, stop. These requests, like in Norway, were mostly ignored with only countries that happen to oppose the United States agreeing to stop publishing the lies. Usually after Falun Gong attacks in their country.

      -1
      • @Buffalox@lemmy.world· · edited

        So besides contradicting yourself

        There is no contradiction, your inability to read however is self evident. The correct path is to have it declared illegal in a court of law in Norway, the king can’t just declare it illegal, that’s not how things work in a democracy.
        I don’t know how you can be so ignorant about how democracy works, even an AI wouldn’t be this stupid.

        Since the US has provided shelter for the Falun Gong

        Seems you can’t get through your head that the issue is completely besides the point. It doesn’t matter if you are right or not. What matters is what a court in Norway decides, and the path to make the book illegal is through the courts. Not diplomatic pressure.

        You are debating the issue like an absolute moron with zero understanding about how things work.

        -1
        • There is no contradiction, your inability to read however is self evident. The correct path is to have it declared illegal in a court of law in Norway, the king can’t just declare it illegal, that’s not how things work in a democracy.

          Cool so when I behead a baby the baby has to sue me and prove that it was illegal? The government doesn’t do it?

          -1
          • @Buffalox@lemmy.world· · edited

            That is a false equivalence, those 2 things are under different segments of the law.
            Again obvious evidence of your complete lack of understanding how things work in a democracy.
            The murder of a child is a criminal offense, the publishing of a book that contain defamation is not. That’s exactly what free speech is protecting us against. Free speech is exactly to protect against prosecution by the state.

            Illegal and criminal is not the same.

            Pull yourself together man, stop being a moron, and educate yourself before holding strong beliefs that are so obviously wrong.

            -1
            • That is a false equivalence, those 2 things are under different segments of the law.

              Since 2007, which is ironically BEFORE the original request from China. But also proves that your values on ‘free speech’ change pretty dramatically and pretty randomly, so, again, how the fuck are foreigners supposed to know?

              Again obvious evidence of your complete lack of understanding how things work in a democracy.

              You keep using the word democracy, you don’t know what it means.

              The murder of a child is a criminal offense, the publishing of a book that contain defamation is not. That’s exactly what free speech is protecting us against.

              Again, since 2007 there has been a distinction, primarily due to pressure by the US to further privatize rights. So now only rich people have the ability to protect themselves from defamation, just like the US.

              Free speech is exactly to protect against prosecution by the state.

              Persecution, not prosecution, otherwise terroristic threats would not be criminalized.

              Pull yourself together man, stop being a moron, and educate yourself before holding strong beliefs that are so obviously wrong.

              Please, stop being a racist piece of shit believing objectively false and implausible information about China because you think Asians are bug people with no concept of self-determination.

              -1
              Continue this thread 5 more replies

Sign in to comment. Sign in