I think Ranked Robin or STAR voting should be used nationwide. The former is the better version of Ranked Choice voting, while the later is mathematically the same as Ranked Robin and can be used in certain Republican states where Ranked Choice voting is banned.
Nope, that’s false. You clearly have not read the actual clause in the Constitution and are just assuming it says what you want it to say. Congress can overwrite the state rules at any time for any reason in any way it likes with two restrictions:
The new rules cannot violate the US Constitution.
They cannot change the location that senators are chosen.
Art. 1 § 4, Cl. 1:
The Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by Law make or alter such Regulations, except as to the Places of chusing Senators.
Comments
We need it nationwide.
I think Ranked Robin or STAR voting should be used nationwide. The former is the better version of Ranked Choice voting, while the later is mathematically the same as Ranked Robin and can be used in certain Republican states where Ranked Choice voting is banned.
the states individually control how they do elections
And every state needs to adopt it.
Congress can overwrite state election rules as they pertain to federal elections.
Only if the state rules are unconstitutional.
Nope, that’s false. You clearly have not read the actual clause in the Constitution and are just assuming it says what you want it to say. Congress can overwrite the state rules at any time for any reason in any way it likes with two restrictions:
Art. 1 § 4, Cl. 1:
I stand corrected. Note that this is for congressional elections.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution-conan/article-1/section-4/clause-1/congress-and-the-elections-clause
Sign in to comment. Sign in