Skip to content

Comment on Alaska voters reject ballot measure seeking to repeal open primaries, ranked voting system

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • Ranked voting also accomplishes this end.

    15
    • @chaogomu@lemmy.world· · edited

      Except it doesn’t at all.

      All Ordinal voting systems trend towards two party dominance. Because all Ordinal voting systems have some degree of spoiler effect.

      The Marquis de Condorcet wrote about the mathematical flaws of a system identical to Ranked Choice back in 1785. His chief complaint was that it could not reliably elect the pair-wise winner, that is, the person who would win a one on one election against every other candidate. Condorcet found that the more candidates that you add, the less likely you’ll see the pair-wise winner be elected.

      There is hope, Cardinal voting systems exist, and tend to work better the more candidates you have (to a point).

      STAR was designed back in 2014. It’s good.

      2
      • @q_q@feddit.org· · edited

        There is hope

        Nah bro

        ~Kenneth Arrow

        0
        • Arrow’s Impossibility Theorem only applies to Ordinal voting systems.

          Cardinal systems are in fact, immune, for the simple fact that you can rate each candidate equally, and thus you have full independence of irrelevant alternatives.

          -2
    • No, it clearly has not. Identify one member of the US Congress elected by instant-runoff voting who isn’t from one of the two major parties.

      -2
      • Small sample size fallacy.

        How about from a country that actually has used RCV more than a handful of times?

        4
      • I’m referring to ranked choice voting accomplishing that ending of your note. I’m not referring to run offs.

        0
        • “Instant-runoff voting” is the generic name for what is called “ranked-choice voting” in North America, “alternative vote” in the UK, and “preferential voting” in Australia.

          Instant-runoff voting and ranked-choice voting are one and the same.

          0

Sign in to comment. Sign in