Skip to content

Comment on Hundreds of men lead protest to urge other men to help reduce violence against women

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Fuck yeah let’s go fellow dudes! We need way more of good men pushing back hard against bad men!

    44
    • Yes, I agree, but it’s not really “good vs. bad” men. The reality has much more shades and even the best of us have been soaked in the patriarchic swamp. Nearly all of us are tainted one way or another and it’s important to acknowledge this. It’s important to make steps forward, all of us, out of the swamp, step by step. Some of the steps might involve to face some very confronting truths.

      4
      • Thank you for linking that recent study.

        This is one of the first studies to our knowledge to directly survey men anonymously about recent attempts to force an unwilling and nonconsenting woman to have sex. Our aim was to advance work in this area by gathering men’s perspectives regarding the strategies they used to enact sexual aggression against a woman with whom they had no established intimate or sexual history. Our reassurances of anonymity likely proved essential as 95% of the 2,689 men reported at least one effort to force such a woman into sex that they knew she did not want. In approximately two-thirds of those occasions, the men were successful in forcing sex. This study indicates that efforts to force women into sex are common and in fact now far better correspond to the high rates of forced sex that women report experiencing at the hands of men (Bonnesen et al., 2025; Mahon et al., 2024).

        3
      • I fully respect the shades of grey and the challenges involved.

        That said stand by my good vs bad characterization. Until men pull themselves out of the swamp they might be able to become good but they aren’t yet good.

        I think we need to be able to call this out explicitly, it’s not a judgment on their character for all time, but I think men need to know what to be striving for and that until they make progress down that road they can’t call themselves good men.

        Everyone has set backs and issues from time to time, and honestly if someone is actively working on it and is able to admit they have issues I’d call them a good man, but if they are stuck in the swamp they need to be called bad until they start crawling out.

        1
    • Collapsed, score -65 is below -5. 9 replies hidden.

Sign in to comment. Sign in