Comment on PieFed v1.9 is released - Shared Blocklists, Auto-bans and TOTP
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
Interesting. Either I scrolled past it or didn’t know what it was and ignored it.
Is there any history on why it was forked? Could be useful to add to the repo.
according to the PyLova devs, it was forked to remove the hard-coded (at that time) censorship in Piefed, especially the anti-memes censor and upvote punishment. memes are a valued and culturally important form of self-expression, and even if the Piefed author is from an older generation, it doesn’t mean those memes should have to swim upriver just to get the same engagement on Piefed as they do on Lemmy.
Anti-memes censor and upvote punishment? Is this real? 😂
To an extent yes. Specifically Rimu has a thing against 4chan and PieFed has a simple detection if an image is a 4chan screenshot. There is also the ability to mark communities as low quality, which means that upvotes on posts in “low-quality“ communities will not increase you Karma/Reputation (which isn’t shown to users anyway so I don’t see why people care so much).
This has not been hard-coded though, at least not for a long time, many months before the PyLova fork. IMO a lot of people are vastly exaggerating the issues with PieFed to fuel their own agenda, which is actually sourced from some other drama that went down sometime before the PyLova fork. (I’m not exactly sure what happened here, there is a lot of deleted comments and banned users at some point)
yes, although after quite a bit of backlash, he apparently added a switch to turn off most of it. it seems that Rimu does not like memes, judging by the fact he added several functions to suppress them. things like marking meme comms “low quality”, making upvotes count less than on other posts, etc. those functions have been removed in PyLova for obvious reasons. memes are fun, and they are culturally relevant to millennials and Gen Z. and while it’s true that older generations like Rimu might not appreciate them as much, they shouldn’t be quietly punished without telling anyone.
Good to know. I guess if I ever sign up to another instance, it’ll be a pylova instance, not a piedfed one.
well having had the pleasure to speak with Mia in Matrix, moth can only highly recommend quokk.au, what one might consider the flagship PyLova instance. she does a terrific job and has surrounded herself with a cadre of very progressive people who genuinely care about the users and their wellbeing.
So the thing about autobans and shared blocklists… they help suppress knowledge about that stuff getting around.
Sign in to comment. Sign in