People complaining about shared blocklists and autobans don’t really get the philosophy of PieFed. It’s clearly very opinionated on particular moderation practices that many other people would consider questionable. That’s fine, that’s the devs prerogative. If you like it, use PieFed, if you don’t, don’t.
The thing about PieFed now making equivalent features that are seemingly intentionally incompatible with the PyLova fork though… that seems suspiciously deliberate to break federation between the platforms. This goes against the entire fediverse idea. That is what I would question more (though I don’t know the details of the incompatibility).
equivalent features that are seemingly intentionally incompatible with the PyLova fork though
Not doubting you because I am not following development of neither very closely, but what would be an example of “intentionally incompatible” features?
That’s great! I personally agree with you. The fediverse is so nice that you can simply choose not to use PieFed in that case, and the people who do prefer that sort of feature can choose to use PieFed if they desire. Everyone is happy.
Lemmy and piefed can interact with each other so the blocklist could also include lemmy users. Sheep mentality is bad, how many people who use those block list will investigate if all users really fit in that block list. Aboiding talking about problems do not solve the problems.
If a PieFed user blocks a Lemmy user because of a shared blocklist from another PieFed user, then that’s the PieFed’s users own choice for doing that. If they didn’t want such a shared blocklist functionality, they could just not use PieFed. Are you going to tell them that they can’t use an instance with a feature they prefer? That’s not very aligned to the ethos of the fediverse, which is that everyone gets to choose their preferred instance.
I don’t agree with that feature, but I’m not gonna tell other people how to live their lives. If they want shared blocklists, that’s their choice.
Do you realize that you can critize things without forcing anybody to do what you believe? What you are doing is toxic posivity where people can’t no longer critisize anything
I can’t work with or communicate with the PyLova people. I have too much trauma from the bullying campaign they continue to operate.
I’m giving away code. It’s a gift. Giving that gift does not put me under any obligations including talking with anyone else, especially not with groups which attack me and disparage me whenever they can.
The way I build PieFed is not intentionally incompatible with Pylova - that happens as a side-effect of me not talking to them and me never looking at their code.
Pretty sure those pointing out flaws in piefed get more bullying and harassment. But what do I know only have 1 user doing it today to me and another user
Perhaps I was clumsy and ham-handed with my work in this situation? Perhaps I didn’t follow social conventions about how FOSS projects are supposed to work together? I hope my corrective action was enough. What do you think?
Regardless, I am sorry for any problems I caused for the Pylova project and will not be doing that again. I wish them well with their fork.
Comments
People complaining about shared blocklists and autobans don’t really get the philosophy of PieFed. It’s clearly very opinionated on particular moderation practices that many other people would consider questionable. That’s fine, that’s the devs prerogative. If you like it, use PieFed, if you don’t, don’t.
The thing about PieFed now making equivalent features that are seemingly intentionally incompatible with the PyLova fork though… that seems suspiciously deliberate to break federation between the platforms. This goes against the entire fediverse idea. That is what I would question more (though I don’t know the details of the incompatibility).
Not doubting you because I am not following development of neither very closely, but what would be an example of “intentionally incompatible” features?
I don’t really know either, I was commenting on some other comments that mentioned it elsewhere in this thread.
People are pointing out the flawed philosophy of piefed. It’s explicitly designed with a singular person’s vision.
The issue is people are happy to ignore that completely and would rather attack those pointing it out than admit the issue.
Then there’s the piefed dev acting like the victim for their own terrible decisions and attacks on others.
I can’t interact with them because they call me out on my bullshit
It promote sheep mentality. I have my own brain to decide what I want to block and not blindly follow a blocklist
That’s great! I personally agree with you. The fediverse is so nice that you can simply choose not to use PieFed in that case, and the people who do prefer that sort of feature can choose to use PieFed if they desire. Everyone is happy.
Lemmy and piefed can interact with each other so the blocklist could also include lemmy users. Sheep mentality is bad, how many people who use those block list will investigate if all users really fit in that block list. Aboiding talking about problems do not solve the problems.
If a PieFed user blocks a Lemmy user because of a shared blocklist from another PieFed user, then that’s the PieFed’s users own choice for doing that. If they didn’t want such a shared blocklist functionality, they could just not use PieFed. Are you going to tell them that they can’t use an instance with a feature they prefer? That’s not very aligned to the ethos of the fediverse, which is that everyone gets to choose their preferred instance.
I don’t agree with that feature, but I’m not gonna tell other people how to live their lives. If they want shared blocklists, that’s their choice.
That’s the spirit
Do you realize that you can critize things without forcing anybody to do what you believe? What you are doing is toxic posivity where people can’t no longer critisize anything
I can’t work with or communicate with the PyLova people. I have too much trauma from the bullying campaign they continue to operate.
I’m giving away code. It’s a gift. Giving that gift does not put me under any obligations including talking with anyone else, especially not with groups which attack me and disparage me whenever they can.
The way I build PieFed is not intentionally incompatible with Pylova - that happens as a side-effect of me not talking to them and me never looking at their code.
Literally what the fuck are you on about?
💀💀💀
Pretty sure those pointing out flaws in piefed get more bullying and harassment. But what do I know only have 1 user doing it today to me and another user
Isn’t that your first rule? Yet your here doing exactly that while still attacking them?
Which is incompatible from what was said by you in just August
https://join.piefed.social/2026/08/14/did-piefed-steal-code-from-pylova-lets-look-at-what-happened/
Sign in to comment. Sign in