What exactly made the old internet better than the modern internet?
Probably asking for people to be educated on the difference as to what they’ve missed out from the internet back then compared to today. I think I have a good perspective since I’m one of the few out there who’ve been around the internet for three of its decades and have seen it develop into what it became.
For one thing, the internet wasn’t reliant on Cloudflare and it was fine. Try to imagine an internet, where you weren’t prompted by a stupid Cloudflare verification check that has a 50/50 chance of it failing. Captcha did exist back then but was no where near as annoying as it’s been designed to now. The only thing between you and getting into your account was a password. Nothing else. No stupid verification codes having to be sent to your phone or whatever else.
And it was fine.
Social Media was tamed. If we could only go back to where it was just Reddit, Facebook and MySpace, then things would be fine. Because that was all that we needed. Now we just have too many and it’s all saturated. Plus the versions of all of those platforms were at their best back then, no where near their broken malformed selves now.
Comments
The morons thought it was just for nerds and stayed off
Corporate slicing it up for profit… enter, algorithms
As an older person who lived through that time, I’d say… (sorry if I’m repeating anyone else’s points!)
It wasn’t as consolidated. Nowadays it’s like half a dozen sites that all just repost content from each other, but back then people just gathered in smaller groups on bulletin boards or had their own site.
Because of this, everything had a sort of home-made, ramshackle creativity to it which meant you got a lot of trash, but also some really neat weird stuff. For example, these days if you have a comic strip you don’t need a site necessarily, you can post it to reddit, Instagram, Facebook, Twitter etc. And sell your merch through a vendor site or set up a Patreon or whatever. Back then, you’d probably have had to make your own site for it.
Also because of this, bots and such were pretty useless. If you can brigade Facebook and get the majority of people to do something it can have a real effect. But there’d be no point in taking over a random BBS and radicalizing them.
No smart phones. You had to actually be at your computer in front of a keyboard to interact with the internet, you couldn’t really be online 24/7.
No influencers. Or at least not like we have them now. Having a website was more like having a scrapbook or a portfolio. You could maybe make some money from banner ads or selling merch if you were big, but the majority of it was just people doing it for the love of the game. There wasn’t really and algorithm to worry about, and no push for ‘engagement.’ People sometimes had a little counter to show how many visits their site had, but it was mostly just for bragging rights, it didn’t really do much.
A more recent one, but no AI of course. If you went to someone’s website, odds are that they probably coded it themselves, did the art etc. Just people making stuff to entertain (or annoy) other people.
That’s all that comes to mind for now, but yeah essentially it was just less corporate and more scrappy. There were still corporations on there of course, but they didn’t own the entire thing yet.
That wasn’t the old internet. That was web 2.0. The old internet was before corporate social media.
And it was glorious…
I still miss the days of dial up BBS. Even the fun of going through a bunch of random phone numbers until you found one that actually hosted something. I financially supported a few, wiring cash so they could upgrade their HD, modem, or something. And I was a fucking child; just forking over my meager savings to a board or two I visited often enough to know all the other regular visitors and form an actual bond with the admin.
https://lemmy.ca/pictrs/image/b54ad22b-b880-432d-b9f7-dddcb4002187.png
The internet used to be a library. You could visit where and when you want, browsing information relatively undisturbed.
Now; every corner of the internet is trying to sell you something, with many of them stealing your information in an attempt to leverage it against you to coerce or even force you to pay up.
I miss when an adblocker was a foreign concept, because it used to be a solution in search of a problem. Now ads are so invasive and overwhelming that browsing without blocking them is unbearable - if you can even browse without having to signup and subscribe to yet another ‘service’.
I read this here recently - used to be a library, now it’s a store.
Smart phones. Once they became ubiquitous there was a sizable shift to redesign all websites to be mobile responsive. With this movement corporations also realized there was a sizable untapped consumer base now. Younger people started getting online and didn’t enjoy using older social media platforms so migrated to things like Instagram and Snapchat, thus pushing in a new era where influencers became a viable career path. I am skipping a lot but you get the idea
i miss when people coded their own web pages with simple html, and there were niche sites for everything. you could probably find like a hundred dragon ball fan sites and they were all uniquely designed
Old internet was more than just the same 4 websites you visit every day
“The internet is a store, but it used to be a library.”
That’s actually a perfect way to put it
You have to be real misled to think the problem with the modern internet is CloudFlare captchas and not Facebook or Reddit.
Oh sweet child, when we say the internet before times, we’re talking about WAY before that bullshit
People were here for two things primarily:
It wasn’t about money. Nobody wanted to be a “streamer” or an “influencer”, they just liked X and wanted to go online and participate in X. People shared memes because they liked memes, or the website/community they shared them on, not because it brings you to their page where they can sell you something.
People made flash games because they loved gaming and wanted to create something and share it. People made blogs and vlogs just to share what they’re up to. People made tutorials and guides because they were good at something and wanted to help others. Sure, many websites had to do things like run ads to pay the bills but it didn’t feel like every step you took you were bombarded by someone trying to make money.
In the beginning (of the Internet), it was a giant bubble, much like the current AI hype. There was a flood of corporate money developing various services and protocols, and random people were able to take advantage of this speculation to build an internet that didn’t yet need to be profitable.
Then the dotcom bubble burst, and the only companies who made it out alive were the ones who figured out how to both offer the free services people wanted AND rake in cash for shareholders: data harvesters. (I remember a quote that I thought was from a Google engineer, but I haven’t been able to find it, but it was something like, “with enough datapoints, every problem is a regression problem.”)
Smarter Every Day likened the phenomenon of harvesting everyone’s data to pay for the services everyone wants to use “for free” to the advent of the internal combustion engine. Yes, it made industry possible, but at great cost to society. So they wondered, is there an “electric motor” for the Internet? A “renewable energy” we can use instead of relying on harm to fund things? To me, the Fediverse is the electric motor, but we haven’t yet figured out the renewable energy part. It’s still barely competing on funding through donations, which cam fluctuate or go away based on various factors.
I don’t think we figure out how to have a “better internet” at a large scale until we figure out how to fund it without data collection.
Your beginning sounds like the late 1990s’. I remember the early 1990s’ a bit differently, although internet was a luxury for me then, didn’t have the money fo it at jome and only used it at university … It was more about individual users setting up their own presence on the web. It felt more like the Federverse of today.
The beginning of the web, yeah. Usenet does count as the internet, and indeed was very Fediverse-y, but I’ll be surprised if that’s the direction the future internet goes, even in a best case scenario.
What made it great? Neither corporations nor everyday people had any interest in it. Nothing was tracking your every click. Netiquette was a real thing.
Oh my sweet summer child, Facebook has always been part of the new Internet.
The Internet has existed since the 1960s. At the time, it was a distributed network for storing documents. Email was invented as a way to send a file from one person to another, but people quickly realised it was more useful for asynchronous conversation. Usenet and IRC later arose, also as communication tools. The WWW began in 1993 at CERN as a way to store files and make them easily viewable by anybody.
Most of that was before my time, but I’m old enough to remember when the web was new. Email had existed for ages, but had only been used by American universities and DARPA. For most people, it was a brand new, futuristic communication system. People had actual personal conversations over email. We developed genuine friendships with people all over the world. Entire new types of jokes were formed.
On the WWW, which is what most people mean when they say Internet, HTML was a much smaller, simpler language. There was no PHP, no JavaScript, not even CSS. There were no rules, conventions, or expectations, and scant documentation; we were all making it up as we went along, and if you saw something cool on another site, you pressed Ctrl+u to view the source code and figure out how they did it.
Websites at the time were gloriously hideous. Objectively modern websites look better, but there was a craftsmanship in ye olden dayes. Nowadays, websites are built with CSS frameworks, which means they all look the same.
But the web was also distributed back then. Now, as someone put it, we have four huge websites, each full of screencaos if the other three. Back then, we talked to each other on forums, over email, in IRC channels and newsgroups. Those all still exist, but people have gradually abandoned them in favour of social media
But social media is crucially different from the old ways. Forums are built around threads; accounts exist, but the basic unit of interaction is the conversation.
The basic unit if social media is the account. You don’t follow conversations, you follow people. As such. there is an inherent push towards cultivating a persona and performing for an audience above having a genuine discussion. Sure, there were a few people who used Usenet that way (Kibo comes to mind), but social media encourages everybody to be Kibo.
And as others have said, SEO also devastated the web. SEO is as old as search engines. Used benignly, it’s simply a way to ensure people looking for information your site provides land on your site. But it turns out that it’s a deal with the devil in which the devil doesn’t even fabe to sign a contract or provide any services. Google, through its algorithms, decides what web pages people can find. Big sites spend money hiring people to make webpages with no intention of showcasing expertise, but in showing up on the first page if a Google search. Small sites run by enthusiasts are crowded out.
This was probably inevitable, but it’s still unfortunate.
Still, there are alternative search engines that focus on the small web and replicate the early days of searching. I use Mojeek and Marginalia; only if (as frequently happens) they don’t turn up useful results, I resort to DuckDuckGo.
I’m fairly certain I used the WWW via ftp in a high School class in 1992.
I miss the exploration part of the internet. You had to actively find communities that interested you and it felt a lot easier to discover things because the internet was not yet filled with trash. It was like the ocean before all the plastic was dumped into it.
I miss how stimulating it was to go online. You were constantly encouraged to learn to be a part of it. I learned basic HTML and became good enough at it that I could make fun and interactive profiles on different forums. I even made profiles for my friends who didn’t know how to do HTML.
I miss the culture of sharing.
I miss blogging culture and how fun it was to go to someone’s blog and read their newest posts where they shared art they were working on and the process of making it.
It felt meaningful back then.
Nowadays, the internet experience is to be a passive consumer, waiting for the algorithm to feed you something mildly interesting and being so inept at searching for things, exploring and displaying curiosity, that you outsource that part to an AI.
It upsets me how diffucult it has become to find things worthwhile. exploration is discouraged every place you go online. Algorithms work against you. It is isolating.
The internet is bigger than ever, but it has never felt smaller and more claustrophobic.
Short answer: It was owned by itself and the communities that were built upon it, instead of the megacorps.
Not exactly an answer to the question, but something that still exists and has old internet vibes https://neocities.org/
I remember the tail end of the old internet. And no, it was not my MySpace or Reddit. It was forums and it was personal websites. I wouldn’t say it’s better per se but it was definitely more fun. There was no money in the internet and so there was no incentive to market anything. People just did what they wanted. Even companies mainly just had fun stuff on their websites.
On the other hand, damn was it hard to find literally anything. The only way to find new things was through word of mouth.
I miss forums. Vbulletin was brilliant.
Yes we had some trolls, but because those forums were independent sites you didnt get so many people stumbling onto them with ragebait because reddit or facebook thought they could generate friction and call it engagement.
Now the internet literally is just a few websites all showing the same things, forcing conflicting groups together, entrenching opinions, sowing division and delivering confirmation bias by the truckload to everyone. All in the name of profit, milking ‘engagement’ to the preferred ends of whoever has the deepest pockets.
Before reddit/Facebook/MySpace there were personal websites through geocities. Then came ytmnd.
At a certain point there were still videos, but it was QuickTime and realplayer and “buffering” was an annoyance.
Flash player came out and allowed for a renaissance of creative games and movies.
We had all the building blocks for creative expression, with none of the garbage that started growing with digg/reddit.
MyFace! There was also the fact that those of us old enough to have been online saw the first shot at these platforms and they were very different than today. I got into gmail when you had to have an invite. I registered for The Facebook when doing so required a .edu email address.
I remember when QuickTime.com posted the first “HD” movie trailer and it blew my mind.
And shockwave, complete with all the sites that built content for it.
We also got to see digg/reddit when they were still pre-prime. My reddit account is old enough to drive.
To answer OPs question, I suspect there are two things going on.
First, the web of lore was not monetized. Google was very young and actually meant it when they said not to be evil. Steam was just launching. Web 1.0 was performant, no one gave a shit about engagement, search ending optimization didn’t exist, small personal websites had great information, and it was private, although privacy was more of an accident. There were bots, but they were very basic chatbots.
Second, people old enough to remember this era are going to be reminiscing. But I still think the old web was better.
Can us old folk agree that search was rougher for a while though? Northern Light was the best I could recall before Google really blew up.
Pre-google, and even during early-google, search was rough. I was an Altavista for quite some time.
Dogpile was our goto before google got big. It searched altavista, webcrawler, excite , Lycos, jeevesa etc and returned a pile of resiults
My view is that SEO ruined the Internet. Once search results became a thing people gamified it just pushed actually good content out of reach.
Problems of the past could be dealt with, e.g. pop-up ads could be defeated with a pop-up blocker. But you cannot “defeat” not being able to find valuable content in the first place.
And today, with LLMs, it’s actually just outright impossible to search for new things without having a preconception of what your actual destination is.
In those days without sesrch engines, people pass good websites around by meeting each other offline.
We’re getting there again.
Or webrings
The internet used to have moderators. That word means something different today. The internet was better when moderators would ban trolls. They’d ban users being assholes even.
It was better when content was real and genuine. I’m not even talking about AI. Content today is created for purely to push quantity. That’s not to say the quality wasn’t bad before.
I wouldn’t necessarily say it’s the content quantity that’s the problem.
Imo it used to be that content was created because you did something cool and wanted to share the experience, now it’s all about monetizability, how many clicks your content can achieve, how money each clicks generates etc…
There sure a lot of Redditors in the comments shouting their old phrase “it used to be a library”.
During the time they are referencing you had to ask why the information you found was up there and why the book in your local library, not dozens of feet from the desk you sat at, wasn’t.
It was never a library. People just painted over the military comm decals because olive drab lowers sales.
When we say ‘old Internet’, we mean ‘before most people could get on the Internet’. Sorry to say it, but it was people that ruined the Internet. Just people.
I think it was corporate people, specifically.
I remember the first time I looked on a food tin and the company had a website listed, and I thought “Why the fuck would some soup need a website?”.
Back then, a lot of websites were very personal, like “Neil’s web site of things I like” or something, and that website would be some photos of him and his dog, a list of songs he liked, how to run Frontier: Elite II on a modern PC, plus the world’s #1 database of converting imperial and metric bolt sizes.
I miss visiting 3dfiles.com where every day there would be the latest shareware games, tech demos, graphics drivers and screensavers available to download. No bloated reviews or sponsored content, just actual cool software that would put your computer’s hardware to use in a fun way.
https://lem.lemmy.blahaj.zone/pictrs/image/294571ea-4a66-41c7-910a-4a8729fd4c26.webp
Sign in to comment. Sign in