The closest stars are not THAT far away if we can consistently hit 50% the speed of light (solar sails are proposed examples).
Oh but they are!
First, even if we assume that speed is possible, the nearest stars are still practically unreachable for humans, and probes would take a lifetime to return useful information.
To use round numbers, let’s say a one-way trip takes 5 years at light speed and 10 years at 50% c.
That means a round trip would take 20 years at a steady 0.5c. But we don’t get to travel at a steady speed, we have to accelerate and decelerate. So the average speed should be roughly half the top speed. Now we have a 40 year round trip, or “only” 25 years to get signals back from a probe.
And second, our working assumption of consistently hitting 50% the speed of light is wildly optimistic. If we look beyond our spacecraft and satellites to the fastest objects ever created by humans, we are still working with well below 0.1% the speed of light.
If I wave a magic wand and make our speed capabilities 10x, which I think means increasing the power/fuel of our propulsion systems by 100x, we are still looking at well over 1000 years for a one-way probe trip.
The scale of our universe is bonkers, in both the big and the small.
Traveling at these relativistic speeds, laser-powered light sails could reach our nearest neighboring star (other than the Sun), Alpha Centauri, or the nearest known potentially habitable planet, Proxima Centauri b, in about 20 years. Both objects are a little more than four light-years away.
One day in the not-so-distant future, light sails may hurtle through space at speeds of around 20% of the speed of light (or 60,000 km/sec),
Considering how long humans opted to live on wooden ships and many lost their lives in pursuit of discovery, seems increasingly probable humans will be hurling some of ourselves towards these stars.
I’m still holding out for us finding the loophole around c. Even in Star Trek, the speed of light and relativity were a thing you stayed away from, it’s too firm an enforcer. You just move differently, like through a different dimension, or move space itself. Action-reaction just has too many problems with it. Maybe life is all over the place, we’re just too far to see and communicate with each other and we’re all stuck in our bubble of space we can feasibly get to right now, waiting for one of us to connect the dots.
I just hope the Dark Forest isn’t a thing. It unfortunately makes sense.
Comments
Oh but they are!
First, even if we assume that speed is possible, the nearest stars are still practically unreachable for humans, and probes would take a lifetime to return useful information.
To use round numbers, let’s say a one-way trip takes 5 years at light speed and 10 years at 50% c.
That means a round trip would take 20 years at a steady 0.5c. But we don’t get to travel at a steady speed, we have to accelerate and decelerate. So the average speed should be roughly half the top speed. Now we have a 40 year round trip, or “only” 25 years to get signals back from a probe.
And second, our working assumption of consistently hitting 50% the speed of light is wildly optimistic. If we look beyond our spacecraft and satellites to the fastest objects ever created by humans, we are still working with well below 0.1% the speed of light.
If I wave a magic wand and make our speed capabilities 10x, which I think means increasing the power/fuel of our propulsion systems by 100x, we are still looking at well over 1000 years for a one-way probe trip.
The scale of our universe is bonkers, in both the big and the small.
Great exchange!
Did more digging:
https://phys.org/news/2018-09-nanophotonic-relativistic.html
Considering how long humans opted to live on wooden ships and many lost their lives in pursuit of discovery, seems increasingly probable humans will be hurling some of ourselves towards these stars.
I’m still holding out for us finding the loophole around c. Even in Star Trek, the speed of light and relativity were a thing you stayed away from, it’s too firm an enforcer. You just move differently, like through a different dimension, or move space itself. Action-reaction just has too many problems with it. Maybe life is all over the place, we’re just too far to see and communicate with each other and we’re all stuck in our bubble of space we can feasibly get to right now, waiting for one of us to connect the dots.
I just hope the Dark Forest isn’t a thing. It unfortunately makes sense.
Sign in to comment. Sign in