Didnt Kipping have a piece come out that suggested only really G stars may have the conditions and G stars are rarer and have a tighter window of time for formation? I forget exactly but he seemed to dismiss the conditions of other star types. Still, amazing points and exchange. Kipping and his team has not ruled out life, but they are increasingly grappling with the possibility of rare earth hypothesis the more their models and observations come in which is interesting.
One of the things I never thought about until I ran across Rare Earth when it first hit the bookstores… how important some type of turnover for carbon is needed, aka plate tectonics. Never connected something that large scale and “just rocks” being so tied to the balance of carbon and how that seems to affect life. It doesn’t mean that there aren’t other ways, and comes back to the question on if carbon is the only base molecule that makes life possible. It seems the best, silicon is close but has issues, but out of our sample of one it looks to be a key factor.
I wish I had a positive outlook on humanity’s future, as there is so much left to discover. We really haven’t even started yet.
Comments
Didnt Kipping have a piece come out that suggested only really G stars may have the conditions and G stars are rarer and have a tighter window of time for formation? I forget exactly but he seemed to dismiss the conditions of other star types. Still, amazing points and exchange. Kipping and his team has not ruled out life, but they are increasingly grappling with the possibility of rare earth hypothesis the more their models and observations come in which is interesting.
One of the things I never thought about until I ran across Rare Earth when it first hit the bookstores… how important some type of turnover for carbon is needed, aka plate tectonics. Never connected something that large scale and “just rocks” being so tied to the balance of carbon and how that seems to affect life. It doesn’t mean that there aren’t other ways, and comes back to the question on if carbon is the only base molecule that makes life possible. It seems the best, silicon is close but has issues, but out of our sample of one it looks to be a key factor.
I wish I had a positive outlook on humanity’s future, as there is so much left to discover. We really haven’t even started yet.
Beautifully put!
Sign in to comment. Sign in