The plot of the third Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy book is about a civilization that evolved on a planet surrounded by a dense dust cloud, unaware that anything aside from themselves existed. When they discovered the rest of the universe, they were so horrified that they launched a crusade to eliminate all other life rather than accept a reality that contradicted their worldview.
When I first read it, I thought such a civilization was absurd; why would anyone seek to destroy others simply for existing? But I’ve learned a lot about humans and our history since then.
But they wouldn’t move randomly, they’d follow paths through the sky just like our planets do. I don’t think they’d have an extra problem with heliocentrism because it was planetary motion that was the reason we developed it ourselves, the fixed stars didn’t factor into it.
It might be slightly harder to plot the courses of the planets without the stars as references, but they’d still have the ground to provide a reference frame. There were observatories before telescopes were invented and those were basically just giant structural astrolabes for taking precise measurements of the locations of celestial bodies. Tycho Brahe’s Uraniborg is one of the most famous and elaborate, but even Stonehenge and its ilk would have counted. Those would be just as usable in these circumstances.
I was perhaps being a bit flippant with my “if they bother with astronomy at all” comment, I’m sure they’d eventually discover that other stars exist as their technology advanced. I’m just thinking they might not care all that much about it since they’d be so much more out-of-reach.
Comments
Any intelligent species evolving on a planet without visible stars would have such a difficult time figuring out heleocentrism
Plus they probably won’t develop telescopes as quickly. All they can look at are those dopey planets that seemingly move randomly around their Earth
The plot of the third Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy book is about a civilization that evolved on a planet surrounded by a dense dust cloud, unaware that anything aside from themselves existed. When they discovered the rest of the universe, they were so horrified that they launched a crusade to eliminate all other life rather than accept a reality that contradicted their worldview.
When I first read it, I thought such a civilization was absurd; why would anyone seek to destroy others simply for existing? But I’ve learned a lot about humans and our history since then.
But they wouldn’t move randomly, they’d follow paths through the sky just like our planets do. I don’t think they’d have an extra problem with heliocentrism because it was planetary motion that was the reason we developed it ourselves, the fixed stars didn’t factor into it.
It might be slightly harder to plot the courses of the planets without the stars as references, but they’d still have the ground to provide a reference frame. There were observatories before telescopes were invented and those were basically just giant structural astrolabes for taking precise measurements of the locations of celestial bodies. Tycho Brahe’s Uraniborg is one of the most famous and elaborate, but even Stonehenge and its ilk would have counted. Those would be just as usable in these circumstances.
I was perhaps being a bit flippant with my “if they bother with astronomy at all” comment, I’m sure they’d eventually discover that other stars exist as their technology advanced. I’m just thinking they might not care all that much about it since they’d be so much more out-of-reach.
Sign in to comment. Sign in