Comment on John Fetterman Signals Breaking Point With Democrats Over Van Hollen
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
There are no political parties in the united states, on paper. Each representative is free to vote however they like, for whatever reason they like, once they are in office. Some states have a way to recall federal representatives, but not all do.
Unlike parliamentary systems you are not (on paper) voting for a party, who appoints a representative; you are voting specifically for a singular person, who may associate with a party.
Now because 250 years have happened between that idea and how congress actually works, the entirely made up and not constitutionally supported positions of ‘House majority leader’ and ‘Senate Majority leader,’ exist. These positions do not exist in the constitution, and did not exist for most of the country’s history. But these positions are now used to appoint committee assignments, and decide what legislation is voted on (primarily, there are ways to force votes, but that requires a supermajority of representatives agreeing to do that). Again these positions that effectively control how congress functions have no basis in the constitution, did not exist before 1925, and go directly against the purpose of congress and the concept of a political party-free government that the US was designed to be as to not descend into the corruption the founding fathers saw in the house of lords in the UK.
But they’re super important now, because the corruption is too entrenched to get rid of.
well said. the founders specifically wanted to not have political parties. the elected person is supposed to represent the collective will of his constituency, which requires flexibility and an ability to find compromises that on the whole benefit the people without regard to particular ideologies.
The founders understood human nature, which is why we have separation of powers, which has been deliberately subverted over decades.
So what youre saying is we have the perfect Supreme court right now to have someone challenge the inability to table a vote because its not in the constitution and these faithful adherents to it will break the majority minority leader positions? 😂
No that would be in January. If a republican brought this up as a challenge and dems didn’t give the game away that this would be better than the status quo, then SCOTUS would see it as ‘kneecapping’ the incoming congress and would absolutely rule it unconstitutional.
Lol, ya. And then somehow reconsider the ruling 2 years later when the GOP somehow wins a majority again.
Sign in to comment. Sign in