A religion quickly abandons pacifism when offered a shot at the monopoly on the legitimate use of violence. That’s like, a major part of European/Christian history in fact. Christians who love Jesus should treat Constantine as a much more complicated figure than they do.
Correct, and it’s all three of the Abrahamic religions in fact, not just Christianity. Once an organized state is established under the banner of religion, then the teachings of the said religion evolve to rule, inflicting state violence on anything challenging its authority. Saul, the first king of ancient kingdom of Israel wanted to kill all non-Israelite Canaanites in the land by claiming divine commandment, and proceeded to indeed exterminate multiple tribes. Islam’s teachings evolved after Muhammed established a state, from being more about social justice and personal growth initially to becoming a tool in justifying state violence and expansionism. This is why the first and second part of Quran are quite different (and even contradict each other sometimes, heh.)
Constantine? They forgive him, even saintify him, because he is attributed at bringing Christianity to the Roman Imperial Cult through that hallucination of the cross story.
Isn’t generalizing the entirety of Buddhism based on the actions of one or two extremist factions, kind of exactly the same thing as generalizing the entirety of Islam based on the actions of one or two extremist factions?
Looking forward to seeing the mental gymnastics that it will take to claim those two things are in any way different
OP’s post is a reaction to people who react to people who say “all religions are bad” by saying “nuh uh, Buddhists never did anything wrong”. Your experience or lack thereof with such people will dictate whether this feels like a strawman or not.
It is most definitely not a “Buddhism is bad because some Buddhists are bad” argument.
I guess the flaw is already in the wording: (from the post) “Buddhism never did anything problematic”, Buddhism cannot do anything, people can (in the name of Buddhism)
Yeah, it seems any doctrine can be malappropriated by people who never tried to understand it and twisted toward some diabolical purpose. That doesn’t mean the doctrine at its core is flawed.
I’m against religious extremism as much as anyone else. But I’m also against generalizing entire cultures based on the actions of extremist factions. There’s no way to convince me that could be based in anything other than ignorance.
True Believer fundamentalists depend on the moderates to exist.
I’m not an expert on Buddhism, but I know with Abrahamics the moderates finance and enable the fundies (often without knowing), and provide them with a veneer of respectability.
Fundies are by nature parasitic. You can see this with sects of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, all depend on more “practical” donors for financing and support why they do more esoteric things.
If you’re trying to fit eastern religions into a western-religion-shaped shoebox, you’re going to have a very hard time defending your thesis to anyone who’s even modestly informed on the topic.
Yeah, it’s a military coup, and they’re killing Buddhists too. But of course they found some fake buddhists to side with the junta to try to try and lend it some semblance of legitimacy.
So people are latching onto that and trying to say it’s Buddhism’s fault, because I guess that sounds edgy?
It falsely portrays Palestinian resistance and probably the conflicts between Israel and Iran, Israel and Lebanon, and Israel and Yemen as “religious violence”, falsely characterizes increased anti-zionism as “a rising tide of hate crimes against Jews” when these reported increases have come from sources that include pro-Palestine and anti-genocide protests as hate crimes. I don’t know as much about the other things, but I certainly can’t just take their word for it when they’ve shown themselves to be so dishonest and compromised on the Palestine colonial conflict.
And for what it’s worth, their main source for the claim about increased religious conflict is also Pew Research (lol), an American capitalist think tank. And they didn’t even link to the correct article that they seemingly meant to cite.
It literally says “In the United States and Europe”… “and Muslims” - "In the United States and Europe, a rising tide of hate crimes against Jews and Muslims… " - why would you truncate something, take it out of context, to fit only the narrative that you’re interested in??
Anyway, their point is that not having state-religion separation will lead to religious violence. For example, a Jewish state is a problem.
It literally says “According to the Pew Research Center, about one-quarter of countries worldwide exhibit “high” or “very high” levels of social hostilities involving religion, including violent religion-related attacks. We’re seeing this play out globally. A new wave of religious violence across the Middle East commenced with the devastating attack by Hamas against Israel on October 7, 2023. Sectarian conflicts continue to simmer in countries as diverse as India, Indonesia, Nigeria, and Vietnam. In the United States and Europe, a rising tide of hate crimes against Jews and Muslims shows that religious violence is by no means limited to the developing world. As of 2025, possible genocides against communities of faith are unfolding in China and in Myanmar. In many ways, religious violence is surging alongside a broader global resurgence of religion itself.” - why would you truncate something, take it out of context, to fit only the narrative that you’re interested in??
Those parts aren’t relevant to the issue, which was answering your question about the elements of the first paragraph of the article that would tarnish the credibility of the authors and publishers. I didn’t say that every single statement in the paragraph is problematic. I had particular criticisms of particular points. I did not take anything out of any relevant context. It is normal to quote only the relevant part for the sake of clarity and sentence structure. My point stands about the supposed “rising tide of hate crimes against Jews” (in the place where it’s purported to be happening, the United States and Europe, as opposed to some other place where it’s not, if it’s so important to you that I specify this). The increase in hate crimes against Muslims in the West, on the other hand, is much more strongly evidenced.
Anyway, their point is that not having state-religion separation will lead to religious violence. For example, a Jewish state is a problem.
I don’t disagree. The rest of the article is a decent analysis of the harms of state religion, using examples that I guess they aren’t averse to acknowledging. My original statement was (emphasis added):
Wow, that first paragraph really tarnishes the credibility of the MIT Press, its editor, and the authors Nilay Saiya and Stuti Manchanda.
But your example of a Jewish state is yours, and not theirs. Their intentional erasure of the ethnoreligious supremacist nature of the state of Israel and its crimes is especially incredible given it’s followed by an entire article about the harms of state religion.
Religion has mastered one remarkable skill: surviving without evidence. For thousands of years, gods have been proposed, worshiped, feared, obeyed, and defended yet never independently verified. This is not a minor oversight. In every other domain of human knowledge, claims without evidence are discarded. Only in religion are they protected, revered, and shielded from scrutiny.
Atheism begins with a simple, unromantic question: Where is the evidence? Not the feelings, not the traditions, not the anecdotes but the verifiable, testable, independently confirmable evidence. When that question is asked honestly, belief systems that rely on revelation and authority rather than observation begin to wobble.
Faith is often praised as a virtue. In practice, it is an admission of ignorance dressed up as confidence. Faith exists precisely where evidence does not. No one has “faith” that gravity works or that germs cause disease. Those are facts established through experiment and replication. Faith only enters when knowledge fails.
If faith were a reliable path to truth, different religions would converge on the same conclusions. Instead, they contradict one another on every fundamental claim how many gods exist, what they want, who they favour, and what happens after death. Billions of believers, thousands of gods, zero consensus. Why should we treat any one of them as special?
A popular apologetic claim is that religion “invented” science or was its primary driver. History tells a messier story. Scientific progress emerged when thinkers began questioning authority including religious authority and insisting on evidence over scripture.
Copernicus, Galileo, Darwin, and countless others faced religious resistance, not encouragement. The Catholic Church condemned heliocentrism. Protestant leaders rejected evolution. Even today, creationism and intelligent design attempt to smuggle theology into science classrooms despite overwhelming biological evidence to the contrary.
Another common claim is that without God, morality collapses. This argument misunderstands both morality and human behaviour. Moral systems existed long before monotheistic religions and vary widely across cultures. Empathy, cooperation, and fairness are products of social evolution, not divine command.
If morality truly came from God, believers would behave demonstrably better than nonbelievers. They do not. Study after study shows no consistent correlation between religiosity and moral behaviour, and some of the least religious countries score highest on measures of social trust, equality, and well-being.
Prayer is often described as powerful, transformative, and effective until it is tested. Controlled studies consistently show that intercessory prayer has no measurable effect on recovery, illness, or outcomes. In some cases, being told you are prayed for worsens outcomes due to performance anxiety.
If prayer worked the way believers claim, hospitals would replace ICUs with chapels. They do not. Why? Because when lives are on the line, even believers trust medicine, not miracles.
Why is scepticism encouraged everywhere except religion? Why are children taught to question advertisements, politicians, and strangers but not gods? Why is doubt framed as intellectual honesty in science and rebellion in theology?
What would happen if religious claims were held to the same standards as scientific ones? If holy books were treated like hypotheses? If miracles required evidence before belief?
Would anything remain? Atheism Is Not Nihilism It Is Responsibility.
Atheism offers no cosmic rewards, no eternal surveillance, no divine forgiveness loopholes. That is precisely its strength. Meaning is not handed down; it is constructed. Morality is not outsourced; it is owned. There is no god to blame, no plan to hide behind.
If this life is the only one, we know we have, then cruelty is less excusable, not more. Kindness matters now. Justice matters now. Truth matters now.
And that is what makes atheism unsettling not that it removes meaning, but that it removes excuses. If faith is a reliable path to truth, why does it produce contradictory conclusions?
Why are religious claims exempt from the standards applied to every other claim?
If morality comes from God, why do moral intuitions change over time and culture?
What belief would you abandon if evidence disproved it and why should religion be different?
“And if someone did somehow survive death in a non-physical form I personally think he’d be far too busy with other celestial activities than to be standing around paradise smiling down on live people. What kind of a fing eternity is that? And why is it no one ever says, ‘I think he’s down there now smiling up at us’? Apparently it never occurs to people that their loved ones might be in hell. Your parents could be in hell right now. Your parents in hell. Your father for sure. Oh s, hell is full of dads. Full of dads. Even the ones who took you to the ball game just for beating the s*** out of you once too often and messing with the neighbor lady… and the neighbor dog.”
just donations and some innocent communication, not him going to the island
part of epsteinists’ general attempts to get reputation in scientific circles (one of the goals being to spread transphobia among prestigious scientists)
The god of the Abrahamic religions, if he exists, is one needy, desperate, and pathetic motherfucker. I mean that’s gotta be like the most abusive being ever. Love him or he’ll torture you for eternity. If a man put a gun to a woman’s head and demanded she love him or else we’d see him as the monster he is. Yet god does it to all of us and he’s this loving kind being? GTFO.
One of the TST branches got radicalized by a charismatic leader who knew the right buttons to push with her followers, they showed it in the Hail Satan? documentary. There is no religion that won’t have the potential for violence, all you need is a manipulative leader and enough followers who want someone or something other than themselves to come up with rules for how they should live their lives.
Whether they believe in the divine, don’t believe in the divine - people are bad.
But the worst kind of people? People who want to crap on other people because of what they believe or don’t believe. They are truly the worst kind of human beings.
People’s belief in imaginary shit makes me distrust their ability to reason or their foundational grip on reality. I’d never debate or discuss anything meaningfully intellectual with an openly religious person with the expectation of it being anything more than intellectual masturbation at most.
Oo good point! Also pedophiles, and people who don’t return their shopping trolleys, and nazis, and eric from work who killed and ate his neighbor, and my awful 4th grade teacher Mrs McAvity who wanted me to learn learn what hyperbole is (but I sure showed her!) and murderers and…
So a person has been brutally murdered in a bloody horrible way.
Ask that person if they give a crap if the person who killed them did it because their invisible sky daddy told them to, or because they were just pissed off because someone cut them off in traffic, or because they were off their meds.
I’m pretty sure the person who died in bloody, horrible agony isn’t going to give a shit.
You only think religious is murder is bad because you hate religion. Which means it’s more about you than it is about the murder. And I think that says more about you than the person doing the killing.
I’m not religious. Not even in the slightest. Couldn’t pick a church out of a line-up.
I just loathe people who want to blame religion for everything and don’t see the irony of saying “I think people who push their beliefs on others are shitty human beings SO I AM GOING TO FORCE MY BELIEFS ON YOU” and don’t realise how exactly like the people they purport to hate they are.
I truly think this should not need to be so explicitly said, but if I’m brutally murdered in a bloody horrible way, I do want people to find out why it happened so that future murders can be prevented. I think this should be done regardless of the nature of the murderous motivations. It does matter to me that society is improved, actually, even once I’m gone.
I think we should improve society. And that we should (try to) prevent future murders, in so far as it is possible (though - let’s be honest - history doesn’t set much of a precedent for that!).
But I think improving society by telling people that something that gives them comfort in dark times is stupid, dumb and idiotic and shitty is not the best way to make society better. I think that - perhaps - fostering understand between people and not crapping on their beliefs, and just letting people live the lives they want to live might, just perhaps, be a better way.
I think improving society by telling people that something that gives them comfort in dark times is stupid, dumb and idiotic and shitty is not the best way to make society better.
Lol, good thing this isn’t the only argument against religion, then.
I’ve said it once and I’ll say it again, every religion, bar none, has the capacity to become violent. Even one of the TST branches went rogue and started spewing violent rhetoric. All it takes is a charismatic leader who knows how to push the right buttons.
I don’t think they need to do it in the name of Buddha per se, there are many other ways to use religion to get people to become violent. For example, “anyone who isn’t Buddhist is an unenlightened subhuman and needs to be exterminated”, can easily be a path to genocide.
Give me a breakdown, because, yeah… All I know about Buddhism is pretty basic beyond the original story of Sidartha (sp?) because I once took a Buddhist “bible” from a hotel I was staying at since it was pretty novel that the Gideons had left not just King James Christian bibles.
They have good PR but they’re pretty guilty of all sorts of atrocities. Also, Tibet is kind of an interesting one because of course, there’s the concern of self determination, but pre-China Tibet was basically a feudal Buddhist society with rampant exploitation and abuse.
This isn’t a “China good” or “China bad” thing, it’s just a complicated situation that got oversimplified by enthusiastic social awareness campaigns in the 80s.
Insulation from the consequences of ones actions lessens their capacity to fully understand the harm they cause, which makes them more likely to make decisions that harm others in the future
i feel like you probably know that causing harm to other living beings is “against the rules” in Buddhism. My copy of the Dhammapada has an introduction that quotes the Buddha as saying you can’t even support soldiers or butchers (I question what the Buddha said and didn’t say because it was word of mouth and then written down much later… I believe it to be essentially accurate tho). That’s why monks dont even swat mosquitos. Theres a huge rabbit hole to go down here between buddhists, but it would just be distracring to this discussion.
The problem is likely the same problem other religions face: these bad dudes are claiming theyre Buddhists while ignoring the core foundations of the religion. This leads to crusades despite “love they neighbor” or, ya know, suicide bombings.
if everbody were a faithfully practicing buddhist, this world would be a utopia. but im sure thats true in a lot of different ways.
I stand by my beliefs. My relationship with God is mine and mine alone. The problem has never been faith. It’s been the men that then co-opted my faith to serve their religions as defined by them not God.
What if faith is just nostalgia from when you were little and/or converted? It was a time of a more loving, innocent and black and white time. I know this seems like I’m trying to get you to not have faith. *But, if people are better towards their fellow man for any reason, I’m all for it. I’m just kind of *thinking out loud.
No they don’t because my parents aren’t religious and never were and neither am I. That said I don’t even think they believe in God. And to be clear mine is not a Christian God.
Comments
Any belief system will inevitably cause harm when it becomes a governing body- which almost always claims monopoly on violence.
A religion quickly abandons pacifism when offered a shot at the monopoly on the legitimate use of violence. That’s like, a major part of European/Christian history in fact. Christians who love Jesus should treat Constantine as a much more complicated figure than they do.
Correct, and it’s all three of the Abrahamic religions in fact, not just Christianity. Once an organized state is established under the banner of religion, then the teachings of the said religion evolve to rule, inflicting state violence on anything challenging its authority. Saul, the first king of ancient kingdom of Israel wanted to kill all non-Israelite Canaanites in the land by claiming divine commandment, and proceeded to indeed exterminate multiple tribes. Islam’s teachings evolved after Muhammed established a state, from being more about social justice and personal growth initially to becoming a tool in justifying state violence and expansionism. This is why the first and second part of Quran are quite different (and even contradict each other sometimes, heh.)
Constantine? They forgive him, even saintify him, because he is attributed at bringing Christianity to the Roman Imperial Cult through that hallucination of the cross story.
Oh I’m well aware. Many don’t even understand that he exchanged the soul of their religion for power and legitimacy
I can’t help notice they didn’t say “religion”, they said “belief system”
Curious that.
Burma. Buddhist monks chopping up the local Muslims with machetes and piling up their body parts in the streets.
Or forcing the last living member bury the rest of their family in the beaches before getting chopped up themselves.
Yes, this is recent history.
Did they reincarnate as a bug or something? I’m going to guess the aliens would say that doesn’t work because of the size or have they tried that?
Fear leads to religion, religion leads to hate, hate leads to suffering.
Suffering leads to fear
And fear is the mind killer
And Chriss angel is the mindfreak.
And the freak is on a leash
BOOOM GER DUBGAGAG, GER DUBGAGAG, SKREEEEEEEE
And I always strive to do the leash I can do.
CHEEEEEEZITS!!1!
That’s David Blane. And a young Mikey Day. The orange soda was cake.
Fear is the little-death that brings total obliteration
From my perspective, not suffering is evil!
https://i.ytimg.com/vi/9LDh8DefWpI/maxresdefault.jpg
, suffering is required by religion.
[deleted]
You don’t need to go into the past, it’s happening in Myanmar right now.
Edit: For those who don’t know:
Source: https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/monks-behaving-badly-explaining-buddhist-violence-in-asia/ - this an excellent long read on politics and discrimination
What is happening? I only found stuff about Buddhists being oppressed in the recent history.
They’re doing a genocide of Muslims.
Isn’t generalizing the entirety of Buddhism based on the actions of one or two extremist factions, kind of exactly the same thing as generalizing the entirety of Islam based on the actions of one or two extremist factions?
Looking forward to seeing the mental gymnastics that it will take to claim those two things are in any way different
They aren’t? That’s why we don’t say all Muslims are the same as the Taliban or all Christians the same as MAGA.
OP’s post is a reaction to people who react to people who say “all religions are bad” by saying “nuh uh, Buddhists never did anything wrong”. Your experience or lack thereof with such people will dictate whether this feels like a strawman or not.
It is most definitely not a “Buddhism is bad because some Buddhists are bad” argument.
I guess the flaw is already in the wording: (from the post) “Buddhism never did anything problematic”, Buddhism cannot do anything, people can (in the name of Buddhism)
Yeah, it seems any doctrine can be malappropriated by people who never tried to understand it and twisted toward some diabolical purpose. That doesn’t mean the doctrine at its core is flawed.
I’m against religious extremism as much as anyone else. But I’m also against generalizing entire cultures based on the actions of extremist factions. There’s no way to convince me that could be based in anything other than ignorance.
Not really.
True Believer fundamentalists depend on the moderates to exist.
I’m not an expert on Buddhism, but I know with Abrahamics the moderates finance and enable the fundies (often without knowing), and provide them with a veneer of respectability.
Fundies are by nature parasitic. You can see this with sects of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, all depend on more “practical” donors for financing and support why they do more esoteric things.
If you’re trying to fit eastern religions into a western-religion-shaped shoebox, you’re going to have a very hard time defending your thesis to anyone who’s even modestly informed on the topic.
Who exactly? Wasn’t there a military coup? What is the connection to Buddhism?
Yeah, it’s a military coup, and they’re killing Buddhists too. But of course they found some fake buddhists to side with the junta to try to try and lend it some semblance of legitimacy.
So people are latching onto that and trying to say it’s Buddhism’s fault, because I guess that sounds edgy?
https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/monks-behaving-badly-explaining-buddhist-violence-in-asia/
Wow, that first paragraph really tarnishes the credibility of the MIT Press, its editor, and the authors Nilay Saiya and Stuti Manchanda.
Care to elaborate?
I do hope this is already very apparent, but:
It falsely portrays Palestinian resistance and probably the conflicts between Israel and Iran, Israel and Lebanon, and Israel and Yemen as “religious violence”, falsely characterizes increased anti-zionism as “a rising tide of hate crimes against Jews” when these reported increases have come from sources that include pro-Palestine and anti-genocide protests as hate crimes. I don’t know as much about the other things, but I certainly can’t just take their word for it when they’ve shown themselves to be so dishonest and compromised on the Palestine colonial conflict.
And for what it’s worth, their main source for the claim about increased religious conflict is also Pew Research (lol), an American capitalist think tank. And they didn’t even link to the correct article that they seemingly meant to cite.
It literally says “In the United States and Europe”… “and Muslims” - "In the United States and Europe, a rising tide of hate crimes against Jews and Muslims… " - why would you truncate something, take it out of context, to fit only the narrative that you’re interested in??
Anyway, their point is that not having state-religion separation will lead to religious violence. For example, a Jewish state is a problem.
It literally says “According to the Pew Research Center, about one-quarter of countries worldwide exhibit “high” or “very high” levels of social hostilities involving religion, including violent religion-related attacks. We’re seeing this play out globally. A new wave of religious violence across the Middle East commenced with the devastating attack by Hamas against Israel on October 7, 2023. Sectarian conflicts continue to simmer in countries as diverse as India, Indonesia, Nigeria, and Vietnam. In the United States and Europe, a rising tide of hate crimes against Jews and Muslims shows that religious violence is by no means limited to the developing world. As of 2025, possible genocides against communities of faith are unfolding in China and in Myanmar. In many ways, religious violence is surging alongside a broader global resurgence of religion itself.” - why would you truncate something, take it out of context, to fit only the narrative that you’re interested in??
Those parts aren’t relevant to the issue, which was answering your question about the elements of the first paragraph of the article that would tarnish the credibility of the authors and publishers. I didn’t say that every single statement in the paragraph is problematic. I had particular criticisms of particular points. I did not take anything out of any relevant context. It is normal to quote only the relevant part for the sake of clarity and sentence structure. My point stands about the supposed “rising tide of hate crimes against Jews” (in the place where it’s purported to be happening, the United States and Europe, as opposed to some other place where it’s not, if it’s so important to you that I specify this). The increase in hate crimes against Muslims in the West, on the other hand, is much more strongly evidenced.
I don’t disagree. The rest of the article is a decent analysis of the harms of state religion, using examples that I guess they aren’t averse to acknowledging. My original statement was (emphasis added):
But your example of a Jewish state is yours, and not theirs. Their intentional erasure of the ethnoreligious supremacist nature of the state of Israel and its crimes is especially incredible given it’s followed by an entire article about the harms of state religion.
*the past
*it’s
And you forgot the period at the end of your sentence
(just to be very clear, I’m not disagreeing or anything like that).
Thanks
i’m sure the comments here will be wonderful and not devolve into mad ramblings after two or three exchanges.
Religion has mastered one remarkable skill: surviving without evidence. For thousands of years, gods have been proposed, worshiped, feared, obeyed, and defended yet never independently verified. This is not a minor oversight. In every other domain of human knowledge, claims without evidence are discarded. Only in religion are they protected, revered, and shielded from scrutiny. Atheism begins with a simple, unromantic question: Where is the evidence? Not the feelings, not the traditions, not the anecdotes but the verifiable, testable, independently confirmable evidence. When that question is asked honestly, belief systems that rely on revelation and authority rather than observation begin to wobble. Faith is often praised as a virtue. In practice, it is an admission of ignorance dressed up as confidence. Faith exists precisely where evidence does not. No one has “faith” that gravity works or that germs cause disease. Those are facts established through experiment and replication. Faith only enters when knowledge fails. If faith were a reliable path to truth, different religions would converge on the same conclusions. Instead, they contradict one another on every fundamental claim how many gods exist, what they want, who they favour, and what happens after death. Billions of believers, thousands of gods, zero consensus. Why should we treat any one of them as special? A popular apologetic claim is that religion “invented” science or was its primary driver. History tells a messier story. Scientific progress emerged when thinkers began questioning authority including religious authority and insisting on evidence over scripture. Copernicus, Galileo, Darwin, and countless others faced religious resistance, not encouragement. The Catholic Church condemned heliocentrism. Protestant leaders rejected evolution. Even today, creationism and intelligent design attempt to smuggle theology into science classrooms despite overwhelming biological evidence to the contrary. Another common claim is that without God, morality collapses. This argument misunderstands both morality and human behaviour. Moral systems existed long before monotheistic religions and vary widely across cultures. Empathy, cooperation, and fairness are products of social evolution, not divine command. If morality truly came from God, believers would behave demonstrably better than nonbelievers. They do not. Study after study shows no consistent correlation between religiosity and moral behaviour, and some of the least religious countries score highest on measures of social trust, equality, and well-being. Prayer is often described as powerful, transformative, and effective until it is tested. Controlled studies consistently show that intercessory prayer has no measurable effect on recovery, illness, or outcomes. In some cases, being told you are prayed for worsens outcomes due to performance anxiety. If prayer worked the way believers claim, hospitals would replace ICUs with chapels. They do not. Why? Because when lives are on the line, even believers trust medicine, not miracles. Why is scepticism encouraged everywhere except religion? Why are children taught to question advertisements, politicians, and strangers but not gods? Why is doubt framed as intellectual honesty in science and rebellion in theology? What would happen if religious claims were held to the same standards as scientific ones? If holy books were treated like hypotheses? If miracles required evidence before belief? Would anything remain? Atheism Is Not Nihilism It Is Responsibility. Atheism offers no cosmic rewards, no eternal surveillance, no divine forgiveness loopholes. That is precisely its strength. Meaning is not handed down; it is constructed. Morality is not outsourced; it is owned. There is no god to blame, no plan to hide behind. If this life is the only one, we know we have, then cruelty is less excusable, not more. Kindness matters now. Justice matters now. Truth matters now. And that is what makes atheism unsettling not that it removes meaning, but that it removes excuses. If faith is a reliable path to truth, why does it produce contradictory conclusions? Why are religious claims exempt from the standards applied to every other claim? If morality comes from God, why do moral intuitions change over time and culture? What belief would you abandon if evidence disproved it and why should religion be different?
https://feddit.uk/pictrs/image/e1143cf6-3e82-4492-b006-100460bc9fbc.webp
[deleted]
“And if someone did somehow survive death in a non-physical form I personally think he’d be far too busy with other celestial activities than to be standing around paradise smiling down on live people. What kind of a fing eternity is that? And why is it no one ever says, ‘I think he’s down there now smiling up at us’? Apparently it never occurs to people that their loved ones might be in hell. Your parents could be in hell right now. Your parents in hell. Your father for sure. Oh s, hell is full of dads. Full of dads. Even the ones who took you to the ball game just for beating the s*** out of you once too often and messing with the neighbor lady… and the neighbor dog.”
https://feddit.uk/pictrs/image/9dc151c1-0691-4744-b47c-e6676fb4b3e7.webp
A genius.
Really sucks that that beautiful sentiment was said by a guy who visited pedo island
wasnt it
correct me if im wrong
Can’t even quote him anywhere now, lol
Amituofo
Religion is an interesting thing. It can inspire humanity to the greatest heights. Or send humanity to the greatest depths of depravity.
Perhaps it is not religion that is bad. But humanity in general that is the problem.
Or perhaps it actually is religion that is bad, in addition to many other things also being bad. But not humanity in general that is the problem.
Perhaps the problem is actually geese.
Or thinking.
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.
Much to ponder.
Bad people do bad things.
Religion makes good people do bad things.
So does greed. So does love. So do drugs.
So do Black Friday sales.
Drugs is similar. If anybody those other things make you do evil deeds, then you’re a bad person.
The god of the Abrahamic religions, if he exists, is one needy, desperate, and pathetic motherfucker. I mean that’s gotta be like the most abusive being ever. Love him or he’ll torture you for eternity. If a man put a gun to a woman’s head and demanded she love him or else we’d see him as the monster he is. Yet god does it to all of us and he’s this loving kind being? GTFO.
Satanism is pretty chill (not Levayan)
One of the TST branches got radicalized by a charismatic leader who knew the right buttons to push with her followers, they showed it in the Hail Satan? documentary. There is no religion that won’t have the potential for violence, all you need is a manipulative leader and enough followers who want someone or something other than themselves to come up with rules for how they should live their lives.
If those kids could read Chinese they’d be very upset.
People are bad.
Whether they believe in the divine, don’t believe in the divine - people are bad.
But the worst kind of people? People who want to crap on other people because of what they believe or don’t believe. They are truly the worst kind of human beings.
People’s belief in imaginary shit makes me distrust their ability to reason or their foundational grip on reality. I’d never debate or discuss anything meaningfully intellectual with an openly religious person with the expectation of it being anything more than intellectual masturbation at most.
You should have more faith in them.
Why?
No, pretty sure rapists are worse…
E: Sexual predators in general*
Oo good point! Also pedophiles, and people who don’t return their shopping trolleys, and nazis, and eric from work who killed and ate his neighbor, and my awful 4th grade teacher Mrs McAvity who wanted me to learn learn what hyperbole is (but I sure showed her!) and murderers and…
bro really tried to sneak in nazis /s
No, they were specifically defending religious people.
No, the worst kind of human beings are people who murder because their imaginary friend said it’s OK. Murder is definitely worse.
In fact, there are many atrocities committed in the name of various gods that are far worse than people who call out believers for being illogical.
So a person has been brutally murdered in a bloody horrible way.
Ask that person if they give a crap if the person who killed them did it because their invisible sky daddy told them to, or because they were just pissed off because someone cut them off in traffic, or because they were off their meds.
I’m pretty sure the person who died in bloody, horrible agony isn’t going to give a shit.
You only think religious is murder is bad because you hate religion. Which means it’s more about you than it is about the murder. And I think that says more about you than the person doing the killing.
ok buddy
That’s gotta be the funniest shit I’ve seen a reactionary say in a while
Yeah its a pretty clear indicator that this conversation is no longer worth having.
Do you want to know the funniest part?
I’m not religious. Not even in the slightest. Couldn’t pick a church out of a line-up.
I just loathe people who want to blame religion for everything and don’t see the irony of saying “I think people who push their beliefs on others are shitty human beings SO I AM GOING TO FORCE MY BELIEFS ON YOU” and don’t realise how exactly like the people they purport to hate they are.
I truly think this should not need to be so explicitly said, but if I’m brutally murdered in a bloody horrible way, I do want people to find out why it happened so that future murders can be prevented. I think this should be done regardless of the nature of the murderous motivations. It does matter to me that society is improved, actually, even once I’m gone.
I think we should improve society. And that we should (try to) prevent future murders, in so far as it is possible (though - let’s be honest - history doesn’t set much of a precedent for that!).
But I think improving society by telling people that something that gives them comfort in dark times is stupid, dumb and idiotic and shitty is not the best way to make society better. I think that - perhaps - fostering understand between people and not crapping on their beliefs, and just letting people live the lives they want to live might, just perhaps, be a better way.
Lol, good thing this isn’t the only argument against religion, then.
Removing a comfortable lie is a crucial step to improving society. Once you realize that this life is it you’re far more motivated to improve things.
[removed by a moderator]
Your last sentence dips into the exact sort of mindset that makes the events in your first paragraph possible.
[removed by a moderator]
I’ve said it once and I’ll say it again, every religion, bar none, has the capacity to become violent. Even one of the TST branches went rogue and started spewing violent rhetoric. All it takes is a charismatic leader who knows how to push the right buttons.
There are looooots of examples of buddhist temples being the source of rebellions and coups
I only know the broad strokes of Chinese history.
Where Buddhists doing things in the name of Buddah or was it just more cultural.
Like the partition in India is very clearly drawn on religious lines but it’s a bit different than the Crusades I would think.
Partition involves Hindus and Muslims mostly.
But yeah everywhere it is the same playbook, religion used to justify horrendous things
I don’t think they need to do it in the name of Buddha per se, there are many other ways to use religion to get people to become violent. For example, “anyone who isn’t Buddhist is an unenlightened subhuman and needs to be exterminated”, can easily be a path to genocide.
Give me a breakdown, because, yeah… All I know about Buddhism is pretty basic beyond the original story of Sidartha (sp?) because I once took a Buddhist “bible” from a hotel I was staying at since it was pretty novel that the Gideons had left not just King James Christian bibles.
More recent: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rohingya_genocide
They have good PR but they’re pretty guilty of all sorts of atrocities. Also, Tibet is kind of an interesting one because of course, there’s the concern of self determination, but pre-China Tibet was basically a feudal Buddhist society with rampant exploitation and abuse.
This isn’t a “China good” or “China bad” thing, it’s just a complicated situation that got oversimplified by enthusiastic social awareness campaigns in the 80s.
[deleted]
People given power will likely abuse that power, even without ill intent.
Insulation from the consequences of ones actions lessens their capacity to fully understand the harm they cause, which makes them more likely to make decisions that harm others in the future
i feel like you probably know that causing harm to other living beings is “against the rules” in Buddhism. My copy of the Dhammapada has an introduction that quotes the Buddha as saying you can’t even support soldiers or butchers (I question what the Buddha said and didn’t say because it was word of mouth and then written down much later… I believe it to be essentially accurate tho). That’s why monks dont even swat mosquitos. Theres a huge rabbit hole to go down here between buddhists, but it would just be distracring to this discussion.
The problem is likely the same problem other religions face: these bad dudes are claiming theyre Buddhists while ignoring the core foundations of the religion. This leads to crusades despite “love they neighbor” or, ya know, suicide bombings.
if everbody were a faithfully practicing buddhist, this world would be a utopia. but im sure thats true in a lot of different ways.
Faith does not require religion.
Religion requires faith.
Faith was not invented by man.
Religion was invented by man.
Man is flawed.
I stand by my beliefs. My relationship with God is mine and mine alone. The problem has never been faith. It’s been the men that then co-opted my faith to serve their religions as defined by them not God.
What if faith is just nostalgia from when you were little and/or converted? It was a time of a more loving, innocent and black and white time. I know this seems like I’m trying to get you to not have faith. *But, if people are better towards their fellow man for any reason, I’m all for it. I’m just kind of *thinking out loud.
*need coffee
For me its a simple comfort in that which we can’t explain or prove. I would argue in it’s purest faith is simply philosophical.
The universe is irrational. There’s nothing wrong with people trying to make sense and comfort out of something so existentially scary lol
Those other people, they follow a tainted and corrupted version of the perfect and pure religion that you happen to have stumbled upon.
The problem is that you are exactly such a person from the point of view of those corrupted impure men.
[deleted]
Your parents practice the same religion. Never done the math on that huh
No they don’t because my parents aren’t religious and never were and neither am I. That said I don’t even think they believe in God. And to be clear mine is not a Christian God.
🙄🙄
I’m not getting your intent here. You aren’t happy that someone can have faith?
What are they talking about? Wasn’t Buddhism oppressed in most of Chinese history?
Oppressed never become oppressors. That’s why Israel’s neighbours are all friends with them
I understand how you read my comment, but it really just was a honest question.
Fair, my bad.
No idea, but Rohingyas for example are heavily oppressed by Buddhists.
[deleted]
Sign in to comment. Sign in