Skip to content

Comment on Same-sex *rule*ationship

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • Even if gov may fund hrt and (again - poorly made) surgeries… still terrible place.

    Even a minimal possible gain for transfem, at cost of dealing with gay bros? Much nope!

    5
    • Is it even a gain for transfem people? Forcing transfem people to choose between bottom surgery or execution is horrific. Informed consent is impossible like this.

      2
      • Agree, sorry for poorly wording of mine.

        3
      • With a 40% suicide rate for not transitioning, I think yes

        2
        • Uh, are you sure the rate is this high? I have heard this figure too but I recall hearing it’s not about successful suicides (i.e. suicide rate) but about something broader involving suicides. Rate of suicidial ideation/contemplation maybe? Not sure.

          Regardless, mandatory SRS will make many transfem people choose not to legally transition. That’s why similar laws in western nations (albeit only mandating SRS for legally changing official gender) were/are so awful.

          I guess only criminalizing some transfems instead of all transfems is better but like only by a hair.

          0
          • I hear that suicidal ideation was 80%, and suicide attempts were 40%, successful suicides will be a little lower. Substantially lower with puberty blockers / HRT / surgeries.

            Mandating surgery is still bad though, taking away people’s bodily autonomy is always bad.

            2

Sign in to comment. Sign in