I appreciate this isn’t perfect and could be exploited but what is a realistic alternative for getting young people into work? Currently many young people have no prospects which is terrible in all ways for them and the government. I don’t know what would be a better alternative
If we are going to be paying the wages, which we are with this system, then shouldn’t we try and get some benefits to society as a whole rather than only benefiting some shareholders?
Cleaning parks, cutting back overgrown pathways, removing rubbish on beaches, delivering NHS prescriptions for people with mobility issues.
All things you can learn on the job and as taxpayers are paying for it shouldn’t we benefit from it too?
Well, we benefit from it as a society. The point isn’t to give the people concerned something to do, it’s to get them on the jobs ladder.
I think you’re right to be concerned that this could be exploited by companies to get free labour, so hopefully it will be properly implemented to prevent that and make sure the only companies who are participating are actually going to give them proper full-time work at the end of the 6 month period.
That could be another good option. I guess my only concer about that is if businesses would see that community work as work experience on a CV. Hence being more likely to be hired.
My feeling is part of govs plan is to offer young people a “foot in the door” and actually show an employer they are competent. With the hope being they’d get hired out right afterwards.
I was out of uni 3 years back and found it difficult to get my first job at a level I studied for since I didn’t have 3 years work experience (you know, cause I was in uni). I settled for something below my qualification but was lucky to be offered a position I actually studied for a year later. Maybe this scheme offers a similar trajectory?
Edit: to be clear, I think your suggestion should be another choice people could make. Also, clearly working in NHS or doing admin for a council could be a foot in the door to work there or otherwise looks decent on a CV.
With the hope being they’d get hired out right afterwards.
The reverse happened last time. Employers fired employees they were paying and got free workers paid for by the government. I guess this version of the system is slightly less shit in that the worker at least gets minimum wage. But that does also make it more expensive.
Comments
I appreciate this isn’t perfect and could be exploited but what is a realistic alternative for getting young people into work? Currently many young people have no prospects which is terrible in all ways for them and the government. I don’t know what would be a better alternative
If we are going to be paying the wages, which we are with this system, then shouldn’t we try and get some benefits to society as a whole rather than only benefiting some shareholders?
Cleaning parks, cutting back overgrown pathways, removing rubbish on beaches, delivering NHS prescriptions for people with mobility issues.
All things you can learn on the job and as taxpayers are paying for it shouldn’t we benefit from it too?
Well, we benefit from it as a society. The point isn’t to give the people concerned something to do, it’s to get them on the jobs ladder.
I think you’re right to be concerned that this could be exploited by companies to get free labour, so hopefully it will be properly implemented to prevent that and make sure the only companies who are participating are actually going to give them proper full-time work at the end of the 6 month period.
That could be another good option. I guess my only concer about that is if businesses would see that community work as work experience on a CV. Hence being more likely to be hired.
My feeling is part of govs plan is to offer young people a “foot in the door” and actually show an employer they are competent. With the hope being they’d get hired out right afterwards.
I was out of uni 3 years back and found it difficult to get my first job at a level I studied for since I didn’t have 3 years work experience (you know, cause I was in uni). I settled for something below my qualification but was lucky to be offered a position I actually studied for a year later. Maybe this scheme offers a similar trajectory?
Edit: to be clear, I think your suggestion should be another choice people could make. Also, clearly working in NHS or doing admin for a council could be a foot in the door to work there or otherwise looks decent on a CV.
The reverse happened last time. Employers fired employees they were paying and got free workers paid for by the government. I guess this version of the system is slightly less shit in that the worker at least gets minimum wage. But that does also make it more expensive.
Fair enough, there will be ways this could be exploited. I just wonder how you’d mitigate against that more?
If you make public sector work for them at least you can ensure there is public benefit from it.
What could your local council do with some guaranteed “free” labour that is paid for by central government?
Sign in to comment. Sign in