Skip to content

Comment on rule

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • I have clear, vivid memories from my childhood related to my trans experience, so that argument has never held water for me. At 6, watching Beetlejuice and wanting to wear the red dress Lydia wears near the end (with the lace sleeves). At 8, having just watched Pinocchio and wishing upon the first star I saw that night that I’d wake up in the morning as a girl. At 10, being extremely upset that my body was growing so large so fast that I could no longer perch on most furniture items without damaging them.

    I truly believe people like them have forgotten their own childhoods.

    50
    • For people who aren’t trans, they don’t have acute memories of wishing they were different the experience of being comfortable doesn’t stand out, so isn’t memorable.

      10
      • People who aren’t trans forget their childhoods because they weren’t trans? What are you saying?

        0
        • Certain aspects of trans kids’ childhood is much more memorable than the corresponding experience in non-trans kids’ childhoods. It’s not about general forgetfulness of childhood.

          4
          • Let’s take a step back and re-examine the logical sequence here.

            1. Kid has experiences
            2. Kid grows into an adult and has kids
            3. Adult suggests kids don’t understand a thing
            4. I have memories of understanding that thing from a young age
            5. I believe adults who think children don’t understand or remember things have some kind of issue where they forget their own childhood because trans or not, they experienced things they should remember and for some reason they don’t and think kids are fuckin’ stupid or something.

            The trans aspect just happens to be my personal example, but it’s an attitude I’ve seen all my life from adults about a variety of subjects.

            4
            • Fair enough. I only had a particular explanation for that scenario. I think it does explain that one very well, without there being any kind of particular “issue” - people who don’t share your experience don’t remember their understanding as children because there was no reason to, so it’s hard for them to believe.

              Maybe it also applies to the other things you had in mind, but maybe not.

              1
              Continue this thread 4 more replies
    • people like them have forgotten their own childhoods.

      Depends the person. But overall, bigots do recall oppressing/bullying other kids because [insert reason for bigotry]. Tailed guardian here is no different.

      7
    • Mikey’s dad isn’t talking about trans kids. He’s saying cis kids can’t understand trans people, so teachers shouldn’t tell cis kids that trans people exist.

      4

Sign in to comment. Sign in