Skip to content

Comment on Sheinbaum signs reform requiring sole Mexican nationality for presidency and governorships

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • @wheezy@lemmy.ml· · edited

    I think some leftist have a misunderstanding of the use of nationalism within states outside of the imperial core. The IRA was a nationalist movement. Nationalism means something different when you’re colonized. It means something different when the fascist are your neighbors, bombing civilian ships in the waters to your south, and interfering with elections everywhere they can. If Cuba or Iran felt that had to do something similar I think we’d all understand. Let’s not confuse things because we don’t understand the meaning of the word “nationalism” and try to apply it universally to mean “bad”. That’s not material analysis. That’s idealism.

    0
    • I think Americans often have a very bad understanding of the IRA and The Troubles, but your point stands. Though I still think all forms of nationalism are bad, they exist on very different terms and are orders of magnitude worse for colonisers.

      1
      • @RedWizard@hexbear.net· · edited

        Liberatory Nationalism, which is the form of nationalism that emancipated Vietnam, China, Russia, Cuba, and countless other socialist states past and present, is undeniably very different from right-wing nationalism. Nationalism at the periphery is how we get anti-imperialist movements; fighting for your nation’s autonomy over its own borders and internal dealings is a highly progressive form of nationalism. Nationalism within the colonizer states gets you modern-day USA, France, UK, Israel, and historical manifestations like Nazi Germany. So, therefore, nationalism in this context is about either the preservation of the status quo, in the case of settler-colonial nationalism, or about dismantling the status quo, in the case of liberator nationalism.

        Ho Chi Minh has probably the sharpest thesis on liberatory nationalism within his texts, but I think you don’t have to look much farther than the Vietnamese declaration of independence.

        Later in life, he would write this: “At first, patriotism, not yet communism, led me to have confidence in Lenin, in the Third International. Step by step, along the struggle, by studying Marxism-Leninism parallel with participation in practical activities, I gradually came upon the fact that only socialism and communism can liberate the oppressed nations and the working people throughout the world from slavery.”

        His patriotism, his nationalism, is what drew him into the struggle against colonial forces. I find it incredibly reductionist to lump both forms of nationalism together under one umbrella as you’ve done, and history shows us there is a clear difference.

        1
      • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CkbSYIyzmF0

        watch this video, it will help you understand why the position you’re taking is a reactionary right wing one. essentially the left is both internationalist and nationalist, it’s internationalism supports the nationalism and sovereignty of other nations, while the right is simply nationalist and it doesn’t support the nationalism of other people.

        1

Sign in to comment. Sign in